Based on 87 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
7 N School St, Mayfield, NY 12117
Phone: (518) 661-5599
Website: http://mayfieldmisterpizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Daneen Zemken
The woman at the counter was extremely rude when we picked up our large order. My order was accepted and nothing was said other than we had to pay up front on the phone We happily paid with a tip for a pickup pizza order when we arrived we were told next time our order would not be accepted unless it was 24 hours in advance If we were told it was an issue filling our order we would have gladly ordered elsewhere. This has been my favorite pizza place for years and I will NEVER order if this is not respectfully addressed with me. You have my number. I have never been so disappointed in the way I was treated.
… more
Christine Annichiarico
First time ordering and WOW! We have always seen their signs around town and decided to give it a try. Took a look at the menu and decided on the artichoke and tomato pizza. Go bold on the first order. Someone new was training who took our order and they did great, btw!!! The pizza was ready on time and wonderful. Perfectly crusty on the bottom filled with the toppings, everything was seasoned well and tasted amazing. You have a new regular customer for sure. Can’t wait to try more items on the menu.
… more
Linda H.
Great food. They have a separate take out section and the the actual restaurant area. I love their chicken parm and subs.
… more
Shelly Hinkle
Great place to eat. My granddaughter asked what secret ingredient Chris uses.
… more
Christopher Wilson
Consistency is key and this place has it. While the quality of food at most pizza places around here has it’s ebbs and flows, you know what to expect from Mr Pizza. And when you order your wings crispy, they actually come crispy, not a soggy vessel for the sauce most places have them swimming in.
… more
Fafe B.
I had to update my last review. My first experience 2 years ago was not so good but I decided to give it another chance and they did not disappoint this time. It is definitely a little pricey but worth it!
… more
Mike Nelson
All the meals are FANTASTIC (HOT and Yummy)
… more
Roger Huseland
My wife and I both ordered lasagna dinners for dine in last week and the salad was great as well as the lasagna dinners. Our server was very personable and helpful! Thanks
… more
Edward Symack
Me and my girlfriend planned on ordering pizza and wings for diner. Which is kind of a treat for us. We placed the order picked it up on time. Buy when we returned home and opened the boxes, we saw that the chicken wings were small, so small that we kind of laughed about it. The price u pay for the size of the chicken wing they give you is ridiculous.
… more
Matthew Stoodley
Have not dined in yet. Had take out twice. Clean kitchen and clean take out area. The pizza is really good. Veggie pizza was a little sloppy due to too many ingredients but delicious. Hawaiin pizza is very good. Garlic-Parm wings are very good. The garlic is not too strong and plenty of parmesan flavor.
… more
… View more