Natalie’s Cafe & Catering Menu – Batesville, AR

Type : American restaurant

Location : Batesville, AR

Based on 317 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Natalie's Cafe & Catering 72501

Address:
3050 Harrison St, Batesville, AR 72501

Phone: (870) 698-0200

Website:

Hours

Friday 11 AM–3 PM
Saturday Closed
Sunday Closed
Monday

(Labor Day)
Closed

Holiday hours
Tuesday 11 AM–3 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–3 PM
Thursday 11 AM–3 PM

Menu

Main Entrees
Cajun Shrimp Pasta With Green Beans $14.85
Openface Pot Roast $14.85
Oven Roasted Chicken & Veggies $14.25
Cheesy Chicken Spaghetti $13.15
The Natalie’s Experience
Create Your Plate!
Choose your main course, bread, and a side.
$10.75
Salads and Such
Natalie’s Own Salad – Half Size
Oven Roasted Chicken atop spring mix, strawberries, pecans, madarin oranges, and feta cheese.
$10.50
Natalie’s Own Salad – Full Size
Oven Roasted Chicken atop spring mix, strawberries, pecans, madarin oranges, and feta cheese.
$13.50
Gwynn’s Garden Salad – Half Size
Choice of Chicken or Turkey with cucumbers, tomatoes, cheese, and your choice of dressing.
$10.15
Gwynn’s Garden Salad – Full Size
Choice of Chicken or Turkey with cucumbers, tomatoes, cheese, and your choice of dressing.
$12.55
Shrimp And Avocado Supreme – Half Size
Our baby shrimp mix on top of shredded lettuce & sliced avocado and topped with fresh tomatoes and cucumber with choice of side or soup.
$11.50
Shrimp And Avocado Supreme – Full Size
Our baby shrimp mix on top of shredded lettuce & sliced avocado and topped with fresh tomatoes and cucumber with choice of side or soup.
$14.50
Tomato Wedge Salad
with Chicken Salad, Cajun Chicken Salad or Tuna Salad with crackers.
$9.19
Pick 3 Plate
Choose any 3 of our sides. Please specify in comments if you would like double or triple of one side.
$10.75
Pick 4 Plate
Choose any 4 of our sides. Please specify in comments if you would like double or triple of one side.
$14.99
Premium Salads
Chicken Salad $6.50
Soups
Beefy Cabbage
Selections change daily. Served with crackers.
$4.89
Paninis
Chicken Salad Panini
Natalie’s famous chicken salad with Swiss cheese on sourdough.
$13.75
Cody’s Chicken Club Panini
Chicken, bacon, spicy ranch sauce, Colby Jack cheese on sourdough.
$13.75
Reuben Panini
Corned beef, sauerkraut, thousand island dressing, & Swiss cheese on rye.
$13.75
Turkey Panini
Turkey, tomato, dried basil, creamy Italian sauce, pepper jack cheese on sourdough.
$13.75
Veggie Panini
Mix of roasted squash, zucchini, peppers, & Swiss cheese on sourdough.
$12.75
Ham & Swiss Slider Panini
Ham, Swiss, poppy seed slider sauce on sourdough with slider sauce.
$13.75
Kids Only
Kid’s Grilled Cheese
with fruit, chips, or choice of other side.
$8.50
Kid’s Cheesy Chicken Spaghetti
with green beans or other side.
$8.50
Kid’s Peanut Butter & Grape Jelly
on with bread with chips, mac & cheese, fruit, or other side.
$8.50
Kid’s Deli Ham & American Cheese
on white bread with chips, mac & cheese, fruit, or other side.
$8.50
Desserts
White Wedding Cake Cupcake With Buttercream Frosting $2.30
Croissant $1.44
Sliced Desserts $4.89
Sandwiches and Such
Natalie’s Club
Ham, turkey, bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, mayo on toasted white bread.
$13.95
BLT Sandwich
with Mayo on toasted wheat & choice of side or soup.
$11.85
Grilled Cheese
with Potato Chips or choice of side or soup.
$8.50
Frito Pie With Cheese
Large bowl layered with Fritos, shredded cheese, and our chili with beans.
$9.75
Deli Sides
Tomato Basil $5.25
Crack Corn Dip $5.25
Spinach-Artichoke Dip $5.25
Fruit Salad $5.25
Tomato & Cucumbers $5.25
Asian Slaw $5.25
Mashed Potatoes $5.25
Mac & Cheese $5.25
Green Beans $5.25
Extra Roll $0.87
Beverages
Bottled Water $1.56
Coke $1.44
Diet Coke $1.44
Pepsi $1.44
Diet Pepsi $1.40
Mountain Dew $1.40
Diet Mountain Dew $1.44
Sprite $1.44
Dr. Pepper $1.44
Diet Dr. Pepper $1.44

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Terri Thompson
The atmosphere reminded me of a mix of Marti Gras and Mexican. I liked the broccoli with bacon salad as my side dish, but the sandwich.. bacon, so crispy, not my thing. But 1st time here, so I didn’t know. But it had turkey ham cheese lettuce mayo n tomatoes… to expensive for me $17 with a lemonade.

… more

Sean O’Hair
We traveled all the way from Saskatchewan to try this place out (Full disclosure: Mom lives near by). It was definitely worth the trip! Had the open faced pot roast sandwich with cracked corn dip and my wife went with the Ruben panini and macaroni and cheese. Both were excellent. We’ll be coming back before we leave.

… more

Scott Mckinley
Excellent food! Very high quality and fresh home cooked style. Fun and unique atmosphere and friendly service with affordable pricing. Can’t ask for much more.

… more

Heather Moore
This place has great food. The servings seem to have shrunk & the prices most definitely have INCREASED. Nice place to eat a little noisy. Food always comes out fast. Don’t look for the cashier to crack a smile or say welcome. Lol

… more

Jennifer Cothron
Amazing food and great people! Natalie and her crew are top notch folks who put their heart and soul into what they do. Generous portions and positive atmosphere.

… more

Lukasz (Luke)
What a delicious place! This was the last restaurant we visited in Batesville and we widh we knew about it earlier! The hours are very short however the food is made fresh! The daily specials are delicious and the lemonade, you just have to try yourself! I went with a muffaletta and was highly satisfied! Highly recommend!

… more

John Newberry
Incredible food. Very healthy. Nothing fried. Baked BBQ chicken. Extra cheesy spaghetti. Potato and salads. Everything was hot and the service was perfect. It’s worth a drive to come here.

… more

Carrie Trego
Natalie’s is the best!!!!!! Hands down! Their broccoli cheddar soup is the BEST I ever had!!!

… more

Brittany Hill
I have been eating at Natalie’s off and on since she first opened in the cottages by Kroger’s. I always get the Shrimp and Avacado Supreme and here the other day as well as today I have added the Cheese Tortilini Pasta for my side. This dish makes me feel clean inside lol literally! I know I need to try other things on the menu, but I just can’t bring myself to cheat on my love lol!! Natalie’s is the only place in Batesville that I would or will ever recommend to anyone. Best and freshest food in town, and the environment is very inviting. Staff is kind and everyone in town knows Natalie’s is the GREATEST GIFT TO BATESVILLE!!! Never a disappointing experience. Love u Natalie and thank you for giving our town a little slice of heaven on Earth!!! U truly are hands down the best!!!!

… more

Ashlee Collins
If I could give 10 stars I would! My boyfriend and I traveled here on Christmas Eve. Natalie’s was amazing! There was so much on the menu that we wanted to try! The hamburger soup was a hit for the both of us. Natalie came out and spoke with us and was so kind. We will definitely be back!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions