Our Neapolitan-style pies are quickly crafted in our 800° wood-burning ovens, and served with 20 taps of local and regional craft beer, in a casual and communal hall. If you are looking for more than pizza, we have not-your-average-pizza-place salads, fire-roasted veggies, and gluten-free and vegan options too.
Based on 890 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
440 Miamisburg Centerville Rd, Centerville, OH 45458
Phone: (937) 886-4513
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Pamela Lyle
Late afternoon/early evening visit of 2 adults and a preschool age child. Our first visit.
… more
Scott Lewis
This was my first time. The atmosphere was just great. Seemed very contemporary, open and inviting. The menu was a bit difficult to navigate, but we managed quite well with four kids and two adults. I was a bit surprised the pizzas were so small, but they were tasty. Luckily we ordered humus for appetizers and a few salads, or else, we would’ve left hungry after eating two pizzas.
… more
Ashlyn Blatz
Been a fan for years! The Centerville location has so much Light, phenomenal pizza and surprisingly incredible veggies!!! Great beer selection. Wonderful Service! Love this place. A Centerville MUST.
… more
Kim Walker
I generally use pickup because I live 35-40 minutes away but whenever I’m anywhere nearby I pick one up for my dad. He says it’s the best pizza he’s ever had – and I can’t disagree. Service and quality has always been outstanding. Would love to have an Old Scratch in my town.
… more
Sarah Lilie
We walked in on a Friday early evening, and it was a full house. They were doing hostess seating, which we had not encountered at that location before. It was a little confusing because the hostess would see you when you went up to order but the guy working the checkout would wait for her to pick out a table before you could place your order so they were sure you had a seat. I don’t know what a better way to do it would be or what it would look like, but it was just confusing for our first time experiencing that setup. The pizza here is why people come here honestly, but I really like their roasted cauliflower (be aware the topping has nuts in it). The pizza is pretty good. It used to be one of my favorites, but now I’m less carb crazy so it’s a good option when we’re in the area. They have a decently lengthy beer selection here, but it feels IPA/hopp heavy, which is probably due to the crowd it attracts, so I generally just get a fountain soda. One cool thing about Old Scratch is that they have a soft serve ice cream machine where you can buy a cone for a donation, and all the money goes to the cause of the month. The vibe here is a little industrial, pretty chill/relaxed. Overall, we’ll be back because my husband loves their pizza, and it’s usually loud, so it doesn’t matter as much if my kids are loud.
… more
Henry Brierton
Great place to eat and drink. Love the expansive beer selection, and that the beer counter is separate from food to keep things moving. If you like unique wood-fire style pizza, it never disappoints. This location doesn’t have quite as much charm as the original, but it’s much less crowded and better for large groups.
… more
Jake DOG
This place is always top notch. I grew up in Colorado where there is quite a few wood fired pizza places, and this place brings back memories. Wood fired pizza rocks and if you’ve never tried it you should give it a go. Also I work at a bar right by it and I love driving by and seeing all the stacks of fresh wood in the back for the ovens, it’s a nice touch. I mostly get carry-out but once in awhile I eat in and it looks like they have a lot of cool stuff for the kids, soft serve machine, video games, but I come for the pizza so I can’t really comment on that stuff. It’s a great place and I wanted to share some love. Cheers!
… more
Jeff V
One of the best neopolitan pizza restaurants in the area! Lots of parking, ordering is easy, and the service and food is quick. The dining area is very expansive, and the patio area has plenty of space for medium sized parties. The personal pizza lunch special is the way to go.
… more
Gary Yurco
Extremely disappointed in tonight’s pizza. Ordered Mr Scratch with bacon, mushrooms & extra sauce. I prep time seemed ridiculous but it is Saturday night. An hour from the time I placed the order to pick up time. I arrived about 5 minutes ahead. Pizza was ready. Box was barely warm.
… more
Joseph Taggart
The food is consistently good at this location. They are generally very friendly and services pretty quick. They always have a great selection of beer on tap. It is a little bit on the pricier side, but definitely delicious. Absolutely get an ice cream when they offer it. It can be very noisy in there sometimes which kind of destroys the atmosphere. Otherwise, the atmosphere is very nice and very open.
… more
… View more