Based on 292 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
200 S Peterboro St, Canastota, NY 13032
Phone: (315) 697-3993
Website: https://www.facebook.com/NewYorkPizzeriaCanastota/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 2–8:30 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Dave Arnold
They do not know how to make a Sicilian pizza right. they use to make a very good one but for the past year or so the Sicilian pizza is terrible.. the one I ordered today was so hard it was non eatable . the one I order before this one was 2 regular crust stacked on top of each other and over cooked. There is a certain technique to making and baking a Sicilian pizza and here it’s not done.
… more
Tev
In from Flordia for a couples days and was referred to New York Pizzeria by a family member and needles to say I was a bit skeptical as I usually head straight to Slice in Utica to tackle my pizza fix. NY Pizzeria knocked it out of the park with their slices. Amazing flavor profile with just the right amount of crunch. Will definitely be back in the future. Keep up the good work.
… more
Alfreda Maurer
I ordered delivery to the hotel I was staying at. The menu in room had coupons which were no longer valid, ordered anyways and was NOT disappointed! Pizza was excellent and wings were perfect! New York Pizza is a good choice. I highly recommend you will not be disappointed!
… more
deb seamon
Will not be buying pizza from there again. When you ask for your pizza not to be burnt and it still comes burnt there’s a problem. I shouldn’t have to ask for Less sauce either. So too much sauce burnt pizza I pay $40 for two pizzas and they’re both disgusting. I don’t know why it’s such an issue to ask for Less sauce and not a burnt pizza?
… more
Bryan Cogan
Being a long distant truck driver it’s hard enough to find parking close to good food. It’s even hard when we break down which is wjat happened to me. Sitting on a on ramp waiting on road service I called new york pizza explained my situation to see if the would deliver. They had no issues with delivering to me. Thank you for having great staff and helping a trucker out while stuck. Now onto the food. Ordered a medium pizza and a drink figure get dinner and next days lunch all in one what showed up to me was not a medium in my experiance but a large pizza. Not sure if they were being nice made a mistake or if that’s the size of a medium to them. Being a ex pizza Shop owner this pizza was amazing keep up the great work and if I’m ever in the area I’ll know where to stop and I’ll be sharing this with other truckers put here that there is a great spot to stop. Thanks again.
… more
jeremy paddock
Best pizza from the best pizzeria on the planet!
… more
ashley garlock
Came up from Florida and this was my first stop. Absolutely amazing pizza and great prices.
… more
Florence R Kline
Good, I saw 4 people cone in to make orders in 15 minutes AND on a nice Saturday afternoon!
… more
Shark Man
After researching top rated eateries, I decided to get my coworkers who live in the area gift certificates to New York Pizzeria. It is a local family owned shop, and I felt it important to support local business. I drove from Syracuse to Canastota to get these gifts. The employees were friendly and it was very difficult not to indulge in the delicious looking slices they had (see pictures!) I will definitely return with my family to eat here.
… more
bulldod23
5 ⭐️ hands down perfect thin slices with the perfect crisp and service with a smile what can I say a very good pizza shop.
… more
… View more