Based on 312 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
442 E Main St, Middletown, PA 17057
Phone: (717) 944-2195
Hours
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Simply A Peach
Traveling and stopped in to order a pizza for take out and the staff was super nice and very courteous. I loved their onion rings and the crust on the pizza was delicious
… more
Michelle Nace
If I could give 0 stars I would! We order from here at least 1 time a week from work. We ordered online. Now both parties are at fault but we picked up our order with one name they gave us the wrong order. So we drove 20 min there ans back twice. Food was burnt and due to the mix up we had to pay for two orders and no even a simple apology! Then another coworker ordered from there today again they mess up their order and they got stuck paying for the mix up due to the overly aggressive people that work/ run this pizza place. We will definitely never get food from here again! You just lost a $50 order that comes 1 to 2 times a week.
… more
Cindy DonBullian
The pizza here was great! Had the chicken, bacon, ranch and everyone loved it. Wings were just ok, sausage sub was good and the Greek salad was so big and packed full of so many great ingredients! The stuffed shells were overcooked, so badly you couldn’t cut them. I wouldn’t hold that one dish against them though, I would definitely go back.
… more
Nyla Cruz
The loaded fries are awful it literally tastes so sour like the cheese was completely bad. I never thought cheese could taste like that and this place has made me never want to buy loaded fries AGAIN.
… more
Charisse Morrell
I really tried to give the benefit of the doubt to this place, but I should have paid attention to the reviews. I notice now that most of the 5 star reviews are 2 or 3 sentences long – a good tip off that they’re not real.
… more
Darren Royer
Why even order toppings if they’re going to be this cheap with them. Pizza is either under baked or there’s half the amount of toppings that any other pizza shop would put on. Plus no delivery until after 5 and nobody to tap a pint of beer ad dinner time on a Saturday…. Place is in the weeds!
… more
Barry Lanquar
Foods actually amazing, visually the place is surprising. The people were so nice and came to us even though we were going to go to them to order. 10/10
… more
Brianna Pinkney
This place has went completely downhill in the last three years. The people running this place are careless and rude. I just got blamed for my own order being messed up lol completely ridiculous. Do yourself a favor and don’t order from here.
… more
Alex Hatfield
I had 11$ on me in cash and the cost of a small pizza was $11.55. The cashier let me go on the change so I didn’t need to use my debit card and as someone who doesn’t have a lot of money, small acts of human kindness like that make the world so much more livable. Great customer service and great pizza!
… more
Barbara Van Aulen
Will not go back! First, their online menu is not correctly priced….prices much higher when placing order. I spent $30. on a small Hawaiian pizza lacking in flavor with too much dough and not enough toppings, especially the pineapple, one basic cheeseburger that they claim is 1/4 lb., and an order of mozzarella sticks. I didn’t appreciate that they threw our side order of mozzarella sticks in the same to go box as my friend’s cheeseburger. I guess they are trying to conserve boxes but this is not a good practice as they had no idea if the mozzarella sticks were going to be for one person or shared. Also, the burger was small but placed on a roll two big for such a small pattie. The cheeseburger was supposed to have lettuce, tomato, onion and mayo but had none of those items, just the cheeseburger on the roll, which my friend doesn’t eat anyway. Thankfully, they at least remembered the side of ketchup and mustard. What I didn’t appreciate was when I called to notify them of the mistake THEY made for an overpriced burger that didn’t even include chips or a pickle, I was made to feel like I was fibbing at first but then she said I could come back in for compensation of some kind. This was the same lady who took my order and chatted with me in the store and seemed really sweet so it surprised me that she questioned my feedback. I also didn’t think it was fair that I’d have to take time to go back to their store to get compensated. They had my ticket, copy of signed receipt, and cc info on hand. There’s too many other great pizza shops around to overpay at this restaurant. I understand prices have gone up but when you overpay for low quality, quantity, and
… more
… View more