Based on 326 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
12459 Olean Rd, Chaffee, NY 14030
Phone: (716) 496-5666
Hours
| Tuesday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Griffin A
Absolutely amazing food, the best Italian in the area. Prices are great and the service was lovely. They have a good selection of beer and wine. The menu is huge and they have a ton of options if you’re not sure what to eat.
… more
Brian
Nicolo’s is a place you can count on for a nice meal. We had the usual, pizza & wings. Both were quite good. They also offer a pretty wide variety of other options. They have soft drinks plus beer or wine. And, if you still have room, the cheesecake is pretty good too.
… more
ed g
Waitress was very friendly and the food was excellent. Special shout out to the dinner rolls–honestly the best I’ve ever had anywhere.
… more
Eliza Kamińska
Everything was great (salads, Italian sausage roll) including fries and pickles! We we definitely be back for more. Friendly atmosphere and service.
… more
Amanda Huffer
My food was cold and had green in it and when told staff the reply was its supposed to be that way. The burger My friend got he said was gross. Between everyone that was with me and the $154. Spent definitely don’t recommend and for a restaurant I would think it would have more variety of foods. Very disappointing.
… more
Trish Lawrence
Norm makes the BEST PIZZA ever!!! Even when we lived in Southern California, we never found pizza as good as his. The battered mushrooms were delicious, too. Service and food were great as always.
… more
Joe Lamoureux
I’ve been coming here since I was a young lad and it’s a great place. Food is always excellent and the people are awesome! Norm, Jen and the crew are such incredible people and have been so kind and supportive! We will always love this place!
… more
peter s
Absolutely “HORRID”!!! Order Italian broiled fish and get this disgusting slab of god knows what.Looks like lemon pepper but the rude 28 year veteran waitress says it’s Italian! Lmao. I’d give no stars if I could.
… more
Robert Pimpo
I was discriminated against for a camo hoody waited 50 minutes for a table and finally someone came and got me and I sat in the corner in a empty room and no one ever came to take my order waited 40 minutes I got up and walked out the door. So i will never go back there again being treated that bad is terrible
… more
Kerri Brown
We went here after our son’s playoff game at Pioneer this weekend. We stood there for 15 minutes before anyone came to seat us, and when we told them party of 11, the server said “well that’s gonna be a problem” and walked away. I tried to follow her and tell her we’ll just sit at different tables if it’s easier but she pretty much snapped at me and said they’d been working since 4 without a hostess. I understand the service industry continues to suffer and everyone is short staffed but had it just been me and my family, I probably would have left at this point. But we had hungry boys so we waited for them to get a table together. Once seated, we waited 15 more minutes before another server came to get our drink and food order. I think she was trying to joke and said “everyone just wants pizza and wings right?” It just felt awkward. I usually have a lot of respect for those in the service industry and go out of my way to be nice especially when I see they’re struggling, but they were just plain rude to us. I felt uncomfortable and unwelcome.
… more
… View more