Massimo’s Italian Restaurant is a dining establishment that offers authentic Italian cuisine and freshly baked goods. With years of experience this family owned business is sure to satisfy and deliver the taste of Italy with it’s home made goods and impeccable pasta dishes.
BYOB.
Based on 53 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
205 Pauline Dr, York, PA 17402
Phone: (717) 855-2154
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Daphne Minkus
This was an unbelievably amazing experience! We had mixed feelings going here after hearing from some people we know that didn’t enjoy their experience. Decided to try it anyway and we are sooo glad we did!
… more
Robyn C
We had lunch with six of us. The food was delicious and the portions are big. Everyone took home leftovers. Their desserts a d pastries are delicious too! We enjoyed a full selection to try different foods.
… more
Travis Hiden
Food was very good! Highly recommend the wood fire Godfather’s pizza. My wife loved her Penne vodka. Staff was extremely nice and the Chef/Owner is very personable and appreciative of his customers. Also, the bakery has all kinds of connolis. BYOB! We will be back soon!
… more
Adorian Lazar
What an amazing find! The last time I ate authentic Italian food like this was in a restaurant I managed downtown NYC in the early 2000s! Sam the young chef is a culinary genius, and he and Massimo have brought New York City dining to York, PA. The crooners of old, like Sinatra and Dean Martin piping through the speakers, along with the white tablecloths and cloth napkins speak to an effort of fine dining from a bygone era. The food was presented well, and exquisitely delicious. Their bakery display was replete with some of the tastiest cannolis and homemade tiramisu you can find. We had to take a couple of fresh baked Breads along with a myriad of pastries home! This is our new date night location, and in between we’ll be stopping in for their fine deserts and espressos/capucinos! If you have the chance, get out here and experience it for yourself. This is not your so called chain Italian box store, so prices might be higher than you’re used to, but everything here is made fresh, and both taste and texture quickly confirms that! We can’t wait to go through their entire menu, and bring hearty appetites or be prepared to take food home, as in Italian fashion, they really mean it when they say mangia!
… more
laceyelle
Visited twice. The first time the service went above and beyond to accommodate a large, picky party of 7-8, including 3 kids. I had the grilled Caesar, fettuccini Alfredo with shrimp and an Oreo desert. It was absolutely to die for. Everyone else loved their dishes as well. The portions are huge and OMG the bread-I cannot even begin to describe the homemade bread and olive oil. The atmosphere is relaxing, clean and spacious. The bakery is amazing according to my Italian family who are cookie snobs. My second time here today, I dined in for lunch with a friend. She had pizza which she raved over (it looked awesome) and I had grilled Caesar with shrimp. It tasted perfect. We were too full for desert and I’m now regretting not getting something to go. The owner here is so sweet. Give them a try! You won’t regret it. They also take reservations which I appreciate!
… more
Charles Ryan
My first review was a 5 star. We have been there 5 times, and even took lots of guests along. Went there tonight for a “date” with my wife and the wheels fell off from the get-go. Forgot bread. Forgot oil. And they Forgot to make my meal as we ordered 2 of the same dishes. We put our 1 meal in a box and left. I’m not sure if we will be going back. SO SAD….
… more
kathy jacobson
Fantastic, authentic Italian food. Huge portions, best calamari we’ve had. Great atmosphere and service. Even during a busy dinner rush, Kelsey was so attentive. We’ve been several times and will be back soon!
… more
Jeff Strine
Great family run athenic Italian restaurant. Classy atmosphere even met owner, super friendly. The desserts are magnifico must go…
… more
Daniele Johnson
We went for dinner. The atmosphere was very nice. We got the 4 Formaggi pizza and the Carbonara pasta. The pizza wasn’t terrible, just smaller than expected. However, the pasta was cold, bacon was burnt and didn’t have much flavor. For it being “authentic” I was expecting homemade noodles, not box noodles. With the restaurant having only two tables, including ours we didn’t understand why the pasta was cold and why it took 45 minutes for our food to come out. Service wasn’t the best either. The young lady acted like she didn’t want to work nor came to the table to see if we needed anything. I had to waive her down to get more water (twice) and our check. It was the first and last time going.
… more
Ned Hickey
Our first and last visit to this establishment. We were seated promptly and that is where the best part ended. The waitress was the absolute worst, barely spoke, never asked if there were questions about the menu and she had 0 personality. Once the beverages and bread were brought we didn’t see her for at least 15 minutes. We finally had the opportunity to order and again she disappeared, no checking on our table or anything. Once the food arrived (1 plate at a time) the linguini with clams , maybe 4 clams were open the rest were shut tight. I can honestly say that is a 1 and done experience.
… more
… View more