Based on 44 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.9 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ No delivery
Address:
1432 Old Tioga Turnpike, Stillwater, PA 17878
Phone: (570) 855-8108
Website: http://www.oldtiogafarm.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 6:30–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 6–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: resy.com
Reviews
Justine Sagan
Exquisitely prepared five course meal for $70 per person (tax and tip included in price). I didn’t get a picture of the gnocchi and tiramisu because I devoured them almost instantly. What a unqiue experience to dine in an old farm house! Dillon is just the best host and Justin’s cooking is out of this world. This place is top notch!
… more
Mark Robbins
Do Justin and Dylan Naylor need another positive review? Probably not, just look at their average score. The bread and butter alone is the best I have had on three continents. This is serious food and worth the tariff.
… more
Kyle Schu
MANGIARE! MEANING FROM THAT OH SO ITALIAN WORDS: LET EAT ! (My Dad) Mr. Karl Schu Birthday Dinner On Sat: 1/4/2020 That I Treated Him To At The Old Tioga Farm In Stillwater, PA 17878 of where 1st time going here and we be back again as it was amazing and mouth watering as thee Chef’s / Owners Justin and Dillon Naylor where right on the spot cooking up the such homemade foods and drinks as we ate the 5 course dinner that was all locally fresh foods and drinks from thee area / around in PA USA as we both had to eat somekind of toasted potatoes braised meatballs soup with leeks and smoked prosciutto potato gnocchi with sausage & cream braised beef with tomatoes & celery puff pastry with apples & cinnamon with beer to drink as we got some to take with us since this place is BYOB where by then also they gave us ice cold very fresh sparking water to drink to lastly a nice hot cup of steaming homemade espresso coffee with the coffee bean being fresh from Philadelphia PA as i say in Italian: il cibo era così delizioso grazie Chef / proprietari Justin e Dillon Naylor meaning the food was so delicious thank you Chef’s / Owners Justin and Dillon Naylor as here is the farm and restaurant Menus & Reservations Reservations can be booked exactly one month in advance beginning @ 9:00 am. (For example, Nov 14 for Dec 14). To join the waiting list for a night which is sold out, click on the “notify” button for any night which is sold out. You’ll receive an email if something opens up. Friday 6:30-9:30 pm and Saturday 6:00-9:00 pm • Our prix–fixe menu costs $65, including 6% PA sales tax and gratuity. We are BYOB. • We can accommodate tables of up to six people. • We accommodate vegetarians, but only upon advance request. And the Menus changes once every 1 month of this truly a must try but you must book very early to get a table because most thy tables are booked before the new month is over or till is half i the new month is started so just book early a spot would preface for a date night too i mean you won’t regret it so thanks all 🙂
… more
Will Schlosser
Dining at Old Tioga Farm was a unique and awesome experience. We enjoyed every minute and every course. The food was amazing and we hope to go back.
… more
Kristina Carry
An amazing culinary experience. Justin’s attention to detail in every plate he prepares is impeccable. You can truly see his passion for what he does and it shows in his food! Everything from start to finish was amazing but the pasta was by far our favorite part of the meal. Ingredients are fresh and delicious and atmosphere is intimate and romantic! Perfect for a date night! Cappuccino was the perfect ending as well!
… more
Ashley Crispin
This was a complete dining experience with excellent food, amazing hosts, and the cuisine was unbelievable. The ingredients were fresh and taken care of in a way that highlighted the flavors of each dish. Highly recommend going here for dinner, even if you come to the area just to eat here. We will definitely be back.
… more
Matt Yeastedt
The atmosphere is an old farm house that has a very warm feeling. The waitress was very pleasant and courteous. The food was very good. Be aware this is a 5 course meal that is spread out over a few hours and if you make reservations, everyone partakes in the same meal. I look forward to going back in the future.
… more
Kyle Marshall
Simply amazing! Justin and Dillon graciously open their home and farm to guests for an incredible evening of great food and relaxed atmosphere. The menu is simple and elegant and everything we had was delicious. I highly recommend dinner at Old Tioga Farm.
… more
Deidre Kaminski
Such a lovely quaint home . We dined in the private room. Service was excellent . Best bread ever.
… more
Matthew Prosseda
Absolutely the best food for 100 miles. Wonderfully prepared and presented prix fixe menu that always delights. BYOB means you can bring what you love. A little hard to get in, but we love it.
… more
… View more