Based on 82 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ Delivery
Address:
66 Main St, Glouster, OH 45732
Phone: (740) 767-9900
Website: https://www.oletimepizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 3:30–11 PM |
| Thursday | 3:30–11 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 12–11 PM |
| Monday | 3:30–11 PM |
| Tuesday | 3:30–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Jax Hanshaw
I don’t normally do reviews but I’ve lived close to this place for almost a year and am just now trying it! It’s way better than any pizza I’ve had in town! As well as some very great service! Thank you!!
… more
Jeff Pingle
Give credit when credit is due, our pizza subs were delicious tonight thank you for a meaty tasty sub and prompt service good job !
… more
Josh Miller
The guy who confessed to drunk driving is the best review. You went and picked it up. You made eye contact in the window and the pizza made you sick and you were drunk lol. Wow. Just wow
… more
Linny Lou
This place was never my go to but if somebody was to order it I would eat it.. it was never this bad though. So last night I accidentally ordered from here. I say accidentally because I looked up the number for Jacksonville Corner Pizza (it’s closer to me and cheaper than little Italy) well when I called I didn’t recognize the voice, she was kinda being snobby. I go to pick up and they told me I must’ve called ole time.. I didn’t want to waste their time so I headed over there. As I get to the window there is a girl who acted like she didn’t see us even though we’ve made eye contact over and over and finally a guy opens the window (nice as can be!) in the background this girl is complaining about having to clean, giving dirty looks just basically acting like she couldn’t do it and didn’t want to be there.. really I hate supporting businesses with people like that it makes me sick. BUT not as sick as this pizza made me. I was drunk and it didn’t even taste good. It’s ex pep ex che and it just looks as a regular amount. It’s burned on the bottom I mean this pizza tasted like burnt hotdogs. to put into context I had leftovers and I chose to eat ramen noodles instead. don’t get me started on past experiences normally the service is good but the food never is. Go to Jacksonville pizza if ur hung up on money or go to little Italy both are AMAZING.
… more
Ljames Hentrich
A smile and good attitude does wonders for impressions…
… more
Jessica Welsh
Awesome pizza if you love pizza eat here!!!
… more
Cindy Shifflet
I know the owners Well good is always made fresh & so DELISH
… more
Bones Does
Great food good prices.
… more
Gabriel Hickman
I really enjoy this place. Moved to the area few months back. I’ve ordered from here about once a week since I moved here. Staff is nice. Food is fresh. Fair prices. I dig it
… more
Willie Collins
Ole time pizza is a great spot to stop and eat. It’s clean, the employees are nice and friendly. Food is great and affordable.
… more
… View more