In 1972, Master Pizza opened its doors in Painesville to give people a destination for delicious, mouth-watering pizza that’s made the right way-from scratch, with top quality ingredients. We add our rich sauce to a perfectly crisp crust and fresh toppings so that an instant favorite is made. We go beyond pizza to prepare our pastas, subs, and other menu items to please everyone. Other Master Pizza’s are in the area, but we are the original, non-franchised shop with the original recipes that you love.
Snug, modest neighborhood parlor serving artisanal oven-fired pies made with homemade dough. Based on 301 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1640 Mentor Ave #1707, Painesville, OH 44077
Phone: (440) 352-3371
Website: https://masterpizzapainesville.com/
Hours
| Wednesday |
3–9 PM |
| Thursday |
3–9 PM |
| Friday |
11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday |
11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday |
3–9 PM |
| Monday |
Closed |
| Tuesday |
3–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
David Welker
My favorite pizza in Lake County! I grew up eating Master Pizza and have always enjoyed it. In our latest stop we ordered (1) small sausage & mushroom, pepperoni & tomatoes, pepperoni, jalapenos & mushroom all with extra cheese. Our super friendly server had a little mix up and brought out a jalapeno & mudhroom instead of the sausage. She made it right – put it in a to go box for us and brought out the right one (didn’t charge us for either). Excellent pizza & great service can be expected!
… more
Connor H
Very disappointing, I used to come here with my grandmother and it was her favorite spot. The size of the large has shrunk but the price hasn’t meanwhile the quality has seemingly plummeted. I always got the seafood pizza and enjoyed the taste of the shrimp, crab, ranch, and cheese together but this time all I tasted was cheese and no ranch. Grandmother ordered an antipasta salad and received lettuce covered in shredded provolone with chopped ham and some chickpeas. Sad to see this place fall so low and I dont believe we will be coming back after this disappointment.
… more
Dona Taylor
My favorite pizza since I was a teenager. I’ve had pizza at pizza places all over and I always come back to Master Pizza because there’s is always great!!
… more
Dustin Kocevar
I LOVE MASTER PIZZA! Always delicious without breaking your bank. Fair pricing and portion sizes. Customer service is 10/10 for me, always friendly. The subs are great but me and mamma always go for classic pepperoni and mushroom with some wings. Nice crispy crust but not too crispy, delicious fresh toppings, and a nicely done gooey (but cooked all the way) center. When it hits your tongue bing, bang, boom! You can not go wrong when you order from here. When it comes to pizza around here they say leave it to the Master!
… more
Doug M
Love this little local pizza shop! Very good food, friendly staff!
… more
Carol Charlton
Pizza too salty I think they switched the salt and Suger in the sauce way too salty people make mistakes but the thing that master pizza can’t do is admit they made the mistake o called them to let them know so they didn’t keep selling the salty sauce but the lady said there is nothing I can do for you but she wasn’t that nice couldn’t be more nasty if she tried I’ll take my 30 years of being a loyal customer somewhere else very disappointed ☹️
… more
Haleigh Whitcomb
We are long time customers, and for good reason! All of the food is great but their pizza is by far the best pizza we’ve had. Customer service is amazing as well, we have never had a bad experience.
… more
John P
Not sure where to start,,Had a large pizza on Friday night, dined in. Waited 45 minutes for the pizza that arrived soggy, the salads were overwhelmed with cheese & olives,too much for sure. No Italian dressing was available, kinda strange for a Friday night Italian restaurant? I started going to master pizza in 1972 when it opened & have gone frequently over the years, what happened to the best pizza shop around?
… more
Brian Kelly
THE BEST PIZZA EVER! Great people. Servers are awesome
… more
Greg Smith
We’ve been long-time customers at the Painesville Master Pizza for years but recently have noticed a decrease in customer service.
… more
… View more
