Laid-back joint fixing up NYC-style thin-crust pizzas with Big Apple-themed names. Based on 495 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
4418 Magazine St, New Orleans, LA 70115
Phone: (504) 891-2376
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Gala La Baud
After our wonderful relaxing pedicure, we went next door and ordered a snack while we waited for our Uber driver to pick us up. We ordered the snow bread and the thin crust cheese & veggie pizza. Everything was hot and delicious.
… more
bunny rieken
Great Staff. Thin crust specialty pizzas-Love it.
… more
caitlin rhame
We get this pizza almost weekly! So my boyfriend being from South Jersey and lived in NYC, we knew finding good pizza here was gonna take a few tries. Luckily we found this place.The crust is perfect, not too thin but still crispy and the right amount of cheese. Local beers on tap. Good prices. Divey but family friendly neighborhood joint atmosphere, just right.
… more
Nicolette Tech (Nikita)
We ordered for pick up, which went very smoothly. Parking wasn’t an issue and timing was quick at 20-25 minutes. This was on a Thursday night. Pizza was good, I did like the ‘Snooie bread’. The vibe at the bar is a dive bar feel with high tops and low tops. There is a bar and I saw that you can get beer by the pitcher for groups.
… more
Garland
Been wanting to check out the Bronx Bar at New York Pizza forever! Pint and a slice(cheese) for $6. Added Italian sausage for a dollar more. Liked the thin crust and the sausage was delicious. A pint of local craft beer and a slice for 7 dollar make me holla! Will be back again. Thanks for letting me hang out.
… more
Elizabeth B Carpenter
Do not subject yourself to this dreadful place. The pizza tasted like it had a chemical cleaning agent mixed into it. I would rather eat a Tombstone pizza from the grocery. The bartender sat behind the bar and drank the entire time without a care in the world. Please don’t even get me started on the filthy bathroom!!!
… more
Stanley Taylor
Went there for a birthday dinner a few years ago, took them an hour and a half to bring 2 large pizzas, which were wrong. Not only was it wrong but it came out cold and bad looking. Service was awful through out, we were barely checked on. We paid for the drinks and appetizers and left. Refused to let them fix it, by then we lost faith in their ability to do that quickly or accurately. Hopefully this place has changed or maybe it was a bad night. Probably won’t go back to figure that out.
… more
Karla Deissler-Nagy
It’s a Sunday night at 9:00 and our favorite places isn’t open so we decided to try New York Pizza on Magazine St. It was about as good as a frozen pizza over cooked. I myself typically like to eat the crust but this crust was like eating cardboard. Not that I have ever done that however, no flavor to the crust by itself and extremely hard. Although it filled a void in my belly, I consider this a waste of calories and we will not patronize this establishment again. Definitely over paid for what we had gotten. 14” cheese pizza with mushrooms with tax and slice fee was $25.29. Frozen would have been better considering the cost for sure. Picture shows how overdone the pizza was not to mention it looks as though it came out of the freezer.
… more
george mathis
NEW YORK PIZZA:
… more
Brittany Weaver
The food, staff and atmosphere were great! We had a kid’s party there and they made it so easy for us to have fun. Great little diner and a park is across the street with shade and plenty of play activities for younger kids.
… more
… View more