NYC Pizza Co. Menu – Bemidji, MN

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Bemidji, MN

Based on 37 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

NYC Pizza Co. 56601

Address:
Inside of Hard Times Saloon, 119 3rd St NW, Bemidji, MN 56601

Phone: (218) 208-3535

Website: http://lovenycpizzaco.com/

Hours

Monday

(Labor Day)
Closed
Tuesday 4 PM–1:30 AM
Wednesday 4 PM–1:30 AM
Thursday 4 PM–1:30 AM
Friday 4 PM–1:30 AM
Saturday 4 PM–1:30 AM
Sunday 4 PM–1:30 AM

Menu

Pizza
Ultimate Cheese Pizza
New York City’s famous thin-crust pizza, features our scratch-made red sauce and layered thick with mozzarella and parmesan.
$11.95
Maui Wowie Pizza
Sweet and savory red sauce topped with mozzarella, pineapple, sliced red onion, and Canadian bacon.
$13.95
Supreme Pizza
Hand-tossed thin crust with house red sauce and loaded with onions, sausage, black olives, green pepper, and mushrooms. A best seller!
$14.95
Margarita Pizza
Wood-fired Napili style, light tomato sauce, fresh basil, garlic, sliced tomato, and fresh mozzarella.
$13.95
The Empire Pizza
Thin and crispy crust, garlic and parmesan white sauce, thinly sliced red onion, fresh basil, chopped bacon, and grilled chicken and smothered in fresh mozzarella and parmesan.
$13.95
Appetizers
Garlic Cheesy Bread
Made to order, light and fluffy crust smothered in mozzarella, garlic butter sauce and freshly grated parmesan. Served with marinara or ranch on the side.
$4.95
Loaded Tater Tots
Golden and crispy tots, smothered in cheddar cheese, chopped bacon, garlic butter sauce, sour cream and fresh green onion.
$8.95
Crispy Chicken Tenders
Jumbo tenders, hand-breaded to order in our famous buttermilk Southern hand-battered boneless jumbo tenders fried to golden perfection. Served with your choice of dipping sauce and a big pile of fries.
$10.95
Cheese Fries
Crispy seasoned fries, smothered in our house made cheese sauce.
$5.95
Redneck Nachos
House-made flour tortilla chips, piled high with crispy fried chicken tenders, shredded Colby Jack cheese, smoked bacon house cheddar sauce, green onion, and a drizzle of BBQ sauce. Topped with chipotle sour cream.
$12.95
Sandwiches
Crispy Chicken Sandwich Deluxe
Hand-battered and fried crispy chicken breast served on a sweet brioche bun dressed in our tangy sauce, smoked bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and red onion. Served with fries.
$11.95
BBQ Chicken Sandwich
Crispy fried chicken breast, bacon, cheddar, house-made BBQ sauce on a sweet brioche bun. Served with fries.
$12.95
The Sweet Spot
New York Style Cheesecake
Thick slice of house-made cheesecake, topped with cherries and fresh whipped cream.
$5.95
Cake Of The Day
Every day we feature a different crafted cake election as what today’s feature is or be surprised!
$4.95

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Hannah O’Connor
FINALLY! Bemidji finally has a restaurant with good pizza! We got the cheese and pepperoni and they were both incredible. My husband cried tears of joy. Actual New York style crust too and their sauce is absolutely delicious. The staff were so friendly, and the gentleman held the door open for us, you won’t get that at other places. Will definitely be our new go-to pizza place!

… more

Hunter Bolte
This is a phenomenal pizza place here in town, and I feel it adds some necessary variety to the types of pizza we have to choose from. The pizza itself is thin and spiced perfectly. It also came with soup, salad, a bread stick, and dessert. The owners here are wonderful, and I certainly look forward to coming back and trying different pizza types.

… more

Sarah Sanchez
Wow… if you’re looking for NY style pizza, this place is your spot! ❤️ Great customer service, hand tossed pizza dough for that perfect NY folded crust, and excellent flavor combinations throughout their menu. We ordered the Empire Pizza, Honey Habanero Wings, and their daily special a slice of lasagna. I fell in love with each item and was so impressed with the overall quality. However, beware, this place is craveable. You will be planning your next visit while finishing your last bite of food.

… more

Isaiah Olson
This pizza is simply amazing and the pricing is competitive with other local pizza options in town. The style of pizza is different from anything else we currently have in Bemidji and it’s truly excellent. The crust is perfect and the sauce and toppings are also very high quality. Their house-made ranch is also excellent. Service is friendly and fast. If you haven’t tried them yet, I highly recommend it! Wishing for success and longevity for these new business owners. They have definitely made a strong start!

… more

Braelyn Paggen
this was hands down the BEST pizza ive ever had!!! definitely try the margherita pizza, it was amazing. my coworker who went to pick the pizza up said the service was incredible and that all of the employees were so nice. we definitely scarfed down the whole entire pizza!:)

… more

Matt Benz-Weeden
Ordered 2 pizzas for pickup. When we arrived we went into the bar and was told that the pizza restaurant was not open and hasn’t been for about a week. Even though they were closed they were still accepting orders online.

… more

Sally VanNyhuis
The pizza was delicious and it was nice to get drinks at Hard Times while waiting

… more

Marty Kennelly
Bought a couple of pizzas for supper. The whole family enjoyed them. Like the thin crust and lots of flavor. Nice to have another pizzeria in the neighborhood. Highly recommend!

… more

Carissa Angelocci
This was some of the BEST pizza I’ve ever had! I ordered the Margarita pizza and cheesy garlic bread and it was amazing! The sauce had so much flavor! You can bottle that s*** and I will buy it. We’ve hopefully sent you a dozen new customers!!

… more

Jamie Y
Delicious! If I could give them 10 stars I would. My coworker ordered the Margherita pizza and garlic cheese bread last night and it was amazing! And the guys were so nice when I went to pick it up. I ate it again today with my fam (different pizzas & wings) and we all loved it. Give them your business!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions