This snug counter serve features build-your-own & specialty pies, plus subs & salads. Based on 583 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
12 E 4th St, Williamsport, PA 17701
Phone: (570) 326-1466
Website: http://oldschoolpizzashop.com/menu.html
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Friday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 12 PM–12 AM |
| Monday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
S Bolles
We stayed a few days in town and came across this place. It was 10000000% delicious!! The service was fantastic. The pizza was so good. Cheese bread was delicious. And the prices are amazing. You can feed a army here and not break the bank. We 100% recommend.
… more
Darien Stuart
We love this place, the pizza is amazing and the cheese cosmo. The service is pretty quick too.
… more
Buck wild Marco
I ordered a FFF TON of food. It was all out and hot to my table in under 15 min mid day. The lady working the desk (had a few tattoos) was extremely nice and helpful. My only complaint is they don’t have a soda machine. While I do workout When it comes time to eat like dog s*** I like to wash it down with a half gallon of coke just to do me in and make the most of it. EAT HERE AT LEAST ONCE. YOUR FOOD WILL BE DONE FAST.
… more
Lily Summerson
Great pizza, subs, and appetizers. Portions are always big for the price and the food is well made!
… more
Ryan Crawford
One of the only delivery services around which is great. Food usually takes 45 to 90 minutes from order to delivery, which is normal. Staff, including drivers, are usually great. Wings and pizza tend to be inconsistent, often well overcooked or very undercooked. I know staffing is difficult right now, so I give Old School a B-.
… more
Chandra la
Not only great pizza, great people
… more
Patrick Turner
Got a stromboll. Not to impressed .they used to be the best in town. Not now. They should go back to the old school the way it used to be. Even if you have to charge more. Still love the pizza.
… more
Courtney Cizek
Get the three cheese cosmo. You won’t regret it. Your bowels might if you are lactose intolerant but your heart won’t.
… more
Erica Splain
Never again will I order from here. Although we had bad experiences in the past w th quality of our food from here, I want to give it another chance because I have ordered and gotten pretty good food a couple of times. This time we ordered half a chicken cheese steak, half a reg cheese steak and breaded mushrooms. My husband wanted extra mayonnaise and got hardly any, his steak was crispy, the lettuce on my sandwich was wilted and smelled bad. The mushrooms as you see were mushy and undercooked. There may have been 6 of them. Just complete disappointment. Sorry, this place is not worth the money or the wait.
… more
Amber Walker
Really delicious Garlic White pizza and stromboli!! Very hard to stop eating it as it was so good! Location is a little inconvenient as it is on the street, but service is quick and staff are friendly.
… more
… View more