New Nelly’s Restaurant II Menu – New Paltz, NY

Type : Dominican restaurant

Location : New Paltz, NY

Based on 148 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

New Nelly's Restaurant II 12561

Address:
235 Main St, New Paltz, NY 12561

Phone: (845) 419-2808

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Monday

(Labor Day)
10 AM–9 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 10 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 10 AM–9 PM
Thursday 10 AM–9 PM
Friday 10 AM–9 PM
Saturday 10 AM–9 PM
Sunday Closed

Menu

Entrees
Baked Chicken $8.80
Roast Pork $11.00
Stew Beef $11.00
Steak & Onions $11.00
Oxtail $12.10
Goat $12.10
Codfish $12.10
Mofongos & Empanadas
Chicken Empanada $2.75
Beef Empanada $2.75
Cheese Empanada $2.75
Chicken & Cheese Empanada $2.75
Beef & Cheese Empanada $2.75
Chicken Mofongo
Mofongo de Pollo
$14.30
Pork Mofongo
Mofongo de Cerdo
$14.30
Cheese Mofongo
Mofongo de Queso
$14.30
Mofongo Combinado
Mixed Mofongo of Pork, Beef & Cheese
$16.50
Shrimp Mofongo
Mofongo de Camarones
$20.90
Natural Juices
Mango Juice $6.60
Tamarind Juice $6.60
Lemonade $6.60
Soursop Juice $6.60
Passion Fruit Juice $6.60
Morir Sonando
“To die dreaming…” a Silky smooth combination of Milk & Orange Juice
$7.70
Shakes
Mango Shake $7.70
Banana Shake $7.70
Strawberry Shake $7.70
Papaya Shake $7.70
Soursop Shake $7.70
Vanilla Shake $7.70
Specials
Fried Pork $16.50
Fried Chicken (Bone In) $14.30
Fried Chicken (No Bones) $18.70
Mangu $14.30
Pastel En Hoja $6.60
Sides
Sweet Plantains $6.60
Green Plantains $6.60
Potato Salad $7.70
Green Salad $6.60
Mixed Vegetable $7.70
Potato Ball
Papas Rellenas Breaded fried mashed potato ball with beef center
$4.40
Postres
Tres Leches $6.60
Flan $6.60
Cheesecake $6.60
Bizocho Dominicano
Dominican Cake
$6.60
Rice Pudding $6.60
Sweet Butter Milk $6.60

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

BKLYN NYC
Delicious Dominican food in upstate NY. The steak with rice and beans was delicious. All the food in the hot case looked amazing will be back to try some different dishes. Staff was super friendly. We enjoyed our lunch.

… more

Jose Hernandez
Nice small place. Food is displayed buffet style. I recommend the potato salad. We ordered white rice & ted beans with stew beef, lunch order. Empanadas, chicken soup, baked chicken with maduros, all tasted good.

… more

Dianne Weisselberg
You want to try these empanadas! Large, light flaky crusts. I wished there was more filling in the chicken one, but the cheese one was overflowing with melted cheese. And the combination mofongo is Delicious! The garlic puree was a wonderful complement to the sweetness of the plantain.

… more

Hillary Guzik-Jung
One of those places where you go to the counter and you get your choice of the fresh food. Everything I have ate here has been pretty good. But the empanadas, well the empanadas are stellar! So tasty! Might be the best ones in the area! They were not over fried not greasy and lots of choices.

… more

Samantha Walnuts
Pernil, chicken and cheese Empanadas with rice and peas

… more

Hugo
Decent food, a bit overpriced and they charged me $2.60 for a small bottle of water. I’ve never paid that price outside of an airport. Total rip-off.

… more

yao he
The food delicious, but little bit salty for my palate. Only few selections, that’s all I want. The price is respectable.

… more

Ashley Marcucci
check your food especially if you order out at this place, fiance almost swallowed this. not the type to file a lawsuit but honestly he could have died.

… more

Gravitas
They always have an attitude and act defensively, whenever you ask them how much the dishes cost. Every little thing costs extra. No lunch specials, nothing. Why even bother opening a business if they don’t have a pleasant attitude towards customers. Zero smiling. The chicken with rice and beans was salty, and greasy.

… more

Laura Hernandez
I have never given a review before, especially a bad one, but I have to write this hoping that the owner reads it and takes note of this instance since I am/was a regular customer here and other locations.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions