Based on 235 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1125 Willard Ave, Newington, CT 06111
Phone: (860) 667-0663
Website: https://www.nicolaspizzamexicaneatery.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Matthew G
The tacos and Mexican food here is incredible. Fresh, tasty, reasonably priced, and good portions. Never tried the pizza or other options, so can’t really comment on those. Girl who works the front counter certainly isn’t winning any awards for “Miss Personality.” I plan on returning for the tacos though, they’re bomb.
… more
Shannon Cuddy
Ramshackle hole in the wall adjoining a run down liquor shop. Looks like family run. The food was ok but nothing to really write home about. I’ve had authentic Mexican food and it was more flavorful than this. I will say there is a nice heat level to the sandwiches and the green sauce that comes with the burrito is quite nice (I think it was a tomatolli cilantro sauce).
… more
Aprylle
I love (and dream about) the crunchy chicken tacos. The best crunchy tacos I’ve ever had if I’m perfectly honest and at a very fair price. When I lived and worked in the area I ordered here multiple times a week, but now that I have moved pretty far away I come back just to snag some tacos to eat in my car.
… more
Nitzely Baez
My experience here was not the greatest and it is sad because the food was so good. (One of the best tacos ive had) The customer service in the other hand was HORRIBLE. When you first walk in nobody greets you, they dont ask if you need anything, sit etc. The girl at the front desk is NOT a people person and honestly that could hurt a business immensely. I would never dine in again because it is soooo cold and you can tell they dont care about their customers. Hopefully they can change that and im sure their business will thrive.
… more
Dan Herrick
Regardless, their tacos and tostadas are 5 stars. 3 tacos, homemade crispy shells (a little over cooked) overstuffed with ground beef and some fixins, red and green hot sauce, very good. My advice to the owners, when a customer walks in and sits down, acknowledge them, don’t just sit at the cash register expecting them to know you’re not going to walk the 5 feet to their table. Also, when you serve, serv with silver or plastic ware. Just be conscious of your consumers.
… more
Molly Zembko
Pretty pretty prettyyyy good tacos. Seems more like a take out place. Decent prices. Got the pulled pork and steak tacos
… more
Asia Soto (Asia McMillan)
Such a great place tacos but the customer service needs improvement. Both cashiers are rude and very unfriendly. I even suggested she smile and she was made about that and rolled her eyes. Do better…I didn’t make you take this job nor do your other patrons!!!
… more
Icon Gate Entertainment
Unassuming little place in Newington. You might miss it driving by on Willard Ave. Nicolas has a pretty varied menu between pizza and Mexican fare. Had Crunchy Tacos and Empanadas. First the good news, the crunchy tacos were fantastic!! Had chicken, beef, chorizo and steak. All four were perfect. If you’re looking for good tacos this place is a great choice. Unfortunately the empanadas were seriously underseasoned and just bland with a fried dough that tasted like bad Chinese chicken tender dough. Taco’s are easily 5 stars (but a big loss for empanadas).
… more
Caliper Collie
Amazing crunchy tacos. Come with same ingredients as taco bell tacos but with fresh crunchy shells, and generous helping of everything on it. Awesomene Tortas, Favorite inexpensive Mexican place. Pizza slaps too
… more
nawaz basha
Good place grab a quick bite.
… more
… View more