If you’re a pizza lover in Opelika, Alabama, you’re in luck! The newest Mr Gatti’s Pizza location is opening its doors and it’s sure to become a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike. Come experience the delicious signature pizzas and toppings made from the freshest ingredients. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, perfect for a family dinner or a casual night out with friends. Don’t forget to try the other menu items like salads, pasta, wings, and desserts. Mr. Gatti’s Pizza is committed to providing excellent service and making your dining experience unforgettable. Come see what the buzz is all about and make sure to visit us soon!
Based on 34 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ No takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
704 1st Ave, Opelika, AL 36801
Phone: (334) 737-6603
Website:
Hours
| Thursday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jim Andrews
Loved Mr Gatti’s growing up, so was excited when hearing they was coming to the area! Same great pizza as I remember with top notch ingredients. Buffet was kept full through the lunch crowd and they have about 15 tv’s in the building so should be a great location for game day. Be mindful of when you go cause they do shut down the buffet from 2-5pm it looks like. Top quality pizza on a buffet with pasta options and salad bar for a very reasonable price is why I will keep coming back!
… more
Valeri White
From being greeted by Patrick to the awesome 80s music…lots of nostalgia from having one in Auburn. It’s a great location with a reasonably priced buffet! Very attentive staff and lots of variety! Yummy!
… more
Kristen Hansen
Definitely opening growing pains. Be prepared to wait awhile if you go at peak times. We went about 6:15 p.m. and the place was slammed. Had to wait in long lines for pizza to be put out. When we left around 7:20, the crowd had calmed down, and there was plenty of pizza. But then the dessert pizza was all gone …. It was refilled eventually. Just be patient.
… more
Lucas Brackin
My parents used to take us to Mr. Gatti’s when I was little. I was so glad when I saw that they were coming back. The pizza still tastes exactly the same. It was great to share the experience with my wife and son, because I had always told my wife about going there as a kid. Only 4 stars because of a couple reasons. The drinks were out all night and the bus boys worked at a snails pace. Anyone that came in had to clean their own table to get a place to eat. But that’s part of the growing pains. Love this place and glad we finally have one back!
… more
Haley Prestridge
This place is nice! And to keep it nice and up to par with customers the staff needs to WORK, went with my fiancé on Friday night and throughout our entire meal there were 1-2 of the 8+ employees actually working, stocking the bar, cleaning, etc. The rest were standing around which unfortunately made the buffet not fully enjoyable. Other than the lack of customer service and laziness the place is good.
… more
Greg Holley
Went around 11:10 am on Monday. Pizza was delicious, atmosphere/staff are solid. TVs will make this location a valid option on game days this fall. Owner is actively working with staff. Opportunities for improvement would be a larger variety of pizza at opening and maybe add a tip jar.
… more
Southern Furniture Plus Tommy Carter
The experience was great! Brought us back to the 80’s! Very crowded, found a table and just enjoyed the experience! I am not an early eatter but after seeing all the reviews we decided we better go! So at 5 o’clock we walked in and it was already packed. The staff was doing everything they could with the crowd and I praise them. Very good experience!
… more
Allison Fontaine
The food was great! The setup of the buffet made it a little difficult to get to some things, but it was worth it.
… more
J at AU
No buffet, ran out of pizza boxes. Pizza was avg to below avg. Such high expectations for this place as Mr. Gatti’s was a childhood pizza place my family visited often. Hope it gets better but lot of work to do. A one and done.
… more
Sam Taylor
This place is a wreck. Buffet bars are a complete mess. Can’t even reach the back row of the salad bar. Pasta always empty. Employees doing nothing. Ice machine doesn’t work. Burger King atmosphere.
… more
… View more
