Old Mill Restaurant Menu – Evansville, IN

Type : Seafood restaurant

Location : Evansville, IN

Based on 149 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.0 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout

Old Mill Restaurant 47720

Address:
5031 New Harmony Rd, Evansville, IN 47720

Phone: (812) 963-6000

Website:

Hours

Sunday 11 AM–3 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday Closed
Thursday Closed
Friday 5–9 PM
Saturday 5–9 PM

Menu

Family Style Dinners
Adults: Available For 2 Or More People
Choice of: Fried Chicken, Honey Roasted Ham or Roast Beef. Served with: Mashed Potatoes, Cream Gravy, Green Beans, Sweet Corn, German Cole Slaw and Homemade Rolls
$12.95
Kids
Choice of: Fried Chicken, Honey Roasted Ham or Roast Beef. Served with: Mashed Potatoes, Cream Gravy, Green Beans, Sweet Corn, German Cole Slaw and Homemade Rolls
$6.50
Dinner Appetizers
New England Clam Chowder – Bowl $4.00
Soup Of The Day- Bowl $4.00
French Fried Mushrooms $9.95
Breaded Cauliflower $4.95
Homemade Onion Rings $4.95
(2) Shrimp Egg Rolls $4.95
Ranch Mix For Four $10.50
Shrimp Cocktail $7.95
Bread Basket For Two $5.00
Mozzarella Sticks $4.95
Chicken Tenders $5.95
Hot Wings $5.95
Entrees
Filet Mignon: 6oz $16.95
Filet Mignon: 8oz $19.95
Filet Mignon: 12oz $21.95
Rib Eye Steak: 8oz $14.95
Rib Eye Steak: Additional Oz $2.50
New York Strip: 10oz $15.95
New York Strip: 12oz $17.95
Porterhouse $18.95
Center Cut Pork Chop: 1/2 Lb $11.95
Center Cut Pork Chop: Whole Lb $15.95
Ground Steak $10.95
Prime Rib $15.95
Texas Cut Prime Rib $20.95
Sauteed Mushrooms & Onions $3.75
Baby Back Ribs: 1/2 Rack $12.95
Baby Back Ribs: Full Rack $18.95
Seafood
Catch Of The Day: Ask Your Server
Shrimp Maui $13.95
Filet Of Sole Almandine $12.95
Orange Roughy $14.95
Baked Scrod $12.95
Fiddlers $11.95
Trout $12.95
Frog Legs $13.95
Breaded Shrimp $12.95
Stuffed Shrimp $13.95
Stuffed Flounder $12.95
Red Snapper Florida $15.95
Alaska King Crab Legs: Mkt Price
Lobster Tail: Mkt Price
Combinations Dinners
Surf & Turf: Mkt Price
Sea & Shore $20.95
Beef & Claw: Mkt Price
Fowl
Chicken Ala Kiev $11.95
Chicken Cordon Bleu $11.95
Fried Chicken: Mixed $9.95
Fried Chicken: Qtr Dark $8.50
Fried Chicken: Qtr White $9.00
Fried Chicken: Half Dark $9.95
Fried Chicken: Half White $10.50
Fried Chicken Gizzards Or Livers $8.95
Charbroiled Chicken Breast: 8oz $11.95
Charbroiled Chicken Breast: 12oz $13.95
Pasta
Chicken Marinara $11.95
Fresh Vegetable Fettuccine $9.95
Pasta Seafood $12.95
German Specialties
Weiner Schnitzel $14.95
SauerBraten $12.95
Sandwiches
Reuben $8.95
Old Mill Tenderloin $8.95
Hot Brown $8.95
Club Sandwich $7.95
Hamburger
with American or Swiss cheese- additional $0.50
$7.95
Marinated Chicken Breast $6.95
B.L.T $5.95
Fish Fillet $6.95
Prime Rib Sandwich $9.95
Salads
Combination Salad $3.50
Sliced Tomatoes $2.50
Cottage Cheese
with fruit- $3.00
$2.75
Cole Saw $2.75
Pop Eye
Fresh spinach topped with real bacon bits, chopped eggs & our own popeye dressing
$4.50
Caesar Salad
with grilled chicken- $8.95
$5.95
Old Mill Chicken
Grilled chicken breast, dried cranberries and rubs
$9.95
Choice Of Vegetable $2.75
Chef Salad
Ham & Cheese $8.95
Shrimp $9.95
Chicken Breast $8.95
Breaded Chicken $8.95
Cobb Salad $9.95
Children’s Menu
Hamburger And Fries $4.95
Chicken Tenders And Fries $4.95
Side Potatoes
French Fries $2.75
Baked Potato
Sour Cream- additional $0.50
$3.75
American Fries $2.75
German Fries $3.75
Mashed Potatoes With Gravy $2.75
German Potato Salad $3.75
Dessert
New York Style Cheesecake
with strawberries
$4.50
Carrot Cake $4.50
Sundae
Chocolate or Strawberry
$3.95
Sinfully Chocolate
Name says it all!
$3.95
Pecan Pie $3.95

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Iambydefault
It took over an hour to get our food. When we did, it was cold. Potatoes tasted instant, (very cold), corn was cold and definitely from a can, green beans were unseasoned from a can, gravy on roast beef was too salty-likely a can or mix. Rolls were cold- decent but cold. Roast beef was stringy. We were offered no refills on our drinks. It was obvious they were understaffed, but the food wasn’t good either. This place used to be great! I’m sad.

… more

Beverly Ray
We enjoyed it very much. Loved the atmosphere. By the time our food came we were the only ones there. Our waiter never stopped working and was very attentive. We enjoyed our food and are glad we went!

… more

Regina Dillworth
Very dark inside. Very slow service. Buffet only on sundays very invited options. Came back from getting our food and there was someone else sitting at our table so we had to move. Definitely will not be back.

… more

Lindsay Cargill
I have to say Thankyou to the complete staff today on Sunday June 18th 2023. You have made this Father’s day wonderful for my family. Thankyou miss Susie for taking my last min order an making it more than I ever expected. Can’t tankyou you guys enough!

… more

Kristy Belt
We enjoyed our meal and our service! Understandably, some items were unavailable due to delays in deliveries. That didn’t stop us from having a nice meal and wonderful service from Will! It took a little while to get our food, but we were happy to have the extra time to spend together on our date night. Overall, good food, good service, would come back! Would recommend maybe having some good instrumental country music or something in the background, if possible. I loved the decor and the ambiance! It’s a really cool place if you have the extra time to dine ◡̈

… more

Rick Thomas
Love the place its self, but it was under staffed, poorly catered an illprepaired for reserved guests. I’m trying to be optimistic, I’m pretty easy to please. Overall it was aweful. Try it for the experience, or not.

… more

Adrianna Gerteisen
Food was good, service very slow and to dark inside. Seems they need faster servers.

… more

Stephanie Mann
This place was so awesome! The owner was so friendly. Made us feel right at home. The food was delicious. I loved Sandy’s dressing. She said it was her grandmother’s recipe. If we’re ever in Indiana again we will stop in and enjoy a delicious meal.

… more

Trixy Fay
My family and I went there for a Father’s Day meal back in 2015. The atmosphere was extremely dark, and whole place smelled like mold. The parking lot has huge potholes and the whole place needs MAJOR updating (looked like it was falling apart.) The food we ordered off of the menu took almost an hour and a half to get to us, and then we were told that they stopped serving things off the menu. I didn’t get the correct food when I got it. I was hungry so stole a few pieces of shrimp from my mom, one of the pieces was raw in one spot. There is also a hole in the buffet area which I had to step over several times. The only good thing about the place was our waitress’ attitude. She was very polite, but the entire place was way understaffed. If you’re like us and want to try it even if you’ve seen a few bad reviews, don’t waste your time. I don’t recommend it.

… more

Ted Miller
We had a fundraiser here. Sandy Mazzier did an excellent job. Very good meal of lasagna, rolls and salad. We had a bar and a bartender.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions