Original Italian Pizza Menu – Sayre, PA

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Sayre, PA

Original Italian Pizza was opened in 1972 in Sayre, PA, and has been providing high quality food to our community ever since. Original Italian Pizza is a family owned restaurant. Our mission is to provide the local community with exceptional quality food at a fair price. We take pride in serving our community the best pizza and Italian cuisine in the valley.

A mix of standard Italian fare, from pizza to pasta to sandwiches, in a modest restaurant. Based on 712 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Original Italian Pizza 18840

Address:
205 S Keystone Ave, Sayre, PA 18840

Phone: (570) 888-9167

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–10 PM
Thursday 11 AM–10 PM
Friday 11 AM–11 PM
Saturday 11 AM–11 PM
Sunday 11 AM–10 PM
Monday 11 AM–10 PM

Menu

Pizza
NY Style Pizza $10.50
Regular Stromboli $9.45
Vegetarian Stromboli
Broccoli, mushrooms & sweet pepper		 $10.45
Hawaiian Stromboli
Pineapple & ham		 $10.45
Cordon Blue Stromboli
Grilled chicken & ham		 $10.45
Chicken Fajita Boli Stromboli
Grilled chicken, sweet pepper, onions & mushrooms		 $10.45
Townie Stromboli
Grilled chicken & broccoli		 $10.45
Sausage Roll Stromboli
Sweet pepper, onions & sausage link		 $10.45
Buffalo Stromboli
Chicken wing pieces, blue cheese & hot sauce mix		 $10.45
Steak Stromboli
Sweet peppers, onions, mushrooms & sauce		 $10.45
Calzone $9.45
White Pizza
Ricotta cheese & garlic base		 $19.50
Garlic Pizza $17.50
Vegetable Pizza
Fresh vegetables		 $19.95
Hawaiian Pizza
Ham and pineapple		 $19.95
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Chicken tender pieces, bacon, and ranch dressing		 $21.95
Townie Pizza
Grilled marinated chicken and broccoli		 $21.95
Original Italian Special Pizza
Sweet peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives, pepperoni & sausage		 $21.95
Buffalo Wing Pizza
Chicken wing pieces, blue cheese & hot sauce mix		 $21.95
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, ham and bacon		 $21.95
Steak Pizza
Onions, banana peppers, mozzarella & Cheddar cheese		 $21.95
Pepperoni Galore Pizza
Mounds & mounds of pepperoni		 $21.95
Margarita Pizza
Fresh garlic, olive oil, fresh basil, fresh roma tomato sauce, Romano & fresh mozzarella		 $19.95
4 Cheese Pizza
Mozzarella, Cheddar, American, and ricotta		 $21.95
BBQ Chicken Pizza
BBQ base, mozzarella cheese, and chicken tender pieces		 $21.95
Tomato Pie Pizza
Marinara sauce, Romano cheese, olive oil & basil		 $13.95
Taco Pizza
Taco meat, lettuce, tomatoes, Cheddar, mozzarella, taco chips, and side of hot sauce		 $21.95
Pesto Pizza
Pesto base and fresh roma tomatoes		 $19.95
Breakfast Pizza
Egg, ham, bacon, sausage, mozzarella, American & Cheddar cheese		 $21.95
Sicilian Pizza $21.95
Stuffed Pizza $28.95
Gluten Free Pizza $14.50
Italian Sub Pizza
Pan Pizza topped with Ham, Salami, Provolone, Mozzarella, Onions, Tomatoes, Lettuce, Italian Dressing, Parmesan Cheese & Oregano		 $25.95
Sweet Cup-O-Char $21.95
Large Specialty Half And Half $13.96
Sheet Specialty Half And Half $24.94
Large Specialty Half And Half BYO $14.48
Sheet Specialty Half And Half BYO $23.71
Cheese Slice $2.25
Garlic Slice $2.25
Italian Sub Slice $3.25
White Slice
Ricotta cheese & garlic base		 $2.75
Vegetable Slice
Fresh vegetables		 $2.75
Hawaiian Slice
Ham and pineapple		 $2.75
Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice
Chicken tender pieces, bacon, and ranch dressing		 $2.75
Townie Slice
Grilled marinated chicken and broccoli		 $2.75
Original Italian Special Slice
Sweet peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives, pepperoni & sausage		 $2.75
Buffalo Wing Slice
Chicken wing pieces, blue cheese & hot sauce mix		 $2.75
Meat Lovers Slice
Pepperoni, sausage, ham and bacon		 $2.75
Steak Slice
Onions, banana peppers, mozzarella & Cheddar cheese		 $2.75
Pepperoni Galore Slice
Mounds & mounds of pepperoni		 $2.75
Margarita Slice
Fresh garlic, olive oil, fresh basil, fresh roma tomato sauce, Romano & fresh mozzarella		 $2.75
4 Cheese Slice
Mozzarella, Cheddar, American, and ricotta		 $2.75
BBQ Chicken Slice
BBQ base, mozzarella cheese, and chicken tender pieces		 $2.75
Taco Pizza Slice
Taco meat, lettuce, tomatoes, Cheddar, mozzarella, taco chips, and side of hot sauce		 $2.75
Pesto Pizza Slice
Pesto base and fresh roma tomatoes		 $2.75
Breakfast Pizza Slice
Egg, ham, bacon, sausage, mozzarella, American & Cheddar cheese		 $2.75
Sweet Cup-O-Char Slice $2.75
Main Menu
French Fries
Shoestring Fries (fast food fries)		 $3.99
Cheese Fries
Fries Topped with a Mozzarella & Cheddar Cheese mix & Baked		 $5.50
Pizza Fries
Fries topped with Marinara Sauce & Mozzarella cheese		 $6.00
Loaded Fries
Fries Topped with a Mozzarella, Cheddar Cheese mix & Bacon		 $8.00
Garlic Bread $4.50
Garlic Bread With Cheese $5.50
Rice Balls $9.50
Bruschetta $7.50
Onion Rings $7.00
Deep-Fried Cauliflower $7.50
Deep-Fried Mushrooms $7.50
Broccoli & Cheese Poppers $8.50
Jalapeño Poppers $7.50
Mozzarella Sticks $7.50
Toasted Ravioli $7.50
Chicken Fingers $8.00
Buffalo Style Chicken Fingers $9.00
Fried Calamari $10.95
Calamari Fra Diavolo $11.95
Steamed Clams
Served with butter		 $11.95
Artichoke And Spinach Dip $10.95
Caprese
Fresh mozzarella, Roma tomatoes, roasted peppers, olives, fresh basil, topped with balsamic glaze and olive oil		 $10.95
Shrimp Cocktail $12.95
3 Pieces Garlic Knots $3.00
6 Pieces Garlic Knots $6.00
12 Pieces Garlic Knots $12.00
Garlic Knots $1.00
Caesar Salad $8.95
Chicken Bruschetta Salad
Marinated Chicken on top of Romaine Lettuce covered with Bruschetta, balsamic, & olive oil		 $13.95
Green Apple Chicken Salad $14.95
Bowl Soup Of The Day $6.00
Bowl French Onion Soup $6.50
Cup Soup Of The Day $4.00
Regular Buffalo Wings $7.49
Char Grilled Wings $7.99
1/2 Dozen Boneless Wings $6.49
Dozen Boneless Wings $12.99
Chicken Wraps
Grilled Chicken with Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, and ranch dressing		 $8.50
Cold Veggie Wrap
Sweet peppers, mushrooms, black olives, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, and oil		 $8.50
Sautéed Veggie Wrap
Cooked (Sweet peppers, mushrooms, black olives) with lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, and oil		 $8.50
Chicken Steak Wrap
Chicken Steak, Sweet peppers, sautéed onions, lettuce and spicy ranch dressing		 $8.50
Steak Wrap
Philly Steak, Sweet peppers, sautéed onions, lettuce and spicy ranch dressing		 $8.50
Turkey Wrap
Turkey, Bacon, lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, and ranch dressing		 $8.50
Buffalo Chicken Steak Wrap
Chicken Steak, Mild sauce, lettuce, tomatoes, and blue cheese on the side		 $8.50
Italian Sub
Salami, ham & cheese		 $9.00
Italian Mix Sub
Salami, ham, capicola & cheese		 $9.00
Roast Beef And Cheese Sub $9.00
Turkey And Cheese Sub $9.00
Tuna And Cheese Sub $9.00
Cold Combo Sub
Roast beef, turkey, ham & cheese		 $9.50
Ham And Cheese Sub $9.00
Veggie Sub
Sweet peppers, mushrooms & black olives		 $7.50
Cheese Sub
A Mix of American & Provolone Cheese		 $9.00
Hot Combo Sub
Mushrooms, onions, sweet peppers, sausage, and sauce		 $9.00
Meatball Sub
Meatball & sauce		 $8.50
Meatball Parmigiana Sub
Meatball, sauce & mozzarella cheese		 $9.00
Sausage Sub
Sausage and sauce		 $8.50
Sausage Parmigiana Sub
Sausage, sauce & mozzarella cheese		 $9.00
Sausage, Onions & Pepper Sub
Sausage, sweet peppers, and onions		 $9.00
Eggplant Parmigiana Sub
Eggplant, sauce & mozzarella cheese		 $9.00
Veal Parmigiana Sub
Veal, sauce & mozzarella cheese		 $9.75
Chicken Parmigiana Sub
Chicken, sauce & mozzarella cheese		 $9.50
Fried Ham & Cheese Sub
Fried ham & melted American cheese		 $9.00
Garden Fried Ham & Cheese Sub
Ham & melted American cheese with lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo & oil		 $9.50
Pizza Sub
Baked mozzarella cheese & sauce sub with choice of pepperoni or mushrooms		 $7.00
Fish Sub
Haddock, lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo & oil		 $10.00
Cheeseburger Sub
Lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo & oil		 $9.00
Pizza Burger Sub
Baked mozzarella cheese and sauce		 $9.00
Sautéed Veggie* Sub
Mushrooms, sweet peppers, black olives, with lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo & oil		 $8.00
BBQ Chicken Sub $9.00
Garden BBQ Chicken Sub
Lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo & oil		 $10.00
Chicken Finger Sub
Lettuce, onions, tomato, mayo & oil		 $9.50
Buffalo Chicken Finger Sub
Lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo, mild sauce & oil		 $10.00
BLT Sub
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo & oil		 $9.00
Chicken Steak $8.50
Steak $9.00
Chicken Cheese Steak $9.00
Cheese Steak $9.50
Pizza Steak
Mozzarella cheese & sauce		 $9.75
Garden Cheese Steak
Lettuce, tomato, onion, oil & mayo		 $10.00
Garden Chicken Cheese Steak
Lettuce, tomato, onion, oil & mayo		 $9.50
Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak
Mild sauce with your choice of blue cheese or ranch on the side		 $9.50
Garden Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, mild sauce, mayo & oil		 $9.95
Cheesesteak Special
Sweet peppers, onions, mushrooms & sauce		 $10.25
Chicken Cheese Steak Special
Sweet peppers, onions, mushrooms & sauce		 $9.75
8oz Cup Of Marinara Sauce $2.00
Extra Dressings $0.75
2oz Side Cheese $1.00
8oz Alfredo Sauce $4.00
Side Caesar Salad $4.00
Side 2 Meatballs $5.00
Side 2 Sausage Link $6.00
Bread $1.50
Veggies $4.00
Rice $4.00
Garlic Mashed Potatoes $4.00
Side Of Broccoli $4.00
8 Oz Cup $3.00
8oz Cheese Wiz $4.00
Extra Wing Sauce $0.75
Side Pasta $5.00
Large Dough Ball $3.00
Medium Dough Ball $2.00
Slice Of Pizza With Fries $5.50
Chicken Fingers With Fries $7.95
Spaghetti With Butter $5.50
Spaghetti With Marinara $5.50
Cheese Ravioli $6.00
Lunch Specials
2 Slices $6.49
2 Specialty Slices $7.49
Any Cold Sub
Any Cold Sub With a Drink		 $8.95
Any Hot Sub $8.95
Any Wrap With Chips $8.95
Cheesesteak & Fries $11.99
Small Calzone $9.49
Small Stromboli $9.49
1/2 Dozen Boneless Wings & Fries $11.99
Catering
1/2 Tray Pasta Marinara $35.95
1/2 Tray Pasta Alfredo $43.95
1/2 Tray Pasta Vodka Sauce $43.95
1/2 Tray Pasta Meat Sauce $45.95
1/2 Tray Baked Ziti $43.95
1/2 Tray Stuffed Shells $43.95
1/2 Tray Lasagna $43.95
1/2 Tray Eggplant Parmesan $43.95
1/2 Tray Chicken Parmesan $55.95
1/2 Tray Veal Parmesan $63.95
1/2 Tray Chicken Marsala $61.95
1/2 Tray Chicken Piccatta $61.95
1/2 Tray Veal Marsala $69.95
1/2 Tray Veal Piccatta $69.95
1/2 Tray Chicken Cutlet Bruschetta $61.95
1/2 Tray Gnocchi Marinara $40.95
1/2 Tray Gnocchi Alfredo $48.95
1/2 Tray Gnocchi Vodka Sauce $48.95
1/2 Tray Gnocchi Meat Sauce $50.95
1/2 Tray Tortellini Marinara $40.95
1/2 Tray Tortellini Alfredo $48.95
1/2 Tray Tortellini Vodka Sauce $48.95
1/2 Tray Tortellini Meat Sauce $50.95
1/2 Tray Chicken Riggies $58.95
1/2 Tray Chicken Cacciatre $58.95
1/2 Tray Spaghetti Caprese $58.95
1/2 Tray Ravioli Marinara $43.95
1/2 Tray Ravioli Alfredo $51.95
1/2 Tray Ravioli Vodka Sauce $51.95
1/2 Tray Ravioli Meat Sauce $53.95
1/2 Tray Fried Calamari $58.95
1/2 Tray Assorted Cold Subs $45.95
1/2 Tray Assorted Hot Subs $48.95
1/2 Tray Assorted Wraps $42.95
30 Meat Balls $67.50
30 Sausage Links $82.50
1/2 Tray Tuscan Blend Veggies $24.95
1/2 Tray Steamed Broccoli $24.95
1/2 Tray Garlic Mash Potatoes $26.95
1/2 Tray Wild Rice $24.95
1/2 Tray Bread $9.00
1/2 Tray Garlic Bread $27.95
1/2 Tray Garlic Cheese Bread $30.95
1/2 Tray Caesar Salad $24.95
1/2 Tray Chicken Bruschetta Salad $46.95
1/2 Tray Chicken Almondo Salad $48.95
Full Tray Pasta Marinara $69.95
Full Tray Pasta Alfredo $85.95
Full Tray Pasta Vodka Sauce $85.95
Full Tray Pasta Meat Sauce $89.95
Full Tray Baked Ziti $85.95
Full Tray Stuffed Shells $85.95
Full Tray Lasagna $85.95
Full Tray Eggplant Parmesan $85.95
Full Tray Chicken Parmesan $105.95
Full Tray Veal Parmesan $121.95
Full Tray Chicken Piccatta $119.95
Full Tray Chicken Marsala $119.95
Full Tray Chicken Bruschetta Salad $119.95
Full Tray Veal Marsala $134.95
Full Tray Veal Piccatta $134.95
Full Tray Chicken Riggies $112.95
Full Tray Chicken Cacciatre $112.95
Full Tray Gnocchi Marinara $79.95
Full Tray Gnocchi Alfredo $95.95
Full Tray Gnocchi Vodka Sauce $95.95
Full Tray Gnocchi Meat Sauce $99.95
Full Tray Tortellini Marinara $79.95
Full Tray Tortellini Alfredo $95.95
Full Tray Tortellini Vodka Sauce $95.95
Full Tray Tortellini Meat Sauce $99.95
Full Tray Spaghetti Caprese $112.95
Full Tray Ravioli Marinara $85.95
Full Tray Ravioli Alfredo $98.95
Full Tray Ravioli Vodka Sauce $98.95
Full Tray Ravioli Meat Sauce $102.95
Full Tray Fried Calamari $112.95
Full Tray Assorted Cold Subs $86.95
Full Tray Assorted Hot Subs $95.95
Full Tray Assorted Wraps $80.95
30 Meat Balls $67.50
30 Sausage Links $82.50
Full Tray Tuscan Blend Veggies $44.95
Full Tray Garlic Mash Potatoes $49.95
Full Tray Wild Rice $44.95
Full Tray Bread $18.00
Full Tray Garlic Bread $47.95
Full Tray Garlic Cheese Bread $57.95
Full Tray Caesar Salad $48.95
Full Tray Chicken Bruschetta Salad $86.95
1/2 Tray Chicken Almondo Salad (Deep Copy) $90.95
Desserts
Chocolate Cake $7.00
Carrot Cake $7.00
Classic Cannoli $5.00
Chocolate Cannoli $6.00
Tiramisu $6.00
Cheese Cake $6.00
Cheese Cake W/Strawberry Topping $7.00
Cheese Cake W/Blueberry Topping $7.00
Cheese Cake W/Cherry Topping $7.00
Italian Rainbow Cake $7.00

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Regina Excell
This place is a Valley staple. Since thier update a few years back it’s done nothing but go uphill. Great food and service. Prices have gone up, but just like everything else since the pandemic, and they are on point with other places to eat. They do great for dine in and take out. Delivery always takes a long time though, so don’t get french fries if you’re getting delivery, they will be cold. Also parking kind of sucks. But regardless of those negatives, this place still easily gets 5 stars for their food.

… more

Michelle Millard
Whenever we come back to the valley we always make a stop here.This was our go to place. The food was always good until this time.

… more

Janelle Robbins
Usually I love their personal Stromboli. However last night it can Gross looking, with like no cheese. Was very disappointed.

… more

Bridgette Dietz
My server wasn’t all bad but didn’t fix her mistake. I ordered a tomato basil pizza and she brought out a margarita pizza. Then she fixed it and she brought out a pizza that was very doughy and when I asked for basil my pizza came out with straight FULL LEAVES of basil so I took a bite and gave it the benefit of the doubt and it was like eating straight leaves and they tasted dirty so they didn’t even wash them. They are more concerned about getting food out than the quality of it. Then my boyfriend orders a buffalo and cheese sandwich and it comes out and he takes a bite and it burned his mouth really bad. But he ate it anyway. Not very good I don’t recommend coming here.

… more

Angel
Great place to eat. Their wings are AMAZING. I had a calzone and they’re good sized, if you get a large you’ll be taking some home. The bread is delicious as well. I’d definitely come again.

… more

Lloyd Wolford
What a great restaurant!!! This is all I can say about it. The ratings are a 5 star across the board. The prices on the menu are spot on reasonable. Even better deals on the special of the day. The location of the restaurant is located in three city blocks from a major medical facility. That means it’s the greatest place to dine before or after your appointment . In my case, it’s both.

… more

Yvonne Guest
We have been drastically searching for decent pizza since moving to the area. We tried like everything in Ithaca, horseheads, Elmira and “it’s ok” was the best we came up with. Until we went to this place in Sayre. We were at Robert Packer and OIP was suggested to us. It. Is. AMAZING. Flavor! It has flavor! And not sugared up spiceless flavor – REAL FLAVOR. It’s been 4 or 5 years since I’ve had truly good food but we finally found it!!! Love love love OIP SAYRE!!!!! Especially recommend the taco pizza, the buffalo pizza, the chicken bacon ranch.

… more

abraham george
An old favorite completely revamped and updated. The food and service is excellent as it always was. Definitely swing by and partake in some of the amazing choices on the large menu.

… more

Niki Sindoni
Not the delivery kids fault. He was apologetic and sincere. The food was mediocre at best. The pizzas weren’t even cut all the way through to pull apart. Some of the bigger boneless wings weren’t cooked all the way through. My 10 year olds chicken fingers were burnt. All of the food was also cold because the person on the phone completely bombed my address, EVEN after repeating it back to me. So the poor delivery driver was all over the valley looking for our house.

… more

Logan Hembrough
2/7/23 delivery, first thank you for delivering to truck drivers! Pizza was good, the boneless wings were absolutely phenomenal I swear that BBQ has a nice sweet taste then switches flavors half through each wing absolutely amazing! We need more places like this around!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch