Mutiny BBQ Company Menu – Asbury Park, NJ

Type : Barbecue restaurant

Location : Asbury Park, NJ

Based on 149 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Mutiny BBQ Company 07712

Address:
808 Fifth Ave, Asbury Park, NJ 07712

Phone: (732) 366-9985

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 12–8 PM
Thursday 12–8 PM
Friday 12–8 PM
Saturday 12–8 PM
Sunday 12–6 PM
Monday Closed

Menu

FOOD
Sliced Brisket – Quarter Pound
The Holy Grail of BBQ. Dusted with a simple rub of kosher salt and course ground black pepper and injected with a secret flavor booster, our brisket is sliced to order.

Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and one Martin’s Potato Roll.

 $8.00
Sliced Brisket – Half Pound
The Holy Grail of BBQ. Dusted with a simple rub of kosher salt and course ground black pepper and injected with a secret flavor booster, our brisket is sliced to order.

Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and two Martin’s Potato Rolls.

 $16.00
Sliced Brisket – 3/4 Pound
The Holy Grail of BBQ. Dusted with a simple rub of kosher salt and course ground black pepper and injected with a secret flavor booster, our brisket is sliced to order.

Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and three Martin’s Potato Rolls.

 $24.00
Sliced Brisket – One Pound
The Holy Grail of BBQ. Dusted with a simple rub of kosher salt and course ground black pepper and injected with a secret flavor booster, our brisket is sliced to order.

Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and four Martin’s Potato Rolls.

 $32.00
Chopped Brisket – Quarter Pound
Our signature brisket is roughly chopped and tossed with our housemade BBQ sauce.

Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and one Martin’s Potato Roll.

 $8.00
Chopped Brisket – Half Pound
Our signature brisket is roughly chopped and tossed with our housemade BBQ sauce.

Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and two Martin’s Potato Rolls.

 $16.00
Chopped Brisket – 3/4 Pound
Our signature brisket is roughly chopped and tossed with our housemade BBQ sauce.

Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and three Martin’s Potato Rolls.

 $24.00
Chopped Brisket – One Pound
Our signature brisket is roughly chopped and tossed with our housemade BBQ sauce.

Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and four Martin’s Potato Rolls.

 $32.00
Pulled Pork – Quarter Pound
Bone-in pork butt is coated in house dry rub and injected with a secret flavor booster. Hand-pulled and finished with our Eastern Carolina-inspired house hot vinegar.

Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and one Martin’s Potato Roll.

 $4.50
Pulled Pork – Half Pound
Bone-in pork butt is coated in house dry rub and injected with a secret flavor booster. Hand-pulled and finished with our Eastern Carolina-inspired house hot vinegar.

Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and two Martin’s Potato Rolls.

 $9.00
Pulled Pork – 3/4 Pound
Bone-in pork butt is coated in house dry rub and injected with a secret flavor booster. Hand-pulled and finished with our Eastern Carolina-inspired house hot vinegar.

Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and three Martin’s Potato Rolls.

 $13.50
Pulled Pork – One Pound
Bone-in pork butt is coated in house dry rub and injected with a secret flavor booster. Hand-pulled and finished with our Eastern Carolina-inspired house hot vinegar.

Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and four Martin’s Potato Rolls.

 $18.00
Turkey Breast – Quarter Pound
A smokehouse staple, slices of moist, flavorful turkey breast are carved to order.

Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and one Martin’s Potato Roll.

 $7.50
Turkey Breast – Half Pound
A smokehouse staple, slices of moist, flavorful turkey breast are carved to order.

Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and two Martin’s Potato Rolls.

 $15.00
Turkey Breast – 3/4 Pound
A smokehouse staple, slices of moist, flavorful turkey breast are carved to order.

Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and three Martin’s Potato Rolls.

 $22.50
Turkey Breast – One Pound
A smokehouse staple, slices of moist, flavorful turkey breast are carved to order.

Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and four Martin’s Potato Rolls.

 $30.00
St. Louis Ribs – Half Rack
St. Louis-cut pork spare ribs coated in our house dry rub and smoked for several hours before being basted in Mutiny’s signature BBQ sauce.		 $18.00
St. Louis Ribs – Full Rack
St. Louis-cut pork spare ribs coated in our house dry rub and smoked for several hours before being basted in Mutiny’s signature BBQ sauce.		 $34.00
Texas Style Sausage
Often referred to as a “hot gut” or “hot link,” these peppery, European-inspired links come to us from Southside Market in the heart of Central Texas.

Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and a Martin’s Potato
Roll.

 $6.00
Smoke Fried Wings – 6
Jumbo wings dry-brined overnight and smoked before being finished with a quick deep fry to ensure perfect crunch. Available in our housemade Buffalo or honey BBQ sauce. Served with bleu cheese and celery.		 $9.00
Smoke Fried Wings – 12
Jumbo wings dry-brined overnight and smoked before being finished with a quick deep fry to ensure perfect crunch. Available in our housemade Buffalo or honey BBQ sauce. Served with bleu cheese and celery.		 $18.00
Smoke Fried Wings – 24
Jumbo wings dry-brined overnight and smoked before being finished with a quick deep fry to ensure perfect crunch. Available in our housemade Buffalo or honey BBQ sauce. Served with bleu cheese and celery.		 $36.00
Wednesday Pulled Pork For 2
One pound pork, a pint of mac and cheese, half pints of cole slaw and pickles, a side of pickled red onions, six Martin’s Potato Roll sliders, and a four ounce mini squeeze bottle of our BBQ sauce. Feeds 2-3. Dine-in or takeout. Available all day while supplies last.		 $30.00
Wednesday Pulled Pork Family Dinner Special
We’ve got dinner covered tonight.

Two pounds of pulled pork, a dozen Martin’s Potato Roll sliders, an 8-ounce bottle of house BBQ sauce, A pint of cole slaw, a pint of pickles, a side of pickled red onions, and a quart of mac and cheese.

Feeds 4-6. Subject to availability. Wednesdays only. Dine-in or takeout. No changes or substitutions.

 $60.00
Thursday Rib Meal For 2 $35.00
Pimento Cheese – Half Pint
Our housemade pimento cheese is a versatile spread that is great to bring to the beach, the park, or wherever you’re heading! Served in a half pint deli tub with smoked saltines.		 $5.00
Shore House Party Package
1 lb. brisket
1 lb. pulled pork
1 half rack ribs
2 Texas sausages
1 dozen slider rolls
1 8oz bottle of BBQ sauce
Pickles/pickled red onions		 $80.00
Ciabatta Chicken BLT Sandwich
Smoke fried chicken thigh, bacon, lettuce, and Jersey tomato with our signature Mutiny sauce on ciabatta. Served with a side of handcut fries.		 $17.00
Sliced Brisket Combo Plate
Half a pound of sliced brisket, your choice of two sides, pickles, onions, and a roll.		 $23.00
Chopped Brisket Combo Plate
Half a pound of chopped brisket, your choice of two sides, pickles, onions, and a roll.		 $23.00
Pulled Pork Combo Plate
Half a pound of pulled pork, your choice of two sides, pickles, onions, and a roll.		 $20.00
Carved Turkey Combo Plate
Half a pound of carved turkey, your choice of two sides, pickles, onions, and a roll.		 $22.00
Half Rack Ribs Combo Plate
Half a rack of St. Louis ribs (5-6 bones on average), your choice of two sides, pickles, onions, and a roll.		 $25.00
Texas Style Sausage Combo Plate
Two Texas style sausage links, your choice of two sides, pickles, onions, and a roll.		 $21.00
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Our Eastern Carolina style pulled pork piled high on a huge “Big Marty” Martin’s Potato Roll and topped with housemade vinegar cole slaw and housemade pickles. Finished with a drizzle of our house signature BBQ sauce. Served with a side of handcut french fries.		 $14.00
Brisket Sandwich
Our signature brisket is piled high on a “Big Marty” Martin’s Potato Roll and topped with housemade pickles and pickled red onions. Finished with a drizzle of our signature BBQ sauce. Served with a side of handcut fries.		 $18.00
The Beast From The East Sandwich
A tribute to one of Asbury Park’s favorite sons, the late great professional wrestling superstar Bam Bam Bigelow, this sandwich features a quarter pound of pulled pork, a quarter pound of chopped brisket, a whole Texas sausage link, cole slaw, pickles, pickled red onion, and our house BBQ sauce piled high on a seeded Martin’s “Big Marty” Potato Roll. It doesn’t come with a side, but trust us. You won’t need one.		 $20.00
Bacon Bama Turkey Sandwich
Our carved smoked turkey breast, bacon, pepper jack cheese, and housemade Alabam White Sauce on a potato roll. Served with a side of handcut fries.		 $16.00
Smoke Fried Chicken Thigh Sandwich
Boneless, skinless chicken thigh dusted with house dry rub, smoked, and then deep fried. Tossed in your choice of wing sauce or house dry rub and topped with housemade pickles. Served on a potato bun with a side of handcut fries.		 $15.00
Cornbread Casserole
Our warm, scoopable cornbread pudding is baked fresh daily.		 $5.00
Fries
Our hand cut Austin fries are a specialty of the house. Tossed in a secret “magic”
seasoning. Servred with a side of our Mutiny Sauce, a Cajun Dijon aioli.		 $6.00
Pimento Cheese – Half Pint
Our housemade pimento cheese is a versatile spread that is great to bring to the beach, the park, or wherever you’re heading! Served in a half pint deli tub with smoked saltines.		 $5.00
Mac And Cheese – 1/2 Pt
Our spin on a classic home-cooked side. Freshly-grated sharp cheddar and gruyere, pasta shells, and a Cheez-It cracker crust.		 $5.00
Smoked Beans – 1/2 Pt
These are not your average, overly sweetened baked beans. Red kidney beans are tossed with sautéed onions and peppers, dusted with house dry rub, and tossed in a signature sauce.		 $5.00
Collard Greens – 1/2 Pt
A traditional take on the southern staple. Freshly chopped greens, slow-braised in a garlic, onion, and red pepper chicken stock with chopped bacon. Finished with our housemade vinegar sauce.		 $5.00
Texas Carolina Potato Salad – 1/2 Pt
A classic Texas BBQ joint style potato salad with flavors of the Carolinas. Russet potatoes, diced egg, relish, and pimentos in a mustard dressing.		 $5.00
Vinegar Cole Slaw – 1/2 Pt
Our house slaw has no mayo and was designed to be a fresh, tangy complement to our rich BBQ. Confetti cabbage and carrots tossed lightly in an apple cider and dijon vinaigrette.		 $4.00
House Pickles – 1/2 Pt
These housemade garlic and dill pickles pair perfectly with our craft-smoked meats. Order extra, they are highly addictive and store well.		 $4.00
Mac And Cheese – Pt
Our spin on a classic home-cooked side. Freshly-grated sharp cheddar and gruyere, pasta shells, and a Cheez-It cracker crust.		 $10.00
Smoked Beans – Pt
These are not your average, overly sweetened baked beans. Red kidney beans are tossed with sautéed onions and peppers, dusted with house dry rub, and tossed in a signature sauce.		 $10.00
Collard Greens – Pt
A traditional take on the southern staple. Freshly chopped greens, slow-braised in a garlic, onion, and red pepper chicken stock with chopped bacon. Finished with our housemade vinegar sauce.		 $10.00
Texas Carolina Potato Salad – Pt
A classic Texas BBQ joint style potato salad with flavors of the Carolinas. Russet potatoes, diced egg, relish, and pimentos in a mustard dressing.		 $10.00
Vinegar Cole Slaw – Pt
Our house slaw has no mayo and was designed to be a fresh, tangy complement to our rich BBQ. Confetti cabbage and carrots tossed lightly in an apple cider and dijon vinaigrette.		 $8.00
House Pickles – Pt
These housemade garlic and dill pickles pair perfectly with our craft-smoked meats. Order extra, they are highly addictive and store well.		 $8.00
Mac And Cheese – Qt
Our spin on a classic home-cooked side. Freshly-grated sharp cheddar and gruyere, pasta shells, and a Cheez-It cracker crust.		 $20.00
Smoked Beans – Qt
These are not your average, overly sweetened baked beans. Red kidney beans are tossed with sautéed onions and peppers, dusted with house dry rub, and tossed in a signature sauce.		 $20.00
Collard Greens – Qt
A traditional take on the southern staple. Freshly chopped greens, slow-braised in a garlic, onion, and red pepper chicken stock with chopped bacon. Finished with our housemade vinegar sauce.		 $20.00
Texas Carolina Potato Salad – Qt
A classic Texas BBQ joint style potato salad with flavors of the Carolinas. Russet potatoes, diced egg, relish, and pimentos in a mustard dressing.		 $20.00
Vinegar Cole Slaw – Qt
Our house slaw has no mayo and was designed to be a fresh, tangy complement to our rich BBQ. Confetti cabbage and carrots tossed lightly in an apple cider and dijon vinaigrette.		 $16.00
House Pickles – Qt
These housemade garlic and dill pickles pair perfectly with our craft-smoked meats. Order extra, they are highly addictive and store well.		 $16.00
Bourbon Foster Banana Pudding
Banana pudding is essential to the BBQ eating experience at great smokehouses throughout Texas. We add a bit of New Orleans flair to ours with bourbon-brouleéd cinnamon and brown sugar bananas. It’s topped (of course) with Nilla Wafer cookies.		 $5.00
Whoopie Pies
Rich, dark chocolate cakes with a delicious whipped marshmallow filling sandwiched between them and then dusted with powdered sugar. Two per order.		 $6.00
Side Of Blue Cheese $0.50
Extra Rolls – Two $1.20
Extra Pickles $1.00
Extra Onions $1.00
Bottled Sauce
An 8-ounce squeeze bottle of our signature housemade BBQ sauce.		 $6.00
Martin’s Potato Rolls (12) $5.00
Side Of Ranch $0.60
Side Of Buffalo Sauce $0.60
Side Of Honey BBQ Sauce $0.60
Koozie
Mutiny BBQ Company logo koozie		 $4.80
Mutiny Cooking Wood $36.00
Mutiny BBQ Dry Rub (Half Pint)
An 8-ounce container of our signature house dry rub. This is the rub that we use on all of our pork and poultry. This versatile blend of dried seasonings is perfect for smoking, grilling, or roasting just about anything!		 $6.00
BEVERAGES
Poland Spring $2.00
Coke $3.50
Diet Coke $2.75
Topo Chico Mineral Water $3.50
Cheerwine $3.50
Boylan Orange Soda $3.50
Boylan Root Beer $3.50
Boylan Grape Soda $3.50
Boylan Creme Soda $3.50
Boylan’s Ginger Ale $3.50
Liquid Death Berry $3.50
Liquid Death Lime $3.50
Liquid Death Mango $3.50
Tropicana Apple Juice $2.50
Sprite $3.50
Joe Lemonade $3.50
Joe Unsweetened Tea $3.50
Joe Sweet Tea $3.50
Joe Tea Peach Iced Tea $3.50
Joe Tea Raspberry Iced Tea $3.50
RETAIL
Keep Asbury Weird Shirt $20.00
Black Logo Shirt – Size XL $20.00
White Logo Shirt – Size Large $20.00
White Logo Shirt – Size Small $20.00
Black Logo Shirt – Size Large $20.00
White Logo Shirt – Size XL $20.00
BEVERAGES (3P)
Poland Spring $2.40
Topo Chico Mineral Water $4.20
Boylan Orange Soda $4.20
Boylan Root Beer $4.20
Cheerwine $4.20
Coke $4.20
Diet Coke $3.30
Boylan Grape Soda $4.20
Tropicana Apple Juice $3.00
Liquid Death Berry $4.20
Liquid Death Lime $4.20
Liquid Death Mango $3.50
Boylan’s Ginger Ale $3.50
Joe Lemonade $3.50
Joe Unsweetened Tea $3.50
Boylan Creme Soda $3.50
Joe Sweet Tea $3.50
Sprite $3.50
RETAIL (3P)
Black Logo Shirt – Size Large $24.00
White Logo Shirt – Size XL $24.00
Black Logo Shirt – Size XL $24.00
White Logo Shirt – Size Large $24.00
White Logo Shirt – Size Small $24.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Ham Taylor
Was heading to Wild Air Beerworks and saw this place on Google maps (about 2 blocks from the brewery). Being a big BBQ fan, I decided to pop in for a taste before the brewery. When I walked in, I was greeted by the smell of smoke, the sound of good punk music, and immediately greeted by a man who turned out to be the owner, Tom . I ordered a small portion since I had already eaten a big lunch a few hours earlier. While my food was being prepared, Tom showed me the smoker out back on the patio, and we talked about BBQ and punk music (two things that go great together). I got a quarter pound of brisket and a small coleslaw. The meat comes with pickles, pickled onions, and rolls. The brisket had a beautiful smoke ring and a ton of flavor. The smoke ring and the amount of fat left after the trim were perfect. The BBQ sauce tasted great and complimented the meat. The vinegar slaw was a perfect side. It was fresh and had a great vinegar bite to it. The pickles were dynamite, and the red onions went well with the dish. I washed it all down with a Cheerwine, which you just don’t see around NJ. Will definitely be making this a regular stop when I’m down in Asbury Park. A bonus is you can grab food at Mutiny and bring it over to Wild Air Beerworks.

… more

K Torch
Great little bbq joint with a very helpful and friendly staff!

… more

MS
Wow!! This is the best brisket I have ever had!! I can’t wait to go back. Mac n cheese, cornbread casserole, and Cole slaw equally delicious. Do not pass over this place. Free parking right in front the restaurant.

… more

John Diamantopoulos (IgneousRidder)
Absolutely phenomenal BBQ at great prices with a fun environment and great people up front to help out the newbies. Literally the best BBQ I’ve had and an absolute must for anyone who claims to be a fan of BBQ

… more

Kayla Chen
Had a great experience at Mutiny. They have a nice back patio that allows for pet friendly seating and the staff even gave her a water bowl. Prices were very reasonable and food was absolutely delicious, I had the pulled pork and brisket with cornbread casserole and they nicely paired everything with rolls, pickles, and picked onions to make some sandwiches. The staff was also really friendly and attentive. Definitely will be coming back!

… more

Daniel Bracey
Visited Mutiny today for lunch and was very impressed. The owner came over and talked to us for a little while and told us to check out the back patio qrea and smoker. The food is outstanding. The wings were not your average buffalo wings, but were delicious nonetheless and were good size. The pulled pork sandwich though was something else, in the best way. One of, if not the best, pulled pork sandwiches i have ever had. Not to mention everything was reasonably priced and good size portions. Will be recommending to friends and will certainly visit again!

… more

Mr. Jim Business
Wanted sometime different than the boardwalk food when in town. Now being from Alabama I know good BBQ so I made sure to order a healthy sample. I ordered the Mac and cheese, fries, turkey and wings togo. All food was hot and fresh when I arrived back at my hotel. Generous portions for great prices for traditional bbq. The fries are home cut crunchy fresh properly seasoned. The turkey breast moist, flavorful, tender. The wings could use a bit more sauce, packaged with blue cheese, I prefer ranch but they were out. The mac and cheese wasn’t the best, Al dente pasta with a basic homemade cheese sauce the pasta drowned in with a couple of cheese its on top. Worthy opponent for BBQ and I would eat here again

… more

Michael Herdeen
We absolutely love Mutiny BBQ. We started ordering from them when they were doing online ordering with pick up at shared kitchen space. So happy that they have a retail space now and more people can enjoy what I think is the best BBQ in NJ. Wishing you guys all the best!

… more

Gavin Conk
Great food and even better atmosphere. We sat in the nicely lit outdoor with a heater to keep us warm. Had a very cool smoker behind us with huge briskets smoking inside. Food came quick and very nice staff. I was allowed to bring my dog and they were very friendly like giving him a water bucket. They have spare ribs which are my favorite so points for that. Great soda selection! Coming here was not a disappointment!

… more

haley r
The food is absolutely outstanding! Not only are the prices reasonable, portions are extremely generous. I was looking at food places on the map near the beach and mutiny BBQ caught my eye. From the mouthwatering pictures in their reviews, I knew I needed to stop by. It was a 15 minute walk from the beach and it was absolutely worth going in. I 100% recommend going here. It was a nice surprise they have sprite with real cane sugar too. It’s now a personal goal to try their entire menu. Don’t skip out on dessert!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch