Mary Zifer’s Pizza in New Philly Menu – New Philadelphia, OH

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : New Philadelphia, OH

Based on 170 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $

✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Mary Zifer's Pizza in New Philly 44663

Address:
145 2nd St NW, New Philadelphia, OH 44663

Phone: (330) 343-1188

Website:

Hours

Wednesday 11 AM–10 PM
Thursday 11 AM–10 PM
Friday 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday 11 AM–10 PM
Sunday 4–10 PM
Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed

Menu

Pizza
Cheese $7.80
Meat & Cheese $8.30
Cheese & Green Peppers $8.10
Cheese, Gr Pepper, & Mushrooms $8.60
Meat, Cheese & Gr Pepper $8.60
Meat, Cheese, Gr Pepper & Mushrooms $9.10
Meat, Cheese, & Mushrooms $4.40
Cheese & Mushrooms $8.30
Low Fat (No Meat Or Cheese)
gr peppers, mushrooms, onions & hot peppers		 $9.10
Additional Toppings
hamburger, sausage, onions, hot peppers gr olives, black olives & anchovies		 $0.60
Pizza Subs
Cheese $2.45
Meat & Cheese $2.65
Meat, Cheese, Gr Pepper $2.80
Meat, Cheese, & Mushrooms $2.90
Meat, Cheese, Mushrooms, Gr Pepper $3.10
Cheese & Mushrooms $2.65
Cheese & Gr Peppers $2.55
Cheese, Mushrooms, Gr Peppers $2.85
Meatball Subs
Plain (No Cheese) $3.80
Splash (With Cheese) $4.10
Spaghetti & Rigatoni
Single $4.25
Family Size $9.00
Salads
Salads
house (vinaigrette) or sweet & sour dressings,		 $4.00
Breadsticks
Breadsticks $3.50

… View more

Reviews

Katie B
Crunchy crust is really good. They use Colby cheese but have mozzarella if you want that instead. And they only take cash or check. Yummy pizza! I included a picture of their menu which is current as of 2/24/2023.

… more

clarence kennedy
Absolutely amazing pizza! It’s the crust that I keep coming back for. Well and the cheesy bread.

… more

David McLaughlin
I grew up on this pizza. One of the best around. Pickup and cash only. Worth it!

… more

Martin Clinton
Zifer’s is always on our list of stops when we’re back home. Great pizza.

… more

Jaime Mansfield
First time to place an order, so I went to pick it up. At the counter I saw a carry-out menu & noticed there was only one in the clear acrylic display rack, actually asked if she had more. She said no but most people just take a picture of it on their cell phone. ☺️ Pizza flavor was good, but I didn’t like the spicy sausage. I didn’t know their crust was going to be so hard and it left a crumby mess. But, I would try them again. I’m all for supporting small businesses that are not chains.

… more

Chase Blackwell
I have loved this pizza my whole life. Always good service. And the price meets the quality of the food. The homemade dressing is amazing!

… more

Mike Wegener
Great food and fantastic prices. The cusine is authentic Italian. Portions are very generous. The staff are friendly Our waitress was absolutely awesome. She went above and beyond our expectations.

… more

Sara A
My family ordered a couple pizzas tonight. We are regulars so we know what to expect. The pizza was so bad tonight it literally tasted like someone had sat on our pies and used them to tube down the Ohio river.

… more

nicole Vance
Loved the pizza first time having it

… more

shawn adorno
Very nice staff.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch