Italian favorites dished up in a casual, warm atmosphere with dark-wood decor & cozy booths. Based on 523 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
611 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735
Phone: (516) 586-5917
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ben
Liz was attentive and patient. We enjoyed all the food. The calamari was larger than expected.
… more
K silly Di
My husband and I had the southwest gourmet burger. All I can say is oh my! The burger is huge, has avocado, onion, cheese, tomato, lettuce and iole sauce. This one brings the hunch out. So delicious and satisfying. Choice of fries or grilled veggies. I had the veggies and they are delicious cooked nicely with a taste of garlic oil. If you haven’t had Mary’s gourmet burger you are missing out.
… more
TRUEST HEART
I thought the cheese, mozzarella was taffy like without taste, the crust and sauce was great? The sandwiches were very good but my crispy bread was ignored. We appreciate keeping prices down but that taffy has to go!!
… more
Hema Dipchand
Went to a family event this past weekend. The service was horrible. I am a vegetarian and 7 months pregnant. I told the waiter that I was a vegetarian and if I can have a vegetarian entree option. He did not seem very willing at all AND MADE ME FEEL HORRIBLE FOR ASKING. We decided that penne alla vodka would be the easiest. The appetizers were all non vegetarian so I could not eat any of it. Then there was a pasta course and to my surprise it was penne alla vodka with ham, I couldnt have that either. Then for the entree course he serves everyone and brings me my pasta last. I was so hungry I could cry at that point. I don’t usually complain but I can’t imagine starving a pregnant lady at a restaurant. I would have been fine with a mozzarella stick atleast. Worst experience ever.
… more
Anthony Ricci
Mary’s has great pizza and a great team! 8.5/10 slice (I don’t give 10s unless it’s a rare reason) highly reccomend.
… more
Marco A
One the best pizza places on the island, my go too when I want go a little extra and know I am getting amazing great food. Never have had a complaint, and food is always on point.
… more
John Schneider
Found this place by accident. So many delicious pizza choices! Other food items look delicious as well. Go there every time I’m in the area!
… more
Donna Battista
Very friendly staff and food was delicious! Nice atmosphere, and reasonably priced. Looking forward to going back!
… more
Hillary Brown
Love the food, uts truly excellent. They have a small dining room, a bar, a party room, and a place in the back between the dining room and party room pick up take out. I had meatballs and spaghetti, which I loved. Their pizza and lasagna are also excellent. The staff is attentive and friendly.
… more
Kristi M
Welcomed a large group of 7 year olds with open arms and without much notice. Service was speedy, and the pizza was tasty! Best of all, I left my bag behind accidentally, and staff placed it safely in the back for me.
… more
… View more