Chicago-style stuffed pizza is the draw at this restaurant also offering thin-crust pies & pastas. Based on 345 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
3965 2007, State Hwy K, O’Fallon, MO 63366
Phone: (636) 272-2223
Website: http://www.nancyspizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
4–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Erin Gohil
Jason did a great job on our pizzas last night! Perfectly assembled and nice ratio of cheese, toppings and sauce. Both pizzas were delicious, we eat here a few times a month and what we had yesterday was the best order by far.
… more
T Takagi
Nancy’s is strictly take out. There is no seating. Hwr, the pizza is great, meatball trio is fantastic and on repeat and their new chopped salad is very good. Rustic crust Nana’s is our favorite. Deep-dish is very good but one slice is a meal in itself. People are always friendly and professional, and our orders are always ready faster than their quote. We no longer order pizza from anywhere else.
… more
Shane Blackledge
Excellent deep dish Chicago pizza. The sauce and cheese is so good! Every bite reminds me of pizza in Chicago. Highly recommend this place. You won’t be disappointed.
… more
Dylan Wilson
This was a very good pie with well balanced flavors. I enjoy this style of deep dish once in a while and Nancy’s really nailed it! Better than any other deep dish in the county. I really appreciate the consistency of the pizza, it is the same every time. The garlic cheese bread is good, but nothing special. If you want a good deep dish with a great balance of tomato to cheese and whatever topping you want, give this ppave a shot!
… more
Samantha Hillis
This pizza is so dang good and so stuffing! In true fashion of Chicago-style pizza, my two teenage boys and I couldn’t even finish half a pizza! We moved here recently from out-of-state, and didn’t really how spoiled we were with NY style pizza. The bar was set high. We had several locals recommend Imos and my family and I did not enjoy the weird, sweet flatbread type pizza. We almost gave up hope finding good pizza here, and then we stumbled across Nancy’s. What a godsend this place is to the world of pizza! Hope has been renewed! We will certainly be frequent customers.
… more
Lyndsey Elliott
I was disappointed to find that there was no dine in option, but that’s not the biggest issue. I was not even able to taste the pizza, as it was a 45-60 minute wait on take out. The lobby was empty, and I’m sure there were call in orders, but for 2:00pm an hour wait for a pizza seems a bit much. If you’re delivery or carry out only, you would think the wait time would be something to work on. We went across the street and enjoyed Chipotle instead.
… more
Jason Green
I follow them on Facebook and have tried it once before and thought it was a little pricey for what you get. I had an ad pop up from 8 days ago for a 19 dollar deep dish and tried to order online. I was told that the 8 day ago ad expired 3 weeks ago. I wanted to order a 3 topping that I knew would be more than the advertisement and a large 3 topping came to 34 dollars. I told the young lady I dont want to pay 34 dollars for a large 3 topping pizza and she said ok great and hung up on me. Never in this conversation was I ever rude to her. I even asked if they had any other specials and was told no we don’t do specials. I’ve had the pizza once and it was really good but there are alot of pizza places that will sell a large 14 inch 3 topping pizza for reasonable prices.
… more
Lucy D. Monkey
Overall both their Deep Dish and Original Thin pizzas are pretty decent (3 star) if you like something different, and a ton of sauce, the Deep Dish is the way to go.
… more
Peter Rager
Excellent place for authentic Chicago-style pizza! Truly a hidden gem! Always a dependably delicious pie! Highly recommend! Online Ordering was a breeze! AAA+++!!!
… more
Mrs. S
My hubby grew up in Chicago, and he requested Nancy’s Chicago-style pizza for his birthday a few days ago. I am southern and do NOT enjoy Chicago-style pizza, so we ordered one Chicago and one thin. Hubby and son reported that they really enjoyed the bowl of pizza, as I call it, and I really enjoyed my pizza, which was loaded with cheese and pepperoni, it was delicious!
… more
… View more