Oley’s Pizza Shoppe is a Fort Wayne favorite! We are known for our homemade double crust pizzas, including the monstrous Big 10, and our delicious garlic cheese bread. We use only fresh, quality ingredients in every order that leaves our store. Customers can enjoy their pizza in a family friendly atmosphere at this family owned and operated restaurant.
Based on 799 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1427 N Coliseum Blvd, Fort Wayne, IN 46805
Phone: (260) 424-8900
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed
Holiday hours
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
candyse trimm
I ordered a large single crust with 3 toppings. It is so thin it was just sliding off. The amount of cheese was horrible there was more cheese than crust and the toppings were pretty well extinct. The pizza sauce tasted spoiled (very off flavor) 33 dollars and didn’t even finish a piece. The staff was friendly. I don’t remember oleys being a so-so place not sure what changed.
… more
Laura Bobay
Melt in your mouth pizza goodness!
… more
Robby Peverly
Oley’s Pizza Shoppe… What can I say? It’s been years since I’ve been here. Why so long? I don’t know. The Double Crust Deluxe (THE BIG 10) is everything I remember & more. So good. Did I mention it weighs 10 pounds? My next return will be sooner than the last.
… more
Dorian
Oley’s pizza has amazing flavor! You can’t sat they are skipping on the toppings. First layer covered with meat. If you want it cooked longer just ask well done. Over all amazing experience with it being my first time here. The waiter always served you with a smile. The Atmosphere is Fort wayne with pictures of different landmarks from past and present. It does have a pizza sport bar feel. When you pay the check you have to at the counter they don’t take it at the table.
… more
candace pescosolido
The atmosphere is fine for a little pizza shop. But the pizza was expensive compared to other places. The deluxe pizza in 16in (a large) was about $25 for the reg thin crust. If you want dbl crust, it’ll cost you almost double (around $46) for doubling the dough (seems more reasonable just to get a second pizza with all the toppings at that rate)
… more
Melanie Carter
Stopped in for a bite to eat and were super impressed by the pizza! Our pizza was delicious and the servers were very friendly. I was happy to learn that Oley’s is family owned and that they strive to serve the most natural foods that they can. And use locally sourced ingredients as much as possible, too.
… more
Ryan Rodgers
The waiter came out with 3 drinks, one was in his arm with his shirt over it, everyone that needed a refill had to ask for it, brought new plates out with his thumb on top the plate. We asked him to take the empty used plates, and he didn’t. The new owner have changed the recipe because it didn’t taste the same.
… more
Joe Frame
Delicious! It’s a great little place to stop for pizza. Wait staff was very good. Pizza was great and the garlic cheese bread was very tasty. The bread was smaller than I imagined, but it’s worth ordering. The double crust pizza is very good, and something you should try. We had a group of over 20, we ordered, ate, paid, and left within about an hour. The pizzas came out very quickly and we’re cooked to perfection. Definitely a must try restaurant.
… more
Alex Riggers
Oleys is famous pizza around here and I can be honest and say I’ve never had it. Left work and ordered an extra large cheese pizza for carry out, single crust as they say here. Man on the phone was friendly, upbeat and seemed happy to help. He told me the pizza would be done at 5:45 and it was done at exactly that time. Not much to the inside of the restaurant itself, very megar and simple, but adequate at the same time.
… more
Mark David
After reading numerous reviews, we had to try this local favorite. I’m a person who loves pepperoni, so I naturally gravitated towards the double crust pan pepperoni lovers. I’m not sure how much “love” there was because my pizza had very little pepperoni on it. Also, I’d say the crust is a little difficult to swallow and hard. The pizza was also smaller than expected given the hefty price. The double crust and second layer of cheese was the saving grace along with the delicious and reasonable priced garlic bread. The wings of fire were delicious and just the right level of spicy.
… more
… View more