Based on 193 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
131 E Broad St, Nanticoke, PA 18634
Phone: (570) 735-1234
Website: https://martyspizzeria.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | 3–9 PM |
| Thursday | 3–9 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 3–9 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Casey
Giving 2 stars because the food was absolutely excellent and delicious but the service was probably the worst service I’ve ever experienced. There were 8 of us and we asked for separate checks before we ordered (as we always do when we go out as a group). The food came out one by one with 15 minutes in between each order. We have never experienced that. I have worked as a waitress and never served a table like that, even with separate checks. The food all should’ve come out together with appetizers first and then entrees. We didn’t complain because we all have worked in some type of food service but the icing on the cake was when our waitress came over and said “Sorry guys. That’s what happens when you want separate checks.” She sounded very rude as if we complained which again we did not say anything. It was an excuse too because some of the entrees came out before others appetizers so I think she did not put the tickets in properly. I also asked for jumbo lump crabmeat on my chicken piccata which was listed as $12 so I figured I would be given a good scoop of crab meat. I was given two little pieces of crab meat. My friends even said to me “Didn’t you ask for crab meat? Where is it?”. It was not a great experience and we probably won’t go back if that’s how they operate.
… more
Denise Devine
The food was fantastic. Served hot with good portion sizes. There’s a bar and seating area. Friendly bartender/server and clean surroundings. Was too hot for us to sit outside, but the patio looked cute.
… more
Thomas Macri
Stopped for pizza at Marty’s, which was our first visit. Pizza was unique and was very tasty, thin and crispy. The service was excellent and provided by a very friendly server. It is a smaller bar type establishment with tables around a large bar area. It was a very enjoyable and satisfying dining experience.
… more
Maegan Zielinski
We thought this place had delicious food. I got the crab cake sandwich (crab burger) which was cooked just right. It comes with fries, they are hand cut and fried crispy. I would ask if the had vinegar next time for them! My friends got the French onion burger and I only heard good things from them. We also tried the garlic knots and farmers cheese pierogi. Our server was really nice and kind but a little distracted. Its affordable and they also have outside seating. Full bar inside!
… more
Natalie harth
I ordered for pick up their Buffalo wing pizza and it was good. I asked and they added blue cheese and extra hot sauce to it. The counter girl answering the phone was helpful and polite. The bar area is clean and well kept and from what I saw a great spot to grab drinks with friends. They have a lot of variety of drinks to chose from and have three tv screens one playing the game that was on that particular night and other shows and movies playing.
… more
Kurt Offal
Catered through Marty’s and was blown away by service food and location. Ordered a lot on what i consider short notice and they came through. Everything homemade and from scratch and everything was delicious. Thick juicy pork chips, chicken parm and meatballs, piggies and pierogi and more… all amazing. They put out a really nice cheese plate and a pickle tray that still has us talking about the tomatoes. Staff couldnt have been nicer or friendlier, and were respectful throughout. Great communication from start to end and accommodated all our requests. Location in the bar and dining room was cozy and intimate; we had some guests not attend but would have been perfect for about 20 people.
… more
Mike Konetski
Well all i can say is we had a another great sweet sauce pizza. Great job and keep up the good work. Looks great and tastes great. Thanks again.
… more
Marissa Costello
The penne alla vodka, garlic bread and salad was amazing!
… more
Charlie Galinski
Great food, the eggplant was out of this world good highly recommend great pizza too.
… more
D L
Nice little pizza joint. The food was fresh, didn’t take long to come out and was tasty. Service was friendly!
… more
… View more