Tavern serving pizza and well rounded pub menu. Full bar, lots of beer, wine and house cocktails. Comfortable atmosphere. Reservations suggested for our dining room, the bar area is first come first serve.
(seasonal salads, soups, hand-cut fries, poutine, burgers, wings, house made sauces, nightly features)
Based on 35 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
19 W Main St, Shortsville, NY 14548
Phone: (585) 289-7010
Website: http://www.mollymoocherstavern.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
| Monday | 4–8 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Dave LaDue
Wow! What a sleeper this place is!
… more
Gabrielle Seeber
We have now been there 3 times and each time has been wonderful. I love that they don’t crowd the tables (rare these days at restaurants), the staff have all been attentive and friendly (and seem to actually be happy at work- allowing for positive interactions, especially with our 4 kids), and the food is great! We especially love their fries- so delicious!
… more
KJ A
The food, I had the Friday Fish Special. Outstanding. Plenty of fish, cooked perfect. Plenty of fries, the tartar sauce was homemade and very good. Cole slaw had a bit of jalapeno in it. Very tasty. I will go back. If you pass up on this place, you passed up a good meal.
… more
Amy Valdes
We ordered take out for dinner last night from Molly Moochers and we’re impressed! My BBQ Burger was fantastic. My husband got the Cuban and he said it was #2 on his list of favorite places to get a Cuban from. The fries were similar to 5Guys without the spice and we enjoyed them. We’ll order from there again for sure.
… more
Shana Baker
As locals we couldn’t love this addition to our community any more! The vibe is great, the food is fresh and menu is a great blend of new twists on old favorites. Some of the highlights include the Wild Fries, Poutine, Tomato Bisque, The Smash Burgers – any style is delish!! The bar is full of an extensive variety of local and regional craft beers. They have a wide array of liquors at different price points, to give you plenty of options. The service is always polite, friendly, and customer-focused. We highly recommend this tavern to anyone passing through town looking for an enjoyable, easy, laid back dining experience….and if you’re a local….this is a must to add to your rotation!!!
… more
Nicole Beagley
The food is great. However, it takes a long time to get your food, even though there was only four other people in the restaurant. The prices are outrageous considering substitutions are not allowed. For example, they serve a Ruben sandwich-corn beef, Swiss, kraut, 1000 Island dressing… the “Rachel” is a Ruben but with turkey and coleslaw. When I asked to have a turkey reuben with kraut, I was told by the waitress that she would have to ask if they would accommodate the change. Are you kidding me?! I’m sure the coleslaw and the kraut are in containers next to eachother. This has happened more than once. You can’t add to a meal, you can’t substitute simple ingredients. We also asked the person delivering the salads if we could get an extra ranch. I quote ” your server will be right with you.” By the way we had to ask for the salad prior to our meal. I’m amazed that this place has been in business this long with all of their “rules” regarding no changes to the meals. It’s disappointing.
… more
Cassy Coyne
Amazing food, service, and atmosphere. Owners are friendly and great, employees are courteous. A gem in Shortsville that we all needed.
… more
Kassie Reed
I’ve had the Cuban sandwich and the beef on week, and both are amazing. All of the menu items sound and look absolutely delicious. Hands down the best restaurant I’ve ever been to
… more
Ashley Rivera
We love Mollys!! We try to order something different every time we go and have yet to have a bad meal. I’ve always thought the timing between drinks, aps and dinner has been perfect. We’ve been while it was packed and not and have had the same experience each time. Love having this little treasure right around the corner.
… more
Alex Northup (Courtsloth)
One of the best meals out I’ve ever had. I got the Cuban, wife had a mushroom swiss burger, we split a plate of poutine – both totally caught off guard at how good everything was. Can’t wait to go back!
… more
… View more