Based on 353 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
126 W Plant St, Winter Garden, FL 34787
Phone: (407) 614-8292
Hours
| Saturday | 7 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 8 AM–8:45 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
7 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 7 AM–8:45 PM |
| Wednesday | 7 AM–8:45 PM |
| Thursday | 7 AM–8:45 PM |
| Friday | 7 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sara Barnett
Upon walking in, it smelled like home. There were knish ads everywhere and a counter of fresh bagels, pizza slices, and a selection of cookies that didn’t interest me. I asked about the knish first, but I was told that they were not able to get them in, so they were not available. Now, I will say that the ads looked just like the ones you can buy in the freezer section of Publix. Knish should be handmade. I can’t judge, as I didn’t get to partake, but we’ll see next time. Yes, I will be going back.
… more
Kiersten Smith
Was really excited to try this place, a friend recommended & the pictures looked amazing. I’m from CT & have yet to find a NY style bagel that meets par… I ordered a ham and Swiss on an everything bagel. As listed on the menu the sandwich is supposed to come with lettuce, tomato, mayo and mustard. Upon receiving the bagel and opening the wrapper, I quickly realized it was not the thick NY style bagel I’ve been dreaming of. Maybe 3 slices of ham and a slice of Swiss. No lettuce, no tomato. I tried to go back to the counter to address the mistake but there was no one at the front desk, I waited a few moments and sat back down & ate because we were starving!
… more
Bryan Fields
I just tried NY Bagel and Deli this morning. I’m from Jersey and was so in the mood for a porkroll, egg, cheese, and potato sandwich. To my surprise they had porkroll. I had it on an egg bagel and it was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!!! The bagel was perfect! I haven’t had a breakfast sandwich this good since I’ve moved down here 7 years ago. Super nice folks there and they did such an amazing job with the sandwich, that I sent pictures of it to people back in Jersey bragging about it. I’ll be there regularly now.
… more
Devyn Prado
Today was my second time here. I ordered the chicken salad on an egg bagel both times and it’s delicious. I also got the lunch special for my kids. It’s a great deal, with two slices and a drink for $6.99. The best part of our experience today though was when the person preparing our order stepped out of the kitchen to ask me if I wanted him to cut the pizza into little pieces for the kids. He delivered me 2 slices cut into small pieces that made it a million times easier to serve to my little ones without having to saw at hot pizza with a dinky plastic knife. It was a kind and thoughtful gesture that was very appreciated. Everything was delicious!
… more
Desiree Agudo
Extraordinary experience! The closest NY Style Pizza to the real N.Y. pizza!
… more
William Stockwell
Great experience, 100% be back! Pizza was thin, but no to thin! Has a Nice crispy crust! The Garlic knots has a nice buttery sauce.
… more
Peter Brolmann
A true NY deli that had a sweet lunch special and THE BEST CANNOLIS I have EVER had. The texture and cream was crafted with such expertise and excellence that it melted in your mouth, and the chocolate chips were the perfect consistency to compliment. 1000% get a cannoli from here!!!
… more
Paul Abraham
Best pizza in Winter Garden! The people are always courteous and helpful as well! I eat here as often as I can! Btw… their lunch special is a great deal, so I definitely recommend it. The price in general for pizza is great as well, especially considering how most restaurants around here tend to gouge as far as they can… love love love this place
… more
Sean Cline
Stopped in for lunch and OMG we finally found authentic NY style pizza!! Everywhere in central FL claims to have NY style, but this place is actually legit! The slices were thin crust big enough to fold, greasy, and full of flavor (the way it should be!!) and the garlic knots were out of this world good!! So refreshing to get a true taste of home! Can’t wait to come back for more!
… more
Patrick Gorham
Went in for two slices of pizza, a cup of water, and a lemonade. Food was subpar and took a while to come out.
… more
… View more