NY Pizza Pie is an all organic non-gmo pizzeria. We locally source all ingredients from local Amish and Mennonite farmers as well as passionate farmers within our area. We use only the freshest ingredients at the peak of their ripeness, and whatever we don’t use for that day we donate to local food banks in the evening. At NY Pizza Pie, our motto is “Highest Quality Possible”. What that means is regardless of the price or time of the year, we will provide our customers with the highest quality ingredients and never anything less.
Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides in an aviation-themed space. Based on 168 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2589 Ogden Ave, Downers Grove, IL 60515
Phone: (331) 777-9981
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday |
4–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
4–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
4–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
4–9 PM |
| Thursday |
4–9 PM |
| Friday |
4–9 PM |
| Saturday |
4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: nypizzapie4u.com
Reviews
Chris Graef
Good pizza and maybe the best option for NY style. The toppings were flavorful, the crust was crunchy and a little bendy. My one complaint is the crust is a bit hard but would be complemented well with some extra sauce. Would other again!
… more
Faisal H.
Dropped in for a quick bite. Nice place. They do slices also and have a good variety. They source all their ingredients fresh and locally. Saw some really nice pies coming out of the oven. The owner/chef not sure who it was, was nice & friendly guy, gave me the run down on a veggie pie that just came out of the oven that I was admiring.
… more
cody bernard
2.5 stars..
… more
Kashif Razzak
Got an 18″ cheese pizza (nice flavor, thin crust,now my favorite), bosco bsticks (cheese filled bread sticks that are delectable), Mac & cheese bites (VERY TASTY FOR ME AND MY 4 yr old) and sweet potato (super tasty, off the hook) with soda on the house.
… more
Alina Kopak
The best Pizza I’ve had so far, now even organic!
… more
Ty R
This place is on another level. Freshest ingredients with an amazing crust. The wings are excellent and travel well. Highly recommend this place. It’s pure quality. It takes a little more time than your chains because of the quality to detail and the fresh ingredients. Well done NY PIZZA PIE, your product is pure class.
… more
Carolina Chavez
Two stars because I hold out hope for the pizza I will never try. I went in for sweet potato fries because I was craving them. An employee raved at how good they were. No. They sucked. And they’re sold by 2 oz,4 oz and so on. I got 4 oz not exactly knowing what to expect. But I hoped a fair amount for 6.99. nope. It came with a drink… which I didn’t know. So that was a plus… I guess. It was a small drink. So for 7.50, what could have been a normal meal. I got a handful of sweet potatoes fries. And a small drink I had no option in having. The picture is of the 4 oz fries. I can only imagine the waste of money for the 2 oz fry. Nope. Never again.
… more
bobby noobin
This place has amazing pizza slices and soda deals all day long. I called them today because it looks like they have moved. They moved down the street they’re still doing deliveries right now. I can’t wait until they open back up for slices and I can get a $5 slice and drink again. I would highly recommend to cheese curds as well. They’re homemade ranch is incredible. I have talked to the owner’s mother every time I am in there she’s a wonderful person. Thank you guys stay safe.
… more
Shawn Casselberry
NY Pizza Pie is no longer here. It is now a place called All Day Kitchens that has food from 13 different restaurants that you can order online and pickup or use a QR code in store. A couple of the restaurants they have food from are 90 Miles (cuban), Honey Butter Chicken, Jeni’s ice cream, Devil Dawgs, We didn’t get food here because we came specifically for NY Pizza Pie but the guy working here was really friendly. He said Google Maps hasn’t changed the name of this location so a lot of people, like me, don’t realize the place has closed.
… more
Amy Diestler
I just got back from a trip to NYC, and was craving a good slice of New York-style pizza. I saw that NY Pizza Pie on Ogden (across the street from Culver’s) had good reviews, so stopped in for a slice during lunch. I was blown away – this place is awesome! The pizza is authentic, very fresh, and just happens to be made with organic, local ingredients. It has a slightly crispy crust, with warm, gooey cheese. A great lunch place, at $4/slice plus free soda.
… more
… View more
