Based on 261 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
410 Old Town St, Guntersville, AL 35976
Phone: (256) 582-1676
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 5–9 PM |
| Friday | 5–10 PM |
| Saturday | 5–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 5–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 5–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ryan Robley
Great little restaurant! We made reservations via email for a party of 6. Everything went smooth. We arrived a little early and went to a pub nextdoor.
… more
Amanda Epperhart
Service was fantastic! Super friendly! Tried so many things from the menu and enjoyed every bite! Didn’t get pictures of everything because we ate it so fast!
… more
Alysia Rabourn
We had such a lovely experience dining out for our fifth year anniversary. Great service, wonderful drinks, exceptional food. The filet was outstanding, and the black grouper was so fresh and cooked perfectly. Oysters from Prince Edward Island were some of the cleanest we have ever had. Highly recommend this little hidden gem in an unlikely place! Compliments to Chef Crystal.
… more
Nika Heart Boyd
Great experience, service is good, food is jusr ok, no wow factor but fine. Its
… more
Robert Kazupski
Everything about this place was perfect from the atmosphere to the food to our server. My fiancee had the stuffed chicken and I had the swordfish and they cooked to perfection. Lex was our server and had a great personality, was very knowledgeable about the menu and was very accommodating when it came to substitutions. All in a perfect experience and we found our new go to spot when we’re in Guntersville.
… more
Tori Rodriguez
If you’re looking for something different than the other restaurants in the area, this is it! Amazing food, friendly staff! Jake was our server and he was super kind and helpful. Hubby and I made a last minute decision to stop by after fishing and we were glad we did! Everything from the appetizers to the deserts were delicious! We even got complimentary glasses of champagne for our anniversary. We will definitely be back!
… more
Rex Marchant
Very exceptional dining experience. The Lobster Crab fondue was a delicious way to start. Everyone in our party of five had the 8oz Filet so I cannot speak to what the other entrees are like I can say the everyone’s Filet was cooked as ordered, we had requests from medium rare to we’ll done. Melt in your mouth DELISIOUS! It’s served with potatoes, mushrooms and a nice flavored sauce. This was mine and my wife’s first time in Guntersville and this was the first place we went. For a comfortable feel and upscale dining experience it would be hard to draw me away to another spot. Enjoy!
… more
M Cole
Have wanted to dine at OTSH for a long time and finally made it happen. Dined at the bar due to my last minute reservation and it did not disappoint. Bartender Matt was welcoming, friendly and served us well. Food was great too! OTSH now on my list of top five favorites.
… more
tristan g
Top notch dining experience! The super cool 1901 bldg and well thought out decorations and adornments, the casual but professional wait service and of course the delicious food were well worth coming back for! We met the head chef/owner Crystal in Huntsville a few days before, and she urged us to come try out her restaurant in Guntersville. We were already going to be visiting my relatives in nearby Arab, AL so we took her up on her offer. And man, it did not disappoint! My uncle and his wife now have a wonderful new fine dining option they can come back to again and again that’s only 10 minutes away from them, and we can’t wait to come back for some different amazing dishes when we visit again from Colorado. The pork chop, the swordfish (special last night) and the Lobster/seafood bisque dip app were all to die for. Our waitress Emma was super friendly and very knowledgeable, and the music in the background was varied, eclectic and delightful. We spent around $300 for four entrees, a decadent appetizer we all split and a bottle of wine and four other drinks, so I felt that was quite reasonable for a fine dining night for four. I Highly recommend checking out this upstairs gem with old town charm and contemporary stylings in downtown Guntersville!
… more
Stacy Pitts
If you are passing thru Guntersville, this is a must. Pictured is, osso bucco, oysters on the half shell and escargot. All were absolutely exquisite. Highly recommend. The atmosphere is amazing. The bar keep was attentive and made an excellent margarita for me. Over all this place is a 10/10.
… more
… View more