100% feel-good pizza. Light avocado oil crust. Thoughtfully sourced ingredients. Finally.
In a seaside shop on Nantucket Island in 2015, Oath Pizza was founded to create the first better-for-you pizza. Oath’s lighter, fresher, feel-good pizzas start with an award-winning crust that’s flash-seared in avocado oil, grilled to golden, crispy perfection and topped with chef-inspired flavor combinations.
We’re also available for delivery through ACK Eats! Now shipping nationwide on Goldbelly!
Based on 110 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
44 Straight Wharf, Nantucket, MA 02554
Phone: (508) 825-5963
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jeremy Scott
In the end, the pizza was really tasty. Yes, more expensive than you’d like, but it is what it is. You know the price going in.
… more
Stacey McKenzie
Augist 2023 update : Pizza tasted better than i remembered it from last summer. New flavors and sizes added to the menu. Salads are also available. Price range – pricey! The staff was great.
… more
B.P. A.
I came here because I heard they had gluten free pizza and my son loves pizza! I wasn’t expecting much from the gluten free but I was very impressed with the gluten free pie. The crust was very good and the toppings, cheese and sauce were great! I loved the choice and quality of toppings! I did one pie with roasted garlic and pickled onions. Really solid gluten free pie.
… more
Jenny Yaeger
Vegan and Gluten free options available. Was a really nice treat for me. Great atmosphere, great casual date spot. Loved the banza chickpea gluten free crust!!
… more
Cheri Jellerson
The crust is so crispy and the flavors are amazing! The view from outside while sitting at the picnic tables is gorgeous! I eat here every time when in Nantucket! I also like that you can order half a pizza if you’re not as Hungrey for a whole one!
… more
Aliza
This may be the worst pizza I ever had. We got “the works”. The Marinara sauce was tasteless. The ingredients were basic. And the cheese was weird. It broke apart but not that melting breaking apart. Save your money go elsewhere
… more
Eric Highers
Lamest pizza experience of my life. I’d like to see how this company can defend how a “large” pizza (spoiler alert: its less than 12 inches and 50% crust), and cheese sticks the size of a saucer are priced at nearly $50 for pickup after tip. I understand that Nantucket is an island but for the same price I could get a lobster roll and maybe even a drink to help numb my prior decisions of wasting my money here.
… more
Tyler Wakefield
Crust is indeed tasty and has a nice texture. Other than that, Farmer’s Garden pizza was pretty disappointing, pricy, and had us wishing we ordered from Foggy’s. Glad they’re moving the ball forward on more humane meat… besides that, not clear what the 100% feel good pizza thing is about besides simply repeating Papa John’s “Better Ingredients” slogan.
… more
Mike s
This was awful pizza. $81 for pizzas that don’t even have real dough is just a scam flat out. Don’t tell me that it’s high end ingredients either. Your sausage is processed garbage and pepperoni isn’t thick cut or anything special. One of the worst pizza experiences of my life. I’d be ok with the price if you weren’t selling me Boboli pizza shell with mediocre toppings. Whoever runs/owns this place should be ashamed. I do restaurant consulting and know first hand what quality ingredients are, and you guys do not have them. So stop lying to customers and own up to the fact it is overpriced trash.
… more
Sean Ryder
Great pizza, fantastic customer service. 10/10 would recommend a spicy clucker on the personal crust
… more
… View more