Based on 103 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
126 Broadway St, Shelby, OH 44875
Phone: (419) 342-7066
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–1 PM, 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–1 PM, 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–1 PM, 4–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–1 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–1 PM, 4–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–1 PM, 4–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
tony coleman
I would have posted a picture but literally within minutes of bringing back to work it was eaten in a blink of an eye. This pizza Stewart has been in the game long enough to know what makes a great pie. Ask for them to make it as crispy as possible. If their are black bubbles it’s not burnt it’s the crispy goodness of perfection. Was gonna do a Portnoy style review but we ate it too quick. Take the time and go get their pizza. This man knows his stuff and the crust alone is worth getting.
… more
Don Schroeder
Had a great 5 item thin crust pizza . Very tasty
… more
Keith Maxim
Pizza looked good in photos, so I ordered 2 for pickup. When I arrived, I must have yelled hello anyone here for 3 minutes straight. As I waited I looked around and the place was a mess. Several pizza boxes on the counter probably to be used that day, but dishes, restaurant items, towels, and miscellaneous items everywhere. It looked like my neighbors garage not a pizza business that had tables where people were to sit and eat.
… more
Tracey Mason
Amazing pizza been going here since I was a little kid
… more
Alexander Hillis
I travel for work and have been to a lot of pizza restaurants…I have also had a lot of subpar pizzas. It’s always nice to stumble on a small town restaurant that does their food really well, and this pizza was done well. The owner was talkative and mentioned that he reads pizza trade magazines and seemed to be genuinely interested in the craft of making pizza. Good for him for bothering to make a great product in a small market.
… more
Heather Stevens
We had this pizza place highly recommended to us. We were a bit skeptical, but man, it was so good. The crust was really good, the sauce was on the sweeter side and not spicy at all. The pizza was a little on the pricey side, but if you’re gonna splurge on a mom and pop pizza place, I’d recommend this place.
… more
John K
Unfortunately the first time I have ever been here! Worst pizza ever and quite possibly rudest worker I have ever came across! Literally very little to no sauce at all! Wish I could add a picture to show everyone! If you order extra cheese you may want to order triple cheese when we asked why there wasn’t cheese on the one corner and was told that’s were the crust bubbled up so there would be any cheese there. LMAO!!! I have order enough pizza in my life to know better!
… more
chelsa young
Best pizza in shelby hands down
… more
Chad Patrick
Below average pizza with extremely rude employees. The guy was rude on the phone when ordering and didn’t like that I asked questions. Stated it was my fault that I didn’t have Facebook to see a menu. I will never go back to this dirt floor pizza place. This must be why most tell me not to eat there.
… more
Out Here
Truck driver here: I got stuck at the local industrial park for the evening/night because of other people’s massive incompetence. Thought maybe some pizza would help ease the sting of the pretty terrible work week overall, and the fact that I should’ve been able to make it home today. Well, nothing can substitute for spending time with my girlfriend and her children, but a good pizza did make the day a bit better. Got a medium w/ pepperoni & mushrooms, & I did not regret the 1.6 miles round trip walk to get it. Got some exercise and enjoyed a tasty meal afterwards.
… more
… View more