Nancy’s Bar-B-Q Menu – Sarasota, FL

Type : Restaurant

Location : Sarasota, FL

Since 2004 we have been smoking and serving authentic BBQ in a family friendly environment in our dining rooms and full bar in downtown Sarasota; voted Best BBQ for 12 straight years; the area’s #1 BBQ caterer. We smoke brisket, pork, chicken, ribs, sausage, wings, whole hogs, portobello mushrooms and fillet of salmon fresh every day on the premises in two 500-lb capacity wood smokers. We serve 16 handmade sides: smoked baked beans, baked mac & cheese, creamy cole slaw, sesame crunch slaw, potato salad, cucumber salad, edamame succotash, collard greens, cornbread, brisket chili, green beans, potatoes au gratin, fries, tots, potato chips plus entree-size fresh salads, appetizers & daily specials. Kids menu, Happy Hour Mon-Fri. Open 7 days.

Based on 12 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Nancy's Bar-B-Q 34236

Address:
1525 4th St Unit C, Sarasota, FL 34236

Phone: (941) 999-2390

Website:

Hours

Saturday 11 AM–10 PM
Sunday 11 AM–8 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
 11 AM–9 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday 11 AM–9 PM
Friday 11 AM–10 PM

Menu

APPETIZER
BOAT OF FRIES $6.95
BURNT END CHILI $8.95
CHIPS & SALSA $4.95
LORRAINE ROAD NACHOS $9.95
SMOKED FISH DIP $9.95
SMOKED QUESADILLA $8.95
SMOKED SLIDER TRIO $11.95
SMOKED WINGS $11.95
BUFFALO DIP $10.95
BULK A LA CARTE
ALMONDS $0.50
BACON $0.50
BEEF BRISKET 1# $29.95
BEEF BRISKET 1# EXTRA LEAN $31.95
BEEF BRISKET 1/2 # EXTRA LEAN $17.95
BEEF BRISKET 1/2# $16.95
BLUE CHEESE $0.50
BLUE CHEESE CRUMBLES $0.50
BRISKET CHILI PINT $8.95
CHEESE $0.50
CHICKEN 1/2 $11.95
CHICKEN 1/4 DARK $5.95
CHICKEN 1/4 WHITE $6.95
CHICKEN WHOLE EACH $17.95
HORSERADISH SAUCE $0.50
PULLED CHICKEN 1# $16.95
PULLED CHICKEN 1/2# $8.95
PULLED PORK 1# $16.95
PULLED PORK 1/2# $8.95
RANCH $0.50
RIBS – ST. LOUIS STYLE 1/2 SLAB $15.95
RIBS-ST. LOUIS STYLE SLAB $27.95
SALMON FILLET 1# $28.95
SALMON FILLET- COLD 1/2# $15.95
SAUTEED ONIONS $0.50
SOLO PULLED CHICKEN SANDWICH $8.45
SOLO PULLED PORK SANDWICH $8.45
DESSERTS
BANANA PUDDING $4.95
BREAD PUDDING $4.95
BROWNIE $2.95
CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE $2.95
KEY LIME PIE $4.95
PINEAPPLE UPSIDE DOWN CAKE $4.95
WHITE CHOCOLATE MACADAMIA COOKIE $2.95
ENTREES
2 LINKS TRAY
2 Links on top of 2 Slices of Fresh Bread, w/ Side Creole Mustard, 1 Side		 $12.95
2 PULLED PORK TACOS
2oz of Pulled Pork in Each Tortilla w/ Cucumber Dill Sour Cream & Salsa on the side w/ 1 Side		 $11.95
2 SLIDERS
2 Slider Rolls w/ 2oz Protein w/ 1 Side		 $12.95
BEEF BRISKET TRAY
7oz of Beef Brisket w/ 1 side		 $17.45
CHILLED SALMON TRAY
5oz Chilled Smoked Salmon on a Bed of Lettuce and a slice of tomato w/ Cucumber Dill Sour Cream and 1 Side		 $14.45
FULL SLAB
12 St. Louis Rib Bones Cut w/ 1 Side		 $29.95
HALF SLAB
6 St. Louis Rib Bones Cut w/ 1 Side		 $18.95
HAY BALER TAKE OUT $183.95
PULLED CHICKEN TRAY
7oz Pulled Chicken w/ 1 side		 $13.95
PULLED PORK TRAY
7oz Pulled Pork w/ 1 side		 $13.95
PULLED PORK & CHICKEN
4oz Pulled Chicken or 1/4 Chicken, 4oz Pulled Pork, 4oz Side		 $13.45
TEXAS HOLY TRINITY
1/2 Slab of Ribs & 4oz of Brisket w/ or w/o Texas Hot Link or Mild Kielbasa Link w/ 1 side		 $28.95
PORK/RIBS/BRISKET/CHICKEN
7oz Pulled Pork or Chicken and 7oz Beef Brisket or 6 Ribs, 1 4oz Side 1 Dab of Cold Side, 1 Slice Bread		 $20.95
TRACTOR PULL TAKE OUT $124.95
FAMILY CRATES
GAME DAY 20 WINGS $58.95
BRISKET FANTASY CRATE $164.95
GAME DAY WINGS & RIB COMBO $124.95
MEAL DEAL CRATE $89.95
RIB FEAST CRATE $139.95
STOCK THE FRIDGE CRATE $149.95
WING & PULLED PORK COMBO $99.95
FARM & OCEAN
BONE IN 1/4 CHICKEN DARK $10.95
BONE IN 1/4 CHICKEN WHITE $11.95
BONE IN 1/2 CHICKEN $14.95
BONE IN WHOLE CHICKEN $18.95
NA BEVS
20oz Drink $2.95
Aqua Panna $3.75
Arnold Palmer $2.95
IBC Root Beer $3.25
Juice Box $1.25
Lemonade $2.95
San Pelligrino $3.75
Sweet Tea $2.95
Tea Gallon $6.95
Tea Half Gallon $4.95
Tea Quart $2.95
Unsweet Tea $2.95
Water Cup $0.00
SANDWICHES
BEEF BRISKET
Fresh Potato Roll, 4oz Sliced Brisket		 $14.95
BEEF O RAMA
Toasted Ciabatta Roll, 6oz Sliced Brisket, carmalized Onions, Horseradish Sauce		 $16.95
BRISKET DEBRIS
Toasted Ciabatta Roll, 6oz Brisket, BBQ Sauce, Salsa, Scallions, Blue Cheese,Bacon		 $16.95
CHICKEN DEBRIS
Toasted Ciabatta Roll, 6oz Pulled Chicken, BBQ Sauce, Salsa, Scallions, Blue Cheese, Bacon		 $15.95
INTERSTATE CHEESE STEAK
Toasted Ciabatta Roll, 6oz Beef Brisket, topped w/ Provolone Cheese,Smoked Portobello Mushroom,Carmelized Onions & Homemade Creamy horseradish Sauce 2 Sides		 $17.95
PULLED CHICKEN SANDWICH
Fresh Potato Roll, 4oz Pulled Chicken		 $11.95
PULLED PORK SANDWICH
Fresh Potato Roll, 4oz Pulled Pork,		 $11.95
PULLED PORK DEBRIS
Toasted Ciabatta Roll, 6oz Pulled Pork, BBQ Sauce,Salsa, Scallions, Blue Cheese, Bacon		 $15.95
SLOPPY JIM $10.95
SMOKED PORTABELLA
Fresh Potato Roll, 4oz Smoked Portabella Mushroom, Crunch Slaw		 $11.95
SWINE SQUARED
Toasted Ciabatta Roll 6oz Pulled Pork, BBQ Sauce, Bacon, Sesame Crunch Slaw, Bread & Butter Pickles		 $14.95
SIDES
3OZ BRISKET CHILI $2.95
4 SIDES $13.95
4OZ BRISKET $9.95
4OZ CHICKEN $5.95
4OZ PORK $5.95
BAKED MAC AND CHEESE $3.95
BIG BUN (ONE) $0.75
CHEESY GRITS $3.95
CIABATTA ROLL $0.75
COLLARD GREENS $3.95
CREAMY COLE SLAW $3.95
CREAMY POTATOES AU GRATIN $3.95
CUCUMBER SALAD $3.95
DOZEN SLIDER ROLLS $4.95
EDAMAME SUCCOTASH $3.95
Finishing Sauce $6.95
HOUSE MADE CORNBREAD $1.95
KETTLE POTATO CHIPS $1.50
NANCY’S BAR B Q SAUCE $7.95
ONE LINK $5.45
ONE TACO $4.95
PINT BAKED MAC AND CHEESE $11.95
PINT CHEESY GRITS $11.95
PINT COLLARD GREENS $11.95
PINT CREAMY COLE SLAW $11.95
PINT CREAMY POTATOES AU GRATIN $11.95
PINT CUCUMBER SALAD $11.95
PINT EDAMAME SUCCOTASH $11.95
PINT GREEN BEANS $11.95
PINT RED SKIN POTATO SALAD $11.95
PINT SESAME CRUNCH SLAW $11.95
PINT SMOKED BAKED BEANS $11.95
PINT TATOR TOTS (3 PORTIONS) $11.95
RED SKIN POTATO SALAD $3.95
SEASONAL LOCAL VEGETABLE $3.95
SESAME CRUNCH SLAW $3.95
SIDE FRIES $3.95
SLIDER ROLL(ONE) $0.45
SMOKED BAKED BEANS $3.95
TATOR TOTS $3.95
SOUP/SALAD
BRISKET “BURNT ENDS” CHILI
A spicy blend w/ tomatoes, red peppers, onions, celery & kidney beans, w/ scallions, creme fraiche & salsa. Served w/ Cornbread		 $11.95
CHOPPED SALAD $10.95
SOUTHERN CAESAR $9.95

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Cheryl Banks
Tonight was their first night. Food was on par with the old location. Actually enjoyed it more. Had the ribs and sliders. Yum! Great atmosphere in the new location. Lots of character in this building. It was buzzing. Full house and things flowed easily. Staff well trained and happy. Very enjoyable experience. Check them out!

… more

Jim Johnson
Erik and Bianca at the bar made my visit to Nancy’s exceptional. Great food, attentive service and friendly atmosphere. Would recommend!

… more

Papa Whiskey Adventures
A BBQ restaurant generally has 4 staple items, Pulled Pork, Pulled Chicken, Brisket, and Ribs. But, when you’re out of 50% of those items, I have to question why you’re even open.

… more

Tom Mckenna
Thrilled to have Nancy’s in Rosemary! Ordered take out for 8 ppl. Everything was perfect. My clan was thrilled & are looking forward to enjoying more Nancy’s! Matty took the order & had it ready on time as planned.

… more

laurie kassman
Food is fab as always but two critiques: people come for the great food, not the LOUD music that makes it hard to have a conversation …and surprised to see styrofoam cups and plastic straws not good for environment, not biodegradable

… more

Melanie Sica
First visit. Definitely won’t be the last. The ribs were outstanding.

… more

Steve Stoneburner
We love Nancy’s BBQ. We were there today and she came by our table and talked with us. It’s great to have her back in Sarasota.

… more

Capt. Carp
Thank goodness they came back to downtown we missed them so much!! This is the only legit BBQ in the area. Best brisket I’ve ever had and the ribs and pulled pork are a 10.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch