Humble, long-standing pizzeria supplying thin-crust pies & slices, plus hot subs & pasta. Based on 432 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
73 E Main St, Lititz, PA 17543
Phone: (717) 627-6466
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Skylin Miller
I grew up in lititz and came here a lot for pizza growing up. In 2015 I left PA and on to the next chapter of my life. Fast forward to today and I come back here to try the pizza. It taste the exact same. Perfect with every bite. Thank you Ninos for not changing and saving a small happy part of my child hood to bring back good memories. Definitely try the pizza here
… more
Rolf Hansen
My pet peeve are places that lack professional drive and don’t care about getting business. Tried ordering a pizza at like 935-940, they close at 10. They wouldn’t answer their phone. Walked there before they closed at 10 to try and get a pizza and the worker said they close down 30 mins before their official closing time. So change your closing time to 930 then! Frustrating when you try to shop local and promote local business when they don’t have the ambition to fight for it themselves. Got papa johns instead.
… more
Zach Klinedinst
Great little pizza place in Lititz. Make sure you park around back as there is a big parking lot and easy door to access. The pizza is excellent, probably the best we’ve had in the Lancaster area!
… more
Chris Kirman
Hot pizza just out of the oven usually can’t go wrong, but it was just OK. Side note, I’m about done with the surcharge for using plastic. This is like being charged for automatic transmission in 2023. Find a better vendor or at least brand it as a “cash discount.”
… more
FatherDavid Sharland
A friendly, tasty place to get Italian subs or pizza. The wait staff was very friendly, and the food was prepared quickly. I don’t care for the refill cost on your cup of soda, since soda cost next to nothing. I would certainly come back again the next time I’m in this lovely little town.
… more
Max Lawson
Repurposed old building. Giant step up into takeout/ order counter in the doorway. The step is marked with yellow tape to make visibility easier. The cheesesteak is an awesome sub. I personally dislike how tall/ high to reach the soda fountain is. At the same token, I can deal with it because it’s one of the only places that serve Mr. Pib cola.
… more
Jackie Clayton
I’m from New York and I personally only eat this pizza when I visit. Which has been alot. Hidden gem if you ask my family. They have funnel cake fries too!
… more
Leeanna Krushinski
I got a pepperoni pizza and cheese fries. The pizza was very greasy. The fries weren’t bad but they could’ve added more cheese.
… more
Kristy Bryan
Nino’s is my favorite pizzeria! They have the most authentic New York pizza around. I recently had a party catered and Nino’s provided pizzas, pasta, salad, and garlic bread for my guests. It was ready on time, delicious, and the price was very reasonable. My orders are always ready on time and delicious. I also love the Mediterranean salad. Highly recommend for a pizza night or large catering order!
… more
s.huss
pizza is alright, definitely not anything special. there’s better in Lititz and Lancaster.
… more
… View more