New York Fried Chicken Menu – Benton Harbor, MI

Type : Fried chicken takeaway

Location : Benton Harbor, MI

Based on 394 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price $

✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery ✔️ No dine-in

New York Fried Chicken 49022

Address:
610 E Napier Ave, Benton Harbor, MI 49022

Phone: (269) 757-7771

Website:

Hours

Monday

(Labor Day)
10 AM–3 AM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 10 AM–3 AM
Wednesday 10 AM–3 AM
Thursday 10 AM–3 AM
Friday 10 AM–5 AM
Saturday 10 AM–5 AM
Sunday 10 AM–3 AM

Menu

LUNCH SPECIALS
Chicken Sandwich Lunch Special $8.99
Cheese Burger Lunch Special $8.99
Chicken Gizzards Lunch Special $8.99
Chicken (2 Pieces) Lunch Special $8.99
WEEKEND SPECIALS
50 Wings Weekend Special
Includes large fries and a 2 liter pop.
$80.00
100 Wings Weekend Special
Includes large fries and two 2 liter pops.
$150.00
30 Piece Mix Chicken Weekend Special
Includes large fries and a 2 liter.
$60.00
SPECIALS
Combo #1: 12 Piece Chicken
Breast, wings, leg, thigh. Includes family fries and 2-liter pop.
$26.99
Combo #2: Chicken Mixed (5 Pieces) $13.49
Combo #3 6 Hot Wings $8.99
Combo #3: 9 Hot Wings $11.99
Combo #4: Chicken Nuggets (9 Pieces) $7.99
Combo #5: Shrimp Basket $11.99
Combo #6: Cheeseburger $10.39
Combo #7: Chicken Sandwich $10.39
Combo #8: Fish Sandwich $10.39
Combo #9: Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich (Beef) $12.49
Combo #9: Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich (Chicken) $12.49
Combo #10: Beef Gyro $12.49
Combo #10: Chicken Gyro $12.49
Combo #11: Double Decker Cheeseburger $10.99
Combo #12: Catfish (4 Pieces) $15.99
Combo #13: 4 Wings $8.99
Combo #13: 6 Wings $12.49
Combo #14: Gizzards $10.39
Combo #15: Chicken Sticks (15 Pieces) $10.39
Combo #16: Popcorn Chicken (20 Pieces) $10.39
Combo #17: Mozzarella Sticks (6 Pieces) $10.39
Combo #18: 3 Piece Tenders $10.39
Combo #18: 6 Piece Tenders $13.99
Combo #19: Jumbo Shrimp (12 Pieces) $15.99
Combo #20: Ocean Perch or Cod (4 Pieces) $13.99
Combo #21: Italian Beef $12.49
Combo #22: Chicken (2 Pieces) & Fish (2 Pieces) $13.99
Combo #23: Shrimp (5 Pieces) & Fish or Chicken (2 Pieces) $13.99
Combo #24: 2-Pizza Puffs $9.99
CHICKEN ONLY
1 Leg With Roll $1.89
1 Thigh With Roll $2.29
1 Breast With Roll $3.59
4 Wing Only $6.49
12 Wing Only $16.99
25 Wing Only $34.99
50 Wing Only $69.99
100 Wing Only $135.99
Thrift Box
9 pieces of chicken (breast, leg, thigh, and wing).
$16.99
Bucket
15 pieces of chicken (breast, leg, thigh, and wing).
$26.99
Barrel
21 pieces of chicken (breast, leg, thigh, and wing).
$33.99
CHICKEN COMBINATIONS
Snack Box
2 pieces of chicken, 1 roll, and mashed potatoes.
$8.99
Dinner Box
3 pieces of chicken, 2 rolls, mashed potatoes, and coleslaw.
$11.49
Jumbo Box
5 pieces of chicken, 2 rolls, mashed potatoes, and coleslaw.
$13.49
Wing Box
6 wings, 2 rolls, mashed potatoes, and coleslaw.
$12.99
6 Piece Box
6 pieces of chicken, 2 rolls, mashed potatoes, and coleslaw.
$15.49
8 Piece Box
8 pieces of chicken, 6 rolls, 2 mashed potatoes, and 1 pt coleslaw or macaroni salad.
$22.99
12 Piece Box
12 pieces of chicken, 8 rolls, 3 mashed potatoes, and 1 pt coleslaw or macaroni salad.
$30.99
15 Piece Box
15 pieces of chicken, 12 rolls, 4 mashed potatoes, and 2 pt coleslaw or macaroni salad.
$35.99
21 Piece Box
21 pieces of chicken, 15 rolls, 4 mashed potatoes, and 2 pt coleslaw or macaroni salad.
$44.99
CHICKEN & FRIES
2 Piece Chicken With Fries
With fries and 1 roll.
$8.99
3 Piece Chicken With Fries
With fries and 2 rolls.
$10.99
5 Piece Chicken With Fries
With fries and 2 rolls.
$13.49
HOT WINGS
6 Piece Hot Wings $6.99
6 Piece Hot Wings With Fries $8.99
6 Piece Wings $6.99
6 Piece Wings With Fries $8.99
9 Piece Hot Wings $9.99
9 Piece Hot Wings With Fries $11.99
9 Piece Wings $9.99
9 Piece Wings With Fries $11.99
15 Piece Hot Wings $17.99
15 Piece Hot Wings With Fries $18.99
15 Piece Wings $17.99
15 Piece Wings With Fries $18.99
21 Piece Hot Wings $23.99
21 Piece Hot Wings With Fries $24.99
21 Piece Wings $23.99
21 Piece Wings With Fries $24.99
CHICKEN NUGGETS
6 Piece Nuggets $4.99
6 Piece Nuggets With Fries $5.99
9 Piece Nuggets $5.99
9 Piece Nuggets With Fries $7.99
21 Piece Nuggets $12.49
21 Piece Nuggets With Fries $13.99
CHICKEN TENDERS ONLY
3 Piece Tenders $5.99
6 Piece Tenders $9.49
9 Piece Tenders $12.99
BURGERS & SANDWICHES
Hamburger $5.29
Cheeseburger $5.29
Double Decker $6.29
Chicken Sandwich $5.29
Gyro Beef $10.49
Gyro Chicken $10.49
Philly Steak Sandwich Beef $10.49
Philly Steak Sandwich Chicken $10.49
Fish Sandwich $5.29
Italian Beef $10.49
SEAFOOD LOVER
6 Piece Jumbo Shrimp
With fries, coleslaw, and 2 rolls.
$11.99
12 Piece Jumbo Shrimp
With fries, coleslaw, and 2 rolls.
$15.99
Shrimp Basket
With fries, coleslaw, and 2 rolls.
$11.99
4 Piece Perch Basket
With fries, coleslaw, and 2 rolls.
$13.99
4 Piece Cod Meal
With fries, coleslaw, and 2 rolls.
$13.99
3 Piece Catfish Meal
With fries, coleslaw, and 2 rolls.
$12.99
3 Piece Tilapia
With fries, coleslaw, and 2 rolls.
$12.99
10 Piece Fish Only Perch $27.99
10 Piece Fish Only Cod $27.99
10 Piece Cat Fish Only $29.99
10 Piece Tilapia Only $29.99
3 Piece Cat Fish Sticks
With fries, coleslaw, and 2 rolls.
$11.99
6 Piece Cat Fish Nuggets
With fries, coleslaw, and 2 rolls.
$8.99
OVER RICE
Chicken Over Rice $11.99
Lamb Over Rice $11.99
SIDE ORDERS
Macaroni and Cheese $4.29
6 Piece Fries Pickles $7.49
French Fries $3.29
Onion Rings $4.99
Popcorn Chicken $6.49
Potato Wedges $6.49
Mozzarella Sticks $6.99
Mashed Potato $3.29
Chicken Sticks $6.49
Rolls $0.49
Cheddar Munchers $6.99
Cheese Fries $3.99
Macaroni Salad (1/2 Pint) $3.29
Macaroni Salad (Pint) $4.29
Coleslaw 1/2 Pint $3.29
Coleslaw Pint $4.29
Cauliflower $6.99
Okra $6.49
Gizzard $6.99
Nachos $7.49
Beef Nachos $9.99
Chicken Nachos $9.99
Pizza Puff $2.99
12 Piece Mac & Cheese Bites $6.99
8 Piece Cheddar & Broccoli Bites $7.49
Jalapeno Bites $6.99
BBQ Sauce $0.50
Hot Sauce $0.50
Ranch $0.50
DESSERTS
Homemade Banana Pudding $3.99

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Sandie Foodie
First visit, ordered a 5 piece with fries and a drink. Fries were plain but cooked well. The chicken looked good, the breading was crispy and had light seasoning but needed more salt. Chicken tasted bland as well. Their wing dings might be better as some have told me but not impressed at all with their fried chicken. A bit pricey compared to other places. Good customer service. No public restrooms so I couldn’t check that out.

… more

Jesusa Vela
Not sure what’s happening with this place it used to be so good. Now the fries are always soggy and the chicken taste so off , it’s crunchy but has like a burnt flavor but no seasoning. The catfish was my favorite and this time around the fish was so over fried. Sad.

… more

king cog
This place used to be great. I ordered and paid through an app, they called me to tell me I owed them more money or they wouldn’t deliver. I told them to cancel the order. I went through the merchants to cancel the order, stop, and reverse payment. They then sent the order to my house after it was canceled and didn’t say anything to their driver!

… more

Angie
First time at this location.. surprisingly good… It did take a while for our food.. and they did forget a beverage…. Napkins or other items….. The burgers were delicious… The chicken was fried great and really good…. The stuffed pizza things were ok.. really greasy and soggy but they were ok….forgot to ask for ranch or bleu cheese…for the hot wings…but they were still good nonetheless….the fries were soggy….the cheese on the cheese fries tasted weird….but other than that it was an ok spot…only place in the area open late..so thats a plus…I would definitely recommend…they were very busy…which is also a good sign…I would go back…great food

… more

Maya Noble
Idk. Normally these guys are fantastic. Mean might take a while for them to deliver your food but have always been pleasant to deal with. Currently dealing with an order that is an hour and a half late and it took several calls to get through before I got to someone and he was absolutely rude and brushed me off about my order.

… more

Joshua C.
My only gripe – Called in an order and was told 20 mins, got there and waited another 25 mins lol food was on point, everything was really good, and the banana pudding hit the spot. For sure, my new late night munchies go to!

… more

Chris Ingle
This place is my new local fried chicken and catfish hot spot. The hours are amazing how late they are open and the employees said they are busy even before closing. That speaks for itself.

… more

Kenneth Utley
Very good chicken ! I would definitely eat there again. It’s like KFC chicken and McDonald’s fries from 1990 lol.

… more

Early Smith
We entered this establishment late at night, the wait time was a little long, what do you expect if you enter establishment 4 in the morning? Overall the food was great, and the people was pleasant.

… more

Srinivasa Gowtham Velagapalli
My wonderful friend here watched out for me and made sure I am not getting the wrong meat (lamb+beef ) .(nothing religious, but not a fan of beef flavor ).

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions