Old Mill Tasty Shop Menu – Wichita, KS

Type : Sandwich shop

Location : Wichita, KS

Sandwiches, ice-cream treats & more in an old-fashioned, family-run parlor opened in 1932. Based on 884 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Old Mill Tasty Shop 67202

Address:
604 E Douglas Ave, Wichita, KS 67202

Phone: (316) 264-6500

Website: https://www.facebook.com/OMTSWichita/

Social Profile:

Hours

Saturday 11 AM–3 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday

(Labor Day)
 11 AM–3 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 11 AM–3 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–3 PM
Thursday 11 AM–3 PM
Friday 11 AM–3 PM

Menu

Sandwiches
Hot Ham & Cheese
With choice of mayo or mustard on kaiser roll		 $6.75
Sliced Bbq Beef Brisket
On your choice of rye, wheat or kaiser roll		 $8.99
Muffaleta
Turkey pastrami, turkey, swiss & jack cheese, topped with olive salad and heated on kaiser roll		 $8.50
Vegetarian Muffaleta
Mushrooms, tomatoes, red onions, swiss & jack cheese, topped with olive salad and heated on kaiser roll		 $8.50
Reuben
Corned beef, sauerkraut & special mustard sauce on toasted wheat, marble rye or our vegetarian option		 $9.50
Vegetarian Reuben
Mushrooms, onions, tomatoes, sauerkraut, spinach, swiss cheese & special mustard sauce heated on marble rye or wheat bread
Pita Bread Stuffed With Hummus
Red onion slices, alfalfa sprouts, carrots, salsa, monterey jack cheese and tomatoes		 $7.75
Hot Turkey Pastrami
Monterey jack cheese on toasted marble rye with dijon mustard		 $7.95
Peanut Butter, Banana & Honey
Or peanut butter & jelly on white bread		 $5.50
Liverwurst
Lettuce, mayo, red onion on white bread		 $7.95
Club Sandwich
Ham, turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo on white toast		 $8.75
Toasted Chicken Salad Club Sandwich
Chicken salad, with bacon, lettuce, and tomato on white toast		 $8.75
Toasted Classic Blt
Bacon, lettuce, tomato with mayo on white toast		 $7.50
Tuna Melt
Homemade tuna salad on white bread with jack cheese melted on top. Served face open		 $8.50
Soups
Kc Steak Soup
Served with whole wheat rolls		 $4.00
Tomato Bisque
Served with whole wheat rolls		 $4.00
Green Chili
Topped with cheese and served with tortilla
Mexican Dishes
Chips & Salsa $3.50
Vegetarian Burrito
Whole beans, mushrooms and tomatoes topped with salsa, cheese, sour cream and sprouts gluten free without tortilla		 $8.95
Fiesta Salad
Fresh greens with tomatoes, cheese, green chilis, pinto beans, salsa, tortilla chip crumbles and sour cream		 $10.50
Cheese Crisps
Tortilla baked crisp with melted cheese, green onion, green chilies, topped with sour cream and salsa		 $8.95
Chicken, Sour Cream Nachos
Chips topped with melted cheese, chicken chunks, sour cream, salsa & jalapeno slices		 $8.95
Salads
House Salad
Crisp greens, carrots, cucumber and sprouts with two cheeses		 $7.95
House Salad
With chicken salad, crab salad or tuna salad		 $10.50
Spinach Salad
With chicken salad, crab salad or tuna salad		 $10.50
Chef Salad
Fresh greens, ham, turkey, tomatoes, cheese, egg and bacon		 $12.50
Spinach Salad
Tender spinach leaves, red onion slices, egg slices, served with our special hot bacon dressing or your choice of homemade dressings		 $7.95
Blue Plate Special
Changes daily – please check menu board
Beverages
Milk
Chocolate Milk
Coffee Or Tea
Orange Juice
Side Orders
Ham $2.50
Sausage $2.50
Bacon $2.50
1 Egg $1.50
2 Eggs $2.25
Potatoes $1.25
Toast $1.75
Biscuit $1.25
Blueberry Muffin $125.00
English Muffins $1.25
Tortilla $1.00
Sour Cream $1.00
Side Of Salsa $1.25
Side Of Gravy $2.75
Side Of Green Chili $2.50
Drinks
Fresh Ground Coffee $2.25
Milk $2.25
Ice Cream Specialties
1 Dip
In a dish		 $2.00
2 Dips
In a dish		 $3.50
1/2 Sundae $4.50
Aspen Snowball
1 dip vanilla, hot fudge, coconut		 $4.25
Malts And Shakes
Choice of flavors, made the old-fashioned way, includes one ingredient		 $5.25
Ice Cream Soda
Choice of flavors		 $4.25
Banana Split
Vanilla, chocolate and strawberry ice cream with banana, chocolate, pineapple & strawberry toppings, nuts, whipped cream, cherries		 $6.95
Floats
2 dips of vanilla, choice of soda pop		 $4.25
Turtle
2 dips of vanilla, butterscotch & hot fudge topping. pecan halves, whipped cream and cherries		 $5.95
1/2 Turtle $4.50
Very Cherry Sundae
One dip of vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, maraschino cherries, and bananas and whipped cream		 $5.95
Old Mill Special
Vanilla, chocolate and strawberry ice cream; marshmallow, chocolate, strawberry topping. whipped cream and cherries		 $6.25
Hot Fudge Brownie Delite
Brownie topped with ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, pecans and a cherry		 $6.25
Cones $2.00
Homemade Desserts
Homemade Carrot Cake
With cream cheese icing and pecans		 $3.95
Apple Bread Pudding
With homemade caramel and whipped cream		 $4.95
Homemade Brownie $2.25
Others
Huevos Rancheros
Corn tortillas with beans, cheese, red or green chili, topped with two eggs		 $7.75
Sausage & Green Chili Omelette
Made with fresh new mexico green chilies and sausage topped with hollandaise		 $7.75
Breakfast Burro
Eggs, cheese, and chilies in a flour tortilla, topped with red or green chili, and cheese		 $7.95
Spinach Omelette
Spinach, onion and mushrooms with cream cheese topped with hollandaise		 $7.75
Sunnyside Chilies
Chopped new mexico green chilies topped with monterrey jack cheese, basted with two eggs		 $7.25
Desert Omelette
Egg omelette stuffed with artichoke hearts, sprouts, tomatoes, and mushrooms topped with hollandaise		 $8.25
Eggs Benedict
Muffins, ham, poached eggs topped with hollandaise		 $7.25
Bacon & Cheddar Omelette
Topped with hollandaise		 $7.75
Sausage, Ham Or Bacon $5.95
Ham & Cheese Omelette $6.25
French Toast $3.95
Half Order $2.25
Biscuits & Gravy $5.95
Pancakes
Regular or blueberry		 $5.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

David Peck Jr.
The restaurant was clean and has a nice atmosphere. Service was friendly and quick. I was a little irritated that the sever immediately started pushing milk shakes. I understand that I had kids with me but I wanted them thinking about lunch before desserts. The Reuben was okay, the side of potato salad was pretty bland. My daughter had the chicken salad sandwich which was very good and the winning choice out of the group. The club sandwich and ham sandwiches were also described as okay. The price for four meals was acceptable. The 4 stars is for the chicken salad, it is worth a return visit. I wouldn’t discourage anyone from trying the Old Mill Tasty Shop but I wouldn’t say it is a must try either.

… more

Melissa Reed
My boyfriend and I were visiting from NYC, and because this was his first time to Kansas (and actually the Midwest), he was very excited to visit an old school soda shop.

… more

J.D. Wilson
The Old Mill Tasty Shop is, and has been a staple of the Wichita community since my earliest memories (like 3 years old). They have wonderful food options, but they are most famous for their malts and desserts. When you get a malt here, they literally give you the metal mixing cup with all the extra inside (great for sharing, or hogging for yourself). If you’ve never been to the Old Mill Tasty Shop, you are definitely missing out on the true Wichita experience. Give it a go! Great pricing, great food, and awesome malts/shakes! This is one of my top 10 restaurant suggestions for Wichita, Kansas!

… more

Jason Garraway
Great little sandwich shop! I had the chicken salad sandwich with a side salad. My meal was served promptly, and according to order. It reminded me of the way my mom made sandwiches growing up.

… more

Lisa Towle
Always a great meal here. The chicken salad is legendary, but you can’t go wrong with the club sandwich, green chile, or blue plate special. Save room for dessert – anything from the pies to cakes to shakes are amazing!

… more

Bily Curless
I have been eating at Old Mill Tasty Shop since I was a little kid back in the 1970’s and 1980’s. My Dad used to bring me here for Ice Cream Floats and Malts. The food is awesome and the atmosphere is fabulous. The employees are great. I strongly recommend eating at Old Mill Tasty Shop. It’s a really cool old place. Keep up the great work. May God bless you always!

… more

Joel Taborsky
Had excellent service they were very attentive to all of our needs and the food was awesome I took my ex’s Grandma there for the first time and she loved the food and the atmosphere thank you to the people at Old Mill tasty shop…! 9.5

… more

Veronica Kindersmith
I am not from the Wichita area but when I do come down for my business trips I always make it a point to come here for lunch! The owners have huge hearts and because of that every employee working here is always insanely happy and accommodating. The toasted chicken salad club is perfectly buttery and toasty with each bite and the chef definitely know how to make a mean green salad! Their cherry limeades are fresh made and so much better than Sonic. Come here for a real cherry limeade!

… more

Mary Sendall
First time there and our waiter Nathan was the best! He walked us through favorites and specials. We had the blue plate special Monterrey, the muffaletta sandwich with potato salad, carrot cake and a special cinnamon toast crisp shake. All of it was very good. The restaurant is great to still have the original soda counter and make shakes and malts and ice cream sundaes there. Nathan was great, very helpful, and seemed to know exactly what we would like. This is a Wichita gem.

… more

Ali Denison
Amazing as always. Such a welcoming place. The food is fresh and tasty. Friendly service. Clean. Reasonably priced and good sized portions. Don’t forget the shake, malt or float. Delish!!!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch