We are a family owned & run Seafood and Steakhouse specializing in fresh Seafood and in house hand cut steak’s. Everything is homemade. We have a wide selection of locally craft beer, cider, & liquors. Nick Stoner Inn has Gluen free options as well as low carb, and vegetarian. Our event venue has been beautifully renovated and is now year round offering many amenities for large or small parties, events, weddings ECT….please visit us on our Facebook page for upcoming daily specials, or inquire about events.
Nick Stoner Inn Seafood & Steakhouse
Based on 228 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
1810 NY-10, Caroga Lake, NY 12032
Phone: (518) 835-8039
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Thursday | 12–8 PM |
| Friday | 12–8 PM |
| Saturday | 12–8 PM |
| Sunday | 12–5 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kari Duesler
This place has the BEST menu, freshest food and homemade everything. While running short staffed, like most family operated businesses these days, you still get a beautiful atmosphere, wonderful quality and dining experience. If you’re expecting “in and out” go to a drive thru. All good things are worth the wait and trust me, Nick Stoner is worth it!
… more
Kimberly Warner
Food was great. We all enjoyed our meal. Rustic atmosphere and service was great. Appetizers, salad and meal all came timely. Portions are very generous. You will not leave hungry. We will definitely be returning again soon.
… more
Cheryl Vanvlack
My expectations were very high when we came here. I love the atmosphere, really good music. The menu only has about ten select meals, they make when you order. Nothing is precooked. When meal came, it was amazing! The steaks were really good cuts,cooked to perfection. We also had the seafood dish… Wow! I’m totally impressed!
… more
Viviana Arroyo
First time going to celebrate my husband’s birthday last night and it was absolutely AMAZING. The staff were so nice to us and we can tell they were working hard to keep everyone satisfied. Even the regulars greeted us. The drinks were so good and the food OMG delicious with huge steak cuts. We will definitely be going back for date nights. Thank you so much for such great food and service!!
… more
SAM LAMANNA
Truly a hidden gem. This place has amazing food that will spoil every other place for you. My wife and I found our new go to restaurant. It was worth the drive. I had Rolotinni and it was delicious. My wife had Salmon and it was amazing. We also had fried clams as an appetizer. The salad was the best I ever had. Finally didn’t have to add more dressing! The fresh bread was so good we gobbled it all up. You can tell they take pride in their food quality. Don’t miss this place!
… more
Adrianne Denenberg
Really wish I could give a better review but our meals took over 2 hrs… now, they have a sign at the door says to expect an hour wait. That we were ready for. But two+? And two items ordered were undercooked. Won’t be going back any time soon.
… more
Michael McLaughlin
My wife had a Filet that was very good. I had seafood over pasta that had scallops, shrimp and a lobster tail. The pasta, egg noodles, was in a white sauce. The scallops and shrimp were large and sweet. The lobster was tough. The pasta was very sticky and dry. Next time, I’ll get a steak and shy away from white sauces.
… more
lily cochran
Took our waitress 20 minutes from when we entered to come to our table. We were the only table there other than a couple at the bar. Took another hour after that to get our food. Didn’t receive bread and salad came out after our meal. Food was good. Had the chicken and shrimp special and my husband had the crab sandwich. Restaurant also had a very strong artificial smell, some kind of air freshener but it was a little too much for me.
… more
Zonika Rizz
We love this place. They serve great food. The food has a beautiful presentation. We always have a nice time!
… more
becki jade
Was really excited to experience their food! Saw a fb post of weekend menu and upon arrival the lunch menu was very limited in comparison to the fb post… we ordered chili dogs and fries (fries were amazing) the buns from the hotdogs were beautifully toasted.. the hot dogs were ok qnd the chili was very tomatoe-y .. their mexican spinach artichoke dip was nothing but heat.. it over powered the real taste of the dip.. BUT the chips were AMAZING… .. just really sad we missed out on what looked like great seafood
… more
… View more