Based on 232 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.2 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
1159 Blair St, Silverton, CO 81433
Phone: (970) 387-5300
Website: http://www.natalias1912.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10:30 AM–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: natalias1912.com
Reviews
Valerie Reyes
My family and I really enjoyed the outdoor seating, we went during the week and it was nice and quiet and the waiter spoke Spanish which was really nice for my family. We got chips and salsa which were good and the salad bar was also neat.
… more
Angela Stumpf
This was a great dining experience. Our group each had a different kind of burger and one person had a Mexican dish. All were very good. The restaurant was very clean, the staff very friendly and the service was very prompt. Definitely a must visit in the town of Silverton.
… more
Pat Neil
The prices were high – which we expected. But dang, this food was not good! My husband had a Buffalo burger which he payed extra to get cheese on and the cheese was literally a handful of shredded, unmelted cheese. Not good, walk a little further and find something good! Service was pretty good though, and despite the influx of people getting off the train or food was pretty quick.
… more
addison
this is the most under seasoned boring lunch of all time. we sampled like 6 different entrees but literally none of them had any seasoning whatsoever. we got the chicken soup and the chicken was undercooked. we covered everything in hot sauce and it was still a slog to get through. service was nice tho
… more
Michael Reed
Stopped for lunch during the round trip train ride. The buffet is highly overrated! All they had was a basic salad bar and small hot food area. Hot food was fried chicken or Swedish meatballs. Rolls, corn, sauerkraut, peas and mashed potatoes. Small selection and big price. We suggest trying a different restaurant while in town.
… more
Robyn Barker
Not a bad choice if you arrive on the train. Not that there is much choice. Our service was terrible. People who came in after us were finished eating by the time we were served. Our bill took forever, which was okay since it was raining anyway. On the plus side, most people seemed to get fed relatively quickly which was an achievement since we all arrived at the same time! The kitchen was on the ball at least! Our Reuben’s were very tasty.
… more
Joe Wadleigh
Wife and I have enjoyed this place every time. Ribeye was great, pasta was great. Very fast service. We’ll be back
… more
Zach
Wow—quite literally the worst food I can recall ever buying. The atmosphere is alright. The restrooms are questionable. The price is high but expected given the touristy location. Sitting was really fast. But again, the food was truly awful!
… more
Matthew Nanney
Upon disembarking our beautiful Durango-Silverton railroad experience, we were beyond excited to see what the historic town of Silverton had to offer us. Unfortunately, Natalia’s 1912 restaurant was more like encountering a nightmare or a scary movie. The food was not only over-priced, but overall the food tasted like a Hungry Man Swanson’s meal meets prison-food. The staff appeared to be overworked and never came to check on our party until our meal was unfortunately consumed. Out of hundreds of cities and restaurants we have enjoyed across this fair land, this was undoubtedly the worst meal and experience of our lives. We left zero tip and left disappointed and cheated. I wish I had my money back and the time I wasted sitting in this pitiful establishment.
… more
Kiefer Thomas
I stopped in here for a new place to try in Silverton. I love the town and come here often. Sadly, Natalia’s grossly disappointed. The establishment felt very…tired and old; like the place was living on borrowed time. It was not a welcoming feeling.
… more
… View more