Where Lobster is our MAINE Event.
If you are looking for a local favorite when exploring the East Coast, look no further than Mystic Lobster Roll Company in Red Bank, New Jersey!
Freshly shelled lobster meat served in a variety of ways. We offer many different lobster roll combinations, all served on a toasted roll. Other menu items include; tacos, sliders, soup, appetizers and many more! Come check us out at and try our delicious and unique creations at our brand new shop in Red Bank, NJ.
Based on 19 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
205 W Front St, Red Bank, NJ 07701
Phone: (732) 268-7904
Website: https://www.mysticlobsterrollsredbank.com/
Hours
| Tuesday |
Closed |
| Wednesday |
12–8 PM |
| Thursday |
12–8 PM |
| Friday |
12–8 PM |
| Saturday |
12–8 PM |
| Sunday |
12–8 PM |
| Monday |
Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Matthew Valle
As many have mentioned the portion size was very, very small. What you see in the picture is just sitting on top of the roll it’s hardly even open ed. Taste was ok for the roll. Not anything to write home about. I also got the lobster bisque soup which ok as well. Best comparison is Kirkland Lobster bisque.
… more
Ben Magovern
Aside from the amazing food, the service was first class! I received my food quickly, the employees at the desk were super nice, and the actual food was to die for. I got a soup and a Deep South roll, which I really recommend! Not only was the taste great, but you could really taste the freshness of the fish, which is rare to find around here. Overall, I had a great experience and would 100% go back!
… more
TitiBella
My husband and I went here craving a lobster roll. So we got the colossal roll for an additional $10. What a joke this was $30 each for something that would fill only a toddler. If I would’ve known I would had got the regular roll. Lucky we got the potatoes that filled us up. I should’ve known when we went there and the place was empty. I’ll stick with Cousins Maine Lobster in Asbury Park there regular lobster roll is a colossal size.
… more
Joy Cady
The lobster rolls were amazing and full of tender lobster meat.
… more
Bunnie Leftwich-Phillips
The lobster meat came from the claws, no flavor and it was previously frozen. It took 25 minutes for the 2 lobster rolls. The pickle and Cole slaw were good.
… more
Nick Finley
Just ate at your red bank location – Kevin is the best. He’s very knowledgeable and passionate about his job. Answered all of our questions with a smile and made sure we were satisfied. Food was amazing, we will be back!
… more
Don Odegard
They had us at lobster roll.
… more
Rian Rivera
i wish i took a picture first of all highly overpriced for the not so fresh lobster meat.
… more
sam coppallo
The best. . Wow last 3 reviews are bad. Seems like the company is making the competition scared. Here’s realty this company puts out some of the most amazing lobster rolls. See for your self and ignore the lie reviews
… more
John Kilar
The food was very good and the staff where very kind. The restaurant was very clean and they also had my food out fast.
… more
… View more
