Based on 31 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
5766 W Lake Rd, Olcott, NY 14126
Phone: (716) 638-4128
Website: https://thenorthernpier.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 7 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 7 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 7 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Michael McAllister
We took our girls out to dinner last Friday night and the service and food was excellent! My kids had burgers, I had the midwestern and my wife had a beer battered fish fry. I also really enjoyed the New England clam chowder which was very flavorful. I would highly recommend trying them out and I will be back for breakfast and to try their lobster and blue crab roll!
… more
Allan Hansford
I’ve been twice once for breakfast and once for dinner, the breakfast was amazing, and very well priced for the amount of food you get. Dinner was also very good. Service was good with friendly staff as well. Overall I recommend giving this restaurant a try if you’re in Olcott.
… more
Beverly McArthur
Fantastic food! Great prices! Tried this place years ago but now under new management, remodeled & new menu. There is a sous chef in the kitchen that cranked out 5 star restaurant dishes. We are seafood lovers & tried ahi tuna cooked to perfection & their clams & mussels in garlic, butter, & wine sauce over lingiuni! No leftovers… Their soup choices & salads were also impressive. Glad we went for a fathers day dinner. Great choice and will definitely return to try other items on their menu!
… more
Mark Schmigel
This is our new go to place to eat “in” Olcott Beach. Right away the waitress made us feel comfortable and welcome. The Midwestern sandwich was an amazing amount of pork loin with a breaded coating that added to the flavor of the meat in the best way and came with French fries that were on point. My wife got the patty melt that we both thought was the most flavourful we’ve ever tasted. For an older place they’ve done a great job making it look fresh and new. We can’t wait to get back to try the rest of the menu.
… more
Beach View
Sad to say, we won’t be back. We’ve tried it 4 times and after the last time, we gave up hope. Each time got worse and worse. The last time we waited 30 minutes for an appetizer, which was immediately followed by our dinner. There were 3 tables with customers, so it wasn’t because they were busy. Our food was wrong and severely over cooked. When we told the waitress she said “I’m sorry, it’s my first night” not sure what that had to do with our food. I wish you the best of luck, sad to say, we won’t be back to our neighborhood restaurant.
… more
Colleen Fryer
Tried this new restaurant out last night and it was a great experience and the food was delicious. I had the NY Strip Steak. It was a nice size, cooked as per my request and was seasoned perfectly. Our server was new and still learning, but he was very nice and was attentive.
… more
Bill Lisk
We tried this new place early this evening. One of us had the NY steak, and one had the ribeye. Both entrees were delicious, as were the fries and fresh bread. Dinner began with a beautiful garden salad with premium ingredients. We only had unsweetened ice tea to drink. It appeared to be freshly brewed. Service was friendly and efficient, and the simple nautical decor was just right. This will be one of our regular stops from now on.
… more
Dina Schearer
Went here to try for the first time, was not entirely impressed. Our waiter was very friendly and informative. The food was ok. I had the crab stuffed mushrooms, good flavor and my dinner, I had the scallops, broiled, and they came in butter. My side was mashed potatoes, those were good, real, not powder. My husband got the Hungarian stuffed peppers, 3 come in this, they were good. For my husband’s dinner, he ordered the NYS steak, it was tough, would have expected a better steak for the price. The meal was just not very impressive. The atmosphere was of an eat-in diner type feel, very casual. The place did fill quite quickly with people. The service was good, quick, and accommodating.
… more
Gina Guido-Redden
This is a wonderful new addition to Olcott – so much so that the entire town has been heading there since they opened creating a great community atmosphere! The owners did a great job renovating the interior of a building that had been unused for 20+ years! The menu is large, the open hours are extensive (which we badly need) and the staff is great! We have dinner in and again for take out. Both were great! I haven’t made it there for breakfast yet – but we will soon!
… more
Rhonda Dietrich
Food is TERRIBLE. We ordered the “roast beef”. It’s not good at all. It’s thinly sliced deli style beef, under cooked and fatty.
… more
… View more