Based on 167 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
806 E 3rd Ave, New Smyrna Beach, FL 32169
Phone: (386) 423-6854
Website: https://www.facebook.com/pages/Mikeys-Pizza/111656265537844
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
3–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 3–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–8 PM |
| Thursday | 3–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Alex Marshall
I’ve been coming here almsot all my life. In the 15 years we’ve been coming to NSB we’ve never had Mikey’s. This changed last night when we ordered for the very first time. The quality of food was amazing and delicious, and considering we got two large two topping pizzas, the 18 dollars was incredibly fair!! The crust was amazing! I highly recommend you come here for a good quality pizza and very fair prices!!
… more
Anita Mendoza
We ordered medium Pepperoni and Jalapeño, and an Antipasto salad. Both were good. Not the best I have ever had, certainly not the worst. I liked the thicker crust, and the toppings were generous. There was the perfect amount of sauce. The crust seemed like it lacked something, perhaps salt? The only observation that would have (perhaps) elevated our experience, was attitude. It’s everything. The person who took our order didn’t seem to be happy to be there. My kind husband said “charming,” when we went back in the car to wait. Just give us a little… we are always kind to wait staff and appreciate a little reciprocity. Mikey’s is still worth a try, just order delivery; your experience might be better than ours.
… more
Krista Doerr
Pizza was great! We ordered several for lunch. The white pizza was pretty good, we added tomatoes and bacon to ours. YUM! And of course pepperoni was a big hit as well. The lady working today was very nice. We also got to visit with the neighboring stores dogs while we waited. Will definitely eat here again when we come back!!
… more
Roger prieto
Best local American pizza good quality and fresh..
… more
Tana McCoy
Delicious!! I would highly recommend this pizza place. Very good service and when I got it it was very hot.
… more
Latasha Stewart
My family and I were on Vacation and we stopped here honestly not expecting much out of this place BOY WERE WE WRONG!! We had ordered a medium meat lovers without pepperoni and a supreme pizza. We were not prepared for the flavor explosion we received! Melty cheesy goodness is all I can say! Not only was the pizza phenomenal the service was great as well. Thank you Mikes Pizza I can’t wait to return!
… more
Jordan King
We had never tried Mikeys despite living just blocks away. Ordered a pizza from them last weekend and it was tops! Quick and friendly delivery, fresh, hot and generous toppings. Will order again!
… more
Matthew Gregory
It pains me to give Mikey’s anything but 5 stars. Whenever we’re in MewSmyrna Beach we have to give Mikey’s Pizza a call and order a few pies. In my opinion, Mikey’s is the best pizza in NDB. However, this time, the woman who answered the phone to take our order and subsequently delivered our order gave my fiancé such an inexcusable attitude that we just couldn’t believe it. We’ve never had this issue with Mikey’s before. We provided a tip despite this. Upon delivery, she was very irritable and rude. She made a comment about my fiancé and how she had dealing with her was a nuisance and claimed to another person with us that we stuffed her on a tip. I’m not sure what this employees issue was, but I’d recommend an attitude adjustment. Leave your personal life at the door when you enter work. I want to continue to enjoy Mikey’s for years to come but we will NOT deal with this sort of attitude for, literally, no reason.
… more
Nicole Sipos
Delicious, plain and simple. How pizza should be. Made with love from scratch.
… more
Josh Pickett
Pretty good pizza. We ordered the All meat pizza and garlic bread with cheese. Toppings were burnt on the pizza mainly the bacon so it didn’t affect it to bad
… more
… View more