It doesn’t matter if you need a single serving or you’re feeding the whole family, everyone will love New York Pizza & Pasta. We also have a selection of Italian appetizers, wings and calzones. Let New York Pizza & Pasta handle dinner duty tonight. Call today to place an order for carryout.
An easygoing setting with red interior details & a menu featuring classic Italian-American fare. Based on 886 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
624 Indian Trail Road South, Indian Trail, NC 28079
Phone: (704) 821-6000
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–3 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–3 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Karen Edwards
We had a soccer tournament this past weekend and not knowing the area, I reached out to 3 Italian Restaurants that offered catering. NY Pizza & Pasta replied first and offered reasonable prices for full and 1/2 trays with many choices. They were so easy to work with and the food was ready on time. During our team dinner, all the parents were complimenting the food and how delicious each option was, and I have to say I have now found my all time favorite lasagna dish! I would highly recommend this restaurant for any size party or dining in. The food had so much flavor and or 11 year old girls went up for seconds!
… more
Summer
woooooow!!
… more
Trey Krajewski
This was the pizza place where I grew up and it was always the best. I heard that new ownership took over and it wasn’t the same at first but that they have recently brought back the original recipe that myself and so many others have fallen in love with. I had it for the first time in over a year as I now live abroad and I’m happy to say the pizza is back tasting just like the original recipe. The new ownership should be proud of themselves, thank you for listening to customer feedback and making my favourite pizza again! Best of luck in your new business guys!
… more
Chip Jones
We had a “party” of 5 for my brother’s birthday dinner. The 4 adults ordered the AYCE buffet at 12.00? each. We walked in were seated and the wait staff was right behind us to take our orders and drink requests. The staff was AWESOME! The owner is AMAZING! The fresh made pizza & pasta were hot and tasty. The garlic buttery noodles are so good. I will be a repeat customer. I certainly recommend dining here. Fantastic overall experience! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… more
C P
Used to be our favorite place to eat as a family. Prices are really reasonable and mostly good portions. However, ownership changed maybe six months to a year ago, and I think the food has gone downhill. The dough on the pizza is different, and everything seems more salty. The worst part now is the experience. The owners and some staff nickel and dime everything. You used to be able to put your own toppings on a side salad from the buffet. That stopped with the new owners, and the side salad has almost nothing on it. All of the former wait staff and kitchen staff were really friendly people. Not the case anymore. Too bad.
… more
Em Lachelle
Very tasty! Service was amazing
… more
Mary Fabian
This place is solid. The take-out pizza is good, I love the quality of their Italian sausage!! The pizza buffet is good, too. Lots of choices and pasta and salad, too. You’re not going to be blown away, but you certainly won’t be disappointed!
… more
Michael Chandler
Absolutely terrible customer service. I place a phone in to go order. I go and pick up the order, get home, and my order is entirely wrong. I call to inquire about it and they blame me that it was wrong when I was very specific with what I wanted and what I wanted on it. They say they can give me half off next time. No thanks… not when I payed full price for something and can’t even eat it. The girl then says I can come back but I’d have to be there in person to get a refund and they’d replace it. I drive all the way back over there and they proceed to tell me they’ll either give a refund OR the food, not both, even though that is what was said on the phone if I came back. I asked for a manager but was told there wasn’t one on duty… makes sense. It was my first time in and definitely my last.
… more
YL
As of 10/17/18, I had to update to 5 stars!!! Best pizza.
… more
Sherry Smith
Been there 3 times. Always get pizza. But the pasta dishes look good also. They have a pizza bar with different toppings. I doubt you’d be disappointed. We’ll be back.
… more
… View more