Best locally-owned independent Italian restaurant in Garnerville serving my real, authentic recipes using only the freshest ingredients. Get the best pizza near you! Every dish is made with love and care to give you a great tasting and unique experience every time. Come taste the difference.
Basic spot for a variety of pies, fried starters, salads & Italian entrees in a simple cafe setting. Based on 362 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1 Main St, Garnerville, NY 10923
Phone: (845) 429-4862
Website: http://oiprestaurant.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Plot Twist
Paid $15 for this bull$hit shrimp platter
… more
TPOT TPOT
I always end up here when I come to have a straw and this place is absolutely amazing whether it’s the middle of the winter or just starting up spring. The staff is really nice and always look like they’re working really hard, I’ve seen the owner as well and he is devoted to his restaurant. I highly recommend coming here if you love Italian food basics like pizza, and lasagna.
… more
Ashley
This place has some of the best pizza I’ve ever eaten. Pictured below is their equivalent to a Supreme Pizza (I believe they call it Dumpster Pile, just know it comes with sardines) and it is glorious. Everything from their basic pepperoni/sausage pizza to this has always been perfect. Pricey, yes, but worth it.
… more
Charles Diamond
This was a random stop, needed a bathroom and a bite on a long trip.
… more
Nereida Miranda
No seasoning sometimes taste funny for them to call this an Italian food place not good.
… more
B C
Owners just changed. No more Italian just someone tried to learn how to do pizza. Lots of options are gone . Very disappointed.
… more
Thomas Smith
Food was good and they were open later than 9 which is a nice change for the area. A bit pricey at $5 a slice but the pizza was good. Parking is available out front but a bit more light would be nice in the parking lot. Staff was friendly and helpful. Would visit again.
… more
GUIDO ALBERONI
I’m a Google contributor and I have to say that the staff of this restaurant took care of an issue that I had with my order, and I really appreciate that. I’m the guy that told you guys that was flying back to Germany that day that they took care of me. I visited my brother in law and he told me about this place that the Baked ziti is really good and oh man was it good, yeaaaahhh it was; it actually tasted like my aunt’s baked ziti here in Milan, Italy that’s where my family is from. I’m here in Germany, I forgot to write the review. I have traveled to 40 countries around the world and posting reviews on Google, I recently received an email from Google saying that 3M people have viewed my reviews/photos of hotels and restaurants, so please if you’re not happy with a service or food, just go back and talk to them help them get better. I’m also from Brooklyn and yes there is no pizza like New York City’s pizza unless you come and have pizza in Italy.
… more
Angelo Llanos
Ate there a couple of times while I was living on the same block just 20 miles from there. Pizza actually good for the price. Plus it’s local so that helps out. If you ever need a quick slice, give them a call.
… more
Ezra Rain
Great food, and wonderful service. Great prices too!
… more
… View more