Based on 420 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
894 SW Federal Hwy, Stuart, FL 34994
Phone: (772) 888-3182
Website: http://nancysitalianrestaurant.com/
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
James Gibney
Nancy’s is amazing! You definitely need to try the garlic knots. They offered to add extra mozzarella to the garlic knots and they were great. My daughters had the kid’s spaghetti and meatballs and the kid’s pizza buffalo. Both were fantastic. I never heard so much yum and oh this is so good from them. The Burrata pizza surpassed the pictures. Enjoy your trip to flavor town. Forgive the Zeppole picture. We were stuffed but had to order them. I’d try the Zeppole stuffed with cannoli but we just couldn’t handle it today. Something to look forward to for next time. Thank you for the wonderful service. Truly a wonderful gem here in Stuart.
… more
Dawn Wade
Amazing Italian food. We had the fresh burrata, which was amazing. We then had the eggplant, which was the best I’ve ever had. This is a serious gem! The service is on point and while the atmosphere is unfussy, it’s clean and the music choice is great.
… more
Mark Marrical
So we were visiting the area, and Nancy’s was recommended to us for pizza. WOW! IT WAS EXCELLENT! Great pizza! We enjoyed the clams in the white wine and also tried their baked ziti. We enjoyed it so much we went back for another dinner in the week we were visiting. The staff was friendly and attentive. Definitely a great restaurant. The food was excellent and it was not expensive. Definitely stop in and enjoy some good food!
… more
PILAR SOLIS
Funny story we went to this shopping plaza to a sushi place but it was close.
… more
Nehemiah Spencer
Service was excellent here. Food was strikingly delicious, and was served almost unbelievably promptly. The restroom was very clean. The price was fantastic. These good folks fully deserve their high ratings and we most certainly intend to return! A+! Thank you!
… more
George E. Cooper III
Fantastic food and staff. Had the mussels one pound in red sauce so good I ordered a second pound in white sauce to see which was better. They both tied with a score of glorious. I was moaning as I ate them like some kind of graphic experience. Garlic knots, and then a small pizza to go and all was perfect in the Universe. You deserve to eat here once before you die.
… more
Dawn Pecci
A great deal on a slice of cheese Pizza, only $2.55 ea. and it’s huge! However, if you wanted a Cheese Lasagna, you’ll pay $17.95! As much as this place is nice, quaint, friendly employees and owner’s I feel the high prices will keep me away except a slice for lunch. Oh, I can’t write this review without mentioning what Nancy’s is famous for their GIANT Meatballs! Literally the biggest Meatball I’ve seen and the table near us ordered it with Spaghetti, I watched as she split that dish with her husband, Unsure of the price on that?
… more
Kasey Sorensen
Super disappointed… we have been loyal customers of Nancy’s for about 4 years- it was even my choice of meal when I went into labor before we went to the hospital we actually stopped here to eat, however after tonight we may be done based on one small principle. We ordered delivery through Uber eats this evening. The order was completely wrong. It was not Uber eats fault as I was told by Nancy’s, they don’t make the food. I saw the receipt and it was clear what my order was. Things were missing, things were wrong, etc. I contacted Uber eats to no avail. I then contacted Nancy’s and reordered a meal that was completely incorrect and said we would just come grab it quickly. They charged us for it, full price, and even charged us for an extra side of ranch dressing. I’m sorry but this is no way to treat loyal customers. We received subpar dinners and DOUBLE PAID because the restaurant was wrong. About 80% of the meal was wrong, all we did was re order one thing and deal with the remaining of the wrong meal and they had the audacity to charge us for the re-do. Super disappointed and I’m all set with this place going forward. We spent over 130$ on a meal we didn’t even want, so wrong.
… more
Marisol rodriguez
Well this is based off garlic knots and garlic parmesan wings. They had no flavor besides the excessive amount of garlic that we could not even eat but I can say the cashier’s customer service was GREAT!!! I didn’t get her name but she was sweet enough to take my order over the phone and come out to my car for the payment being that I had a newborn in the car. That would be a reason to give them another try.
… more
Kamaria Kuhn
We started with the garlic knots and I ordered the Burrata pizza with added grilled chicken, spinach and mushrooms. Hands down this place was amazing, the pizza crust was crispy, flavor was off the chart; the garlic knot was fluffy with generous amounts of garlic and that marinara sauce is incredible! I’d been eyeing this place since it opened last year! It was worth the wait! The staff was friendly and attentive. I will definitely be back to try more items.
… more
… View more