Pizzeria showcasing thoughtfully sourced ingredients in its inventive, homemade pies. Based on 277 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
2224 E Cedar Ave #6, Flagstaff, AZ 86004
Phone: (928) 774-5000
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jonathan Barnett
Had really high expectations from all the different reviews. Ended being highly disappointed. Almost an hour wait for food even though only 1 other customer was in there and 2 pickup orders came in. They messed up our order even though there were only 3 toppings between 2 pizzas. Pizza ended up just being ok, crust was burnt. Salad was decent. Definitely wanted more for the price of pizzas ($19 fo 12 inch pizza).
… more
Vallie Rodriguez
Very welcoming staff and was our first time trying this place out. Got a large calzone with fire roasted chilies, pepperoni, and Sicilian spicy sausage. It was delicious! Definitely holds the flavor of pizza and calzones from back East.
… more
Kendrick Sutton
Pizza great! We try NY/NJ pizza everywhere we travel. (Been to 47 states). No place like Jersey Shore, Mario’s in Niagara, and a tiny place in Wilkes-Barre, but this place rocks out here in Flagstaff. We will order here again every time we pass. And the customer service was outstanding! Stayed at Little America, and they brought us plates and napkins.
… more
Franny Updike
I highly recommend this place! It’s truly a hidden gem in Flagstaff. The pizza is AMAZING and the owner was incredibly friendly and welcoming. The ingredients were quality, the food was freshly crafted, and every crumb was devoured. The dine-in had an ambience perfect for a romantic date night or a nice meal with friends and family. I’m in town for a few weeks and will certainly be visiting again!!
… more
Wendy Campione
The pizzas at New Jersey are sublime. They can elevate a simple mushroom sausage pizza into a delight. The delivery was spot on time wise and the delivery person was friendly and polite.
… more
Parker Newcomer
We ordered 4 pizzas to share with 7 people – the hour long wait was well worth it. The pizza was thin and crispy and had perfect ratios of sauce, cheese, and toppings. Very delicious.
… more
C
My family has been ordering here for about 5+ years now, and the food is always consistent & delicious. The pizza is verryyy flavorful, the crust is crispy on the outside & fluffy on the inside. The wings are amazing as well! They’re so crispy, with just the right amount of spice 🙂 all in all a very delicious place to eat!
… more
Angel Bowman
We completed the South Kaibab trail at the Grand Canyon, so what better way to treat yourself then with delicious pizza? Bought a pepperoni pizza and cheese sticks. Both were fantastic. The husband is an Italian Yankee and he was pleased with the pizza. Reminded us of Nolitas in NYC. Would definitely come here again if we found ourselves in Flagstaff again. The people were very friendly, couldn’t ask for better service.
… more
Nick B
The place is slammin. Great pies! One of the best places, if not the best (of this style), in town. Definitely deserving of the name, it’s pretty close to the quality of pies you find on the shore.
… more
K Bober
Great vegan pizza and hummus – best we’ve had in Flagstaff!! Staff made us feel welcome and called us 5 minutes before our food was ready to pick up, much appreciated.
… more
… View more