Nicky’s The Real McCoy® at 24th & Cicero Avenue is a fast-casual restaurant located in Cicero. We serve all of the Windy City’s favorites, such as Chicago-style Hot Dogs, Italian Beefs, Gyros, Polishes,
Nicky’s The Real McCoy® original location at 58th & Kedzie Avenue is where all the flavorful magic first began back in 1969 and eventually expanded to 11524 South Pulaski in Alsip, IL and then here in Cicero. Our success has let to some counterfeit venues using our likeness, so unless it says, Nicky’s The Real McCoy®, order at your own rick.
Based on 719 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
2400 S Cicero Ave, Cicero, IL 60804
Phone: (708) 222-8500
Website:
Hours
| Sunday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10:30 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday |
10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday |
10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Friday |
10:30 AM–11:30 PM |
| Saturday |
10:30 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Donald Green
Italian combo is the bomb, they also have real lemons in their Italian ice. I ordered one and ate it driving off, I was mad as hell that I didn’t buy two, prices are unbeatable as well as the quality they provide. Will be my go to place for Italian beef combo.
… more
DEVNTE Sims
The worst Italian beef I have ever had the meat not cooked long enough. The gyro was actually very good .
… more
Jeannie Jones
Had the Italian beef with mozzarella cheese not dipped and it was so freaking delicious I order beefs just about everywere I go and this is hands down one of the best I’ve ever had 2nd to susys beef that used to be on montrose Ave …This is my new go to for beefs needless to say I won’t order them dipped tho there’s a perfect amount of juice as it was so don’t go ruin it …you won’t be disappointed
… more
Iam SunshineNChicago
Nicky’s has the best charbroiled chicken breast and charbroiled steak sandwich! Can’t go wrong with the Grecian chicken dinner or Gyro dinner. Enough food for 2 easily! Say hello to Nelly… she’s a gem!
… more
Brian Lowenberg
Food is very good for the price. I’ve always found that the Grecian half chicken meal which comes with a bit of salad, Greek fries, rice and garlic bread is more than enough to feed my partner and I. Thought the prices have gone up it’s still a good value. Also I’m happy you can run in order and be back on the way home in just a few minutes.
… more
Jorge Duarte
The younger lady with the tattoos was friendly.
… more
kim gutierrez
I and my family of 4 generations have been coming here over 30 years and all the other locations as well. Never had a problem with the food. But to serve you a burnt burger bun on both sides. In my opinion shows inexperience and lack of training on Nicky’s part.I will still come here but I will check to see who is at the grill cooking. My son was hungry so he didn’t see what he was eating. I could smell it was burnt without looking. Not happy because I will need to check my order before I leave the place the next time I place an order. Burger was still eaten by my son but I’m not thrilled to buy burnt food.
… more
Michele Mayweather
The food is very seasoned well and tasty! The service was very nice & greeted you with a smile and was very helpful
… more
Yuven Asiatu
I’ve been here a few times. Excellent fast food at affordable prices. I had the chicken with cheese, no tomatoes, and grilled onions with tzatziki sauce on pita. Alternatively, the gyro sauce. It was scrumptious.
… more
Nancy Garcia
I love the lemon chicken and the fries. And beef. Everything is awesome.
… more
… View more
