My New Joint Menu – Cudjoe Key, FL

Type : Oyster bar restaurant

Location : Cudjoe Key, FL

My New Joint 420 Lounge is located above the Square Grouper Bar and Grill. My New Joint is a Lounge that has a raw bar featuring fresh shucked and grilled oysters, stone crab claws (Oct 15-May 15) and peel and eat shrimp. Happy hour is from 4:20-6:30 daily featuring $6 well drinks. We offer 16 draft beers and 150 canned and bottled beers. Our wine list offers many wines by the glass as well as half bottle options. We have live music nightly. Our kitchen is open from 4:20-10 pm with lots of sharing plates, sandwiches and dinners. We have table shuffleboard, too! Come on in and enjoy yourselves!

Bar & grill dispatching innovative American small plates & mains in a sunny, contemporary setup. Based on 425 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

My New Joint 33042

Address:
22658 Overseas Hwy, Cudjoe Key, FL 33042

Phone: (305) 745-8880

Website: https://www.mynewjoint420lounge.com/

Social Profile:

Hours

Saturday 4:20–11 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday

(Labor Day)
Closed
Tuesday 4:20–11 PM
Wednesday 4:20–11 PM
Thursday 4:20–11 PM
Friday 4:20–11 PM

Menu

Let’s Eat
House Smoked Fish Dip
jalapeno | red onion | tomato
$14.00
Baked Artichoke & Spinach Dip
corn tortillas
$12.00
Ginormous Soft Pretzel
3 dipping Sauces: jalapeno cheese dip |sweet heat mustard | IPA mustard
$14.00
Mac & Cheese $9.00
Thai Chicken Lollipop Wings $15.00
Buffalo Chicken Lollipop Wings
Blue Cheese
$15.00
Empanadas
ever-changing
$13.00
Voodoo Shrimp
creamy cajun sauce
$16.00
Roasted Cauliflower
green curry sauce
$10.00
Raw Bar
Fresh Shucked Oysters
see raw bar selection on specials sheet | with cucumber jalapeno mignonette
Sandwiches
Mary Jane’s Blaze Burger
jalapeno cheese sauce | bacon jam
$16.00
Sauteéd Local Fish
key lime tartar
$17.00
8oz. Cheese Burger
onion rings | BBQ | bacon | white cheddar
$16.00
Sliders
Filet Mignon Sliders
onions | horseradish sauce
Fried Root Vegetables
Loaded Tater Tots
jalapeno cheese | bacon | scallions
$12.00
Shoe String Fries
parmesan | herbs | zesty ranch dip
$8.00
Crispy Tater Tots
ketchup | buffalo hot sauce
$8.00
Desserts
Magic Bar Sundae
butterscotch | coconut | walnuts | chocolate chips | graham cracker | warm chocolate sauce | caramel | salted caramel crunch ice cream
$9.00
Key Lime Pie $8.00
Fried Banana Split
rice paper wrapped | salted caramel crunch ice cream | cinnamon sugar | praline pecans
$9.00
Cocktails
Ian’s Gin Drank
Fords Gin, triple sec, lemon & lime juice, honey basil
$12.00
Nick’s 420 Kush
Captain Morgan, Malibu, Midori, pineapple juice, fresh lime juice, simple syrup
$12.00
Purple Trainwreck
Tito’s Vodka, fresh pomegranate juice, fresh lime juice & simple syrup
$12.00
Mary’s Mother
Chilled Absolute Pear Vodka, St. Germain, Proseco
$12.00
Maple Smoke Manhattan
Maker’s Mark, sweet vermouth, Vermont maple syrup, bacon
$15.00
Hemingway Haze
Pilar White Rum & fresh lime juice
$12.00
Bubba Kush Mule
Pilar White Rum & Ginger Beer
$11.00
Indica
Torched rosemary infused Tito’s Vodka, fresh lime & grapefruit
$12.00
Strawberry Grouper
Tito’s Vodka, fresh strawberries, basil, house made ginger syrup
$13.00
Bubonic Chronic Margarita
Tanteo Jalepeño infused tequila, fresh lime & simple syrup
$11.00
Fresh Strawberry Margarita
Milagro, fresh strawberries, agave, fresh lime juice
$12.00
Gin
(Mule) Tanqueray London Dry Gin, fresh lime juice and ginger beer
$11.00
Cucumber Mule
Ketel One Citroen, Fresh muddled cucumber, fresh lime juice and ginger beer
$11.00
Rosie’s Mule
BSB Bourbon Whiskey, fresh lime juice and ginger beer
$11.00
Blueberry Yum Yum
Stoli Blueberry, fresh lime, pomegranate juice, Proseco
$12.00
Gold Rush
Bulleit Bourbon, fresh lemon juice, locally sourced honey
$12.00
Southern Tea
Deep Eddy Sweet Tea Vodka, fresh lemonade, club soda
$11.00
Hot Box
Effen Cucumber Vodka, fresh grapefruit, fresh jalapeño
$12.00
Cafe Con Leche
Tito’s Vodka, Kahlua, Godiva White Chocolate, fresh espresso
$14.00
Gin & Juice
Nolet’s Gin, Fresh lime & grapefruit juice, simple syrup, rosemary
$11.00
Hurricane
Captain Morgan Spiced Rum, fresh OJ & lime, passion fruit, grenadine
$12.00
Spicy Paloma
Milagro, grapefruit juice, Ancho Chili Liqueur, fresh lime & club soda
$12.00
Ray’s Key West Old Fashion
Pilar Dark Rum, cherry juice, local cinnamon honey, spiced cherry bitters
$13.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Julie Schwartz
Great place. I prefer over Square Grouper on theain level due to typically no wait, and yet decent food although less variety than the Square. Nice appetizers, drinks, and limited main courses, but everything is quality a delicious. Never been disappointed. Great deserts, I recommend the Magic Bar. The cheese flight was generous compared to most. Always cheerful atmosphere and service.

… more

Timothy Potter
Went here with family and had terrible service. Not for tourist. Rude staff from wait staff to bartender. Cocktails were below average, nothing special for the price. My drink was all juice barely any vodka. Would not recommend to anyone with kids or family. Consider going else where. Parking lot is a nightmare as well.

… more

Victoria Leigh Music
i have been playing music here for the last 6 or 7 years and I look forward to coming down each month for a plethora of reasons.

… more

Blaine Dockery
The square grouper is our favorite restaurant in the Florida Keys. The clean, modern, nautical theme is unmatched. The food and service is top notch. Downstairs is the more traditional dining area and upstairs is also a dining area but with also a large bar to sit at and live music.

… more

Dennis Voulopos
We really enjoyed ourselves, the food, drinks and music, fantastic! The plates and small but sharable and service was perfect. Get the Voodoo shrimp, so good we got a secend one. And the draft selection is awesome, something for everyone not just IPA lovers.

… more

K C
I had a great waiter Traci who was very attentive and fast with serving our food, she was tipped very well. Chris the bartender was rude, unprofessional, and just a flat out jerk. He got mad cause we didn’t tip the 1st drink cause we waited over 30mins and watched him serve other people their drinks that ordered after us. when we went back to purchase more drinks, he refused to serve us. Said he doesn’t work for free. His exact words were “why didn’t you tip me the last time? You’re going to have to find another server to make your drinks” we were such is shock that he said that. When we wanted management to help us out, he sided with the server and said that’s how it is in the keys. Again, left in shock. Idk who trains these people but they’re not doing it right. If you don’t get a tip it’s cause your service sucked. The owners response to our review said we sounded entitled. This time I’m not shocked but glad everyone else can see the type of people you’re gonna deal with.

… more

Matt Harris
By FAR the BEST food I’ve had in the keys! The atmosphere is great too with live music, classy ambiance and friendly staff who really know the menu. Just go here! You won’t be disappointed. Shout out to Evan for serving up an AWESOME experience! We’ll be back!

… more

Susan Thomas
Really nice place. I had the boiled shrimp and fish sandwich with fries. The shrimp were hard to peel and sandwich bun was dry. The fish was tasty. Wait staff was excellent. Fast seating and fast service.

… more

Gregory Eagle
Ok, I waited until my second visit to give my opinion. I have not much else to say other than THIS PLACE HAS THE BEST FOOD IN THE REGION. PERIOD. The best beer selection you could ever ask for an a super friendly and knowledgeable staff. My New Joint is MY NEW JOINT!!! And the prices are not what you’d think. Check this place out!

… more

Isabella Lopez
Over priced, very rude, small serving sizes, and watered down drinks that are over filled with ice. Do not waste your money at “my new joint”. There are better places in the keys than this restaurant which are more friendly and better bank for your buck. As a proud conch I am super disappointed in this restaurant. Please train staff better!!!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions