We are family owned and operated since 1999. New York Pizza features fine Italian dining. Private party room accommodates up to 85 people. Buffet parties of 20 or more with fixed menu.
We Take Reservations | Walk-Ins Welcome | We accept all major credit cards
Established outpost for classic & specialty pies, plus calzones & other familiar fare. Based on 239 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
57 Main St #2, Chester, NJ 07930
Phone: (908) 879-4424
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Mantej Singh Dhanjal
I was hungry when I left work, I also wanted to surprise my wife. I googled “best pizza near me” and this came up.
… more
David Tittensor
Had a great experience! Food was excellent. Service was great…and owners came over and introduced themselves. My 97 year old father-in-law who is Italian and knows Italian food… loved the food! Will definitely be back! Highly recommend!
… more
Stephanie Robshaw
Love this place. Delicious food and wonderful atmosphere in both the pizzeria and restaurant. Family owned / operated and are all so friendly and welcoming!
… more
Patricia Mendoza
My husband and I took our kids there a few weeks ago. The kids wanted pizza and we wanted Italian food. This place had it both. Really good pizza and the food was excellent! We had the calamari and it was super tender is was delicious! Then we had penne vodka with shrimp and it was very good. The owner came to our table greet us and they were very attentive and polite. This place is great! We definitely going back
… more
Madison Conti
Amazing restaurant! My family and I have been ordering from them for years. They have always been consistent with their quality of food and service. Incredibly friendly staff and very good communication through mobile ordering
… more
Chuck Mound
Moving along the NJ Pizza Tour in Morris County brings us to New York Pizza in Chester. Chef Shabo could not be nicer or more accommodating. The place was clean and staff was nice. The slice was an above average slice where the crust spoke to you first. Cooked perfectly, then the Grande Cheese gives you the best Pizza Cheese and finally the sauce. Would have loved to taste more of the sauce to go with the cheese and the crust. You can tell Shabo takes a lot of pride in his products and places a high value on his customers. This was one of the best in Chester, see where they will Rank in the Morris County rankings. Worth stopping for sure, the speciality pizzas looked great, especially the sicilian. Great Job New York Pizza of Chester.
… more
S A
I ordered 4 pies for my kid’s party and I asked them to cut them smaller. They didn’t cut them to 16 pieces as they said they would and each pie had 8 pieces. So many waste so I had to order 2 more in the middle of the party. I was so frustrated and unhappy about it.
… more
Vanessa Switzler
Love this family restaurant. The owners are so welcoming, food never fails to please.
… more
Rob Healy
Can’t say enough. Food deserves a solid 5 stars. Service? Can you go above 5 on that? When you come here, you’re probably expecting solid NJ pizza joint service… Which isn’t to disparage… only to say that a few pies, drinks and apps doesn’t lay the foundation for ultra formal service. Our visit to New York Pizza was incredible and the food did not fall behind either. Waitress was genial, attentive and infinitely knowledgeable. Pizza was something i haven’t had in awhile; robust crust, great underside scorch, tangy sauce and beautiful, hi qual Mozz and Pepperoni. Coming back again and again
… more
Michael D
Great pizza, dining area comfortable, staff friendly. wish they delivered.
… more
… View more