Longtime family-owned bar & pizzeria making brick-oven pan pies & other Italian favorites. Based on 176 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
125 Midland Ave, Port Chester, NY 10573
Phone: (914) 939-2241
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 12–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8:30 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
12–9:30 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 12–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 12–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 12–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tom McNicholas
The pizza in this quaint little bar is to DIE FOR!! Look at the char on that crust! This one was the hot woodsy which has hot sausage, hot cherry peppers and mushrooms (I had the mushrooms omitted), and I absolutely loved this pizza from the first bite to the last!
… more
James Mitchell
Wonderful experience here, very friendly staff, met owner and found out its been the oldest pizzeria in Port Chester and run by a father and daughter team the pizza is delicious and place is very clean. I highly recommend stopping in for a pie and a drink!
… more
Jeff Brown
Crisp and flavorful! The personal pizza was generously sized, would definitely go back.
… more
Luthier Dawn
I ordered online and asked for “a little extra sauce action” in my pasta. Not only did they deliver with an extra container of sauce but it was so so good. I always order here. Never disappointed. Thank you to whoever gave me a lil extra sauce action
… more
Alexander Bea
What is the matter with the world when Michael’s of Port Chester does not get 5 stars for its pizza?
… more
Katelyn Vickery
I would never normally give a negative review for a small business and never for just one bad experience. The woman who runs this place is the RUDEST! I love the pizza but after so many bad experiences this will be our last time ordering from there. I just ordered 3 pizzas and a salad and ONLY the salad was delivered. Most businesses would make it right but not them. Their response was basically tough luck and they couldn’t care less. My son is special needs and is in a full tantrum because he was supposed to get pizza and can’t just simply get over it. They actually suggested that I replace the order and then in an hour and a half they will deliver the old pizzas they have ready for us right now. Or I can come get it. So pack up my newborn and my special needs child and come get the pizza that will now be two hours old and pay full price. So many people in this community have had similar or worse experiences. With so many other restaurants around who care for their customers I highly suggest a restaurant that will treat you better. Antonio’s, Frankie and louies, t&js, roddys, Frank’s, villa rustica just to name a few who work so hard for the customer experience.
… more
Moe Noriega
What we have here is a Woodsie half spicy/half sweet. Pepperoni pizza and Goose Island IPA.
… more
Poor Hello
I was there last night for the first time ever.
… more
Ek Will (E.K.)
That pizza is the best! Always was and still is!! I haven’t had it in a good minute, only no disappointment. We all enjoyed it completely!! Definitely going back sooner than later. Highly recommended.
… more
Greg Harris
In March Of 2021, I brought and treated my wife and myself for dinner at Michael’s Pizza and we both very much enjoyed our dining experience at this great restaurant.
… more
… View more