Michael’s Frozen Custard Menu – Madison, WI

Type : Fast food restaurant

Location : Madison, WI

Local chain serving frozen custard, burgers & hot dogs in an old-school setting. Based on 638 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through

Michael's Frozen Custard 53714

Address:
3826 Atwood Ave, Madison, WI 53714

Phone: (608) 222-4110

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Thursday 10:30 AM–8 PM
Friday 10:30 AM–9 PM
Saturday 10:30 AM–9 PM
Sunday 10:30 AM–8 PM
Monday 10:30 AM–8 PM
Tuesday 10:30 AM–8 PM
Wednesday 10:30 AM–8 PM

Menu

Twisters
Emerald City
Somewhere over the rainbow are refreshing mint, chunks of gooey brownies and salted pecans twisted with mint custard.
$7.49
Cookie Jar
Cookie dough chunks twisted with real Oreos.
$7.49
Strawberry Cheesecake
Chunks of strawberries and real cheesecake pieces made for a refreshing satisfying taste.
$7.49
Key Lime Pie
Refreshing taste of why key west has become so famous for its key lime pie.
$7.49
Malts and Shakes
Vanilla $6.89
Strawberry $6.89
Single Topping Sundae
Single Topping Sundae
Choose a topping: Hot Fudge, P.B. Bups, Cookie Dough, Salted Pecan Halves, Chocolate Syrup.
$5.94
Cones and Dishes
M&M Waffle $5.92
Chocolate Dipped Waffle $5.25
Plain Cone $4.42

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Keenon Morris
This place has been around for a long time now. Great ice cream selection. From the food and old fashioned custards. You will understand if you visit that this still has the old school feel to it. The food and Custards can be a little pricey, but when you get it, it’s well worth the price. They always keep the restaurant and restrooms clean. Love the staff and your food will be cooked fresh and hot. I give this place. 5

… more

Michelle Headrick
The food was good and the staff was super friendly. The outdoor seating is dog friendly. They even have water bowls and treats for your pup.

… more

Paco K
Great ice cream parlor. The strawberry shake was unbelievable .

… more

Fawn Hawpetoss
Extremely nice service. The group in front of me intended to order sweet potato fries but the man at the counter didn’t hear them. When they told him, he gave them the fries on the house (sometimes it’s the little gestures that matter). I love the old school diner theme, takes me back to my childhood when Michael’s FC sponsored my soft ball team.

… more

Aaron Goldbin
Good food and custard, just quite pricey.

… more

Benjamin Wilz
I love this place. Been going for years. Prices have gotten very high, which, if you are paying your employees well. Fine. However, in my most recent trip through their drive thru I was prompted for a tip… at a drive thru. So are they not paying their employees well enough? If you are paying them with tips, then the food should be cheaper. You can’t have both.

… more

John Stephenson
Service is amazing. The ladies at the counter are always extremely friendly and kind. The custard is not cheap but in my opinion tastier than the one at Culver’s. The burgers are always so fresh! I don’t understand how this place doesn’t have more 5 star ratings. Support your local businesses!!! It might be a bit more expensive than Culver’s but the atmosphere and the food always makes it worth the trip for me.

… more

Eric T
I live right by here and want to love this place. But there are several factors that really turn me off. The prices are simply too high, except for the coffee. Right down the road there is a Culver’s that is fully half the price and if all you want is a turtle Sunday, Culver’s is at least as good. The dance club music – tiresome and not the vibe you want at 11 AM and blasted to the exterior at all times. The food is ok and the custard is really good but somehow it’s just not an appealing place. I can guarantee that if they fixed a few things you’d have the whole neighborhood lined up here on summer nights.

… more

Jamie Pittman
I am extremely disappointed in my experience here. Not only did I have to repeat my very simple order 4 different times to confirm the employee heard it correctly, but my rather small blended ice cream (16oz) was very costly, and very poor quality. I got a cup of coffee flavored custard, and it was over $11. As if that’s not bad enough, it was soupy, and had an icy, grainy texture. I have heard good things about this place, which is why I tried it, but I could’ve had such a better experience for less than half the price if I went to Culver’s.

… more

Jeff Arevalo
If you want to drop $50 for 3 kids to eat basic summer food, by all means. The desserts are good so not going to knock them on that

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions