Paesano’s New York Pizza Menu – La Palma, CA

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : La Palma, CA

Based on 64 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price

Paesano's New York Pizza 90623

Address:
5440 Orangethorpe Ave, La Palma, CA 90623

Phone: (714) 521-4748

Website:

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Traves O’Neill
Half-way decent pizza hole with some other stuff and limited beer selection. Prices are good. $18 for an 18″ pie with 1 topping. We got the inflation beater which included 1-18″ large pizza with one topping, 6 garlic breads, 1-family style spaghetti, and 1-family size salad all for $32. This was enough food for the whole family and we had a little extra to take home. As far as quality of food goes… Well, it wasn’t amazing by any means. The sauce was bland but not bad. The pizza was good. Salty, greasy and authentic house made pizza with real cheese (although light). The salad was fresh, although the tomatoes were not ripe. The short of it, I would go again. Not great, but good.

… more

James Colannino
Crust was a little thin on the bottom (I prefer it thicker, but that’s just my own personal taste), but it was thick and bready on the edges, which is perfect for me, and had a great flavor. I have a hard time finding a good thick crust pizza, and if that’s your thing, you’ll enjoy this place 🙂

… more

rivasfreight
The antipasto salad was terrible. It had CANNED mushrooms and the salad was brown and wilted. The pastrami sandwich needs more meat. The atmosphere was uninviting as i waited for my food. I’ve met the owner and when he’s there everything is better. Unfortunately I don’t know his schedule so I just won’t be going back.

… more

Annette Arias
My favorite local pizza place. Food comes out quick and hot! Pizza does not disappoint, flavorful, not to bready, and freshly made! (They open 3pm daily) hope they open for lunch again soon!

… more

D K
Stop there 1/2/2020. OUCH. When we walked in the place was empy and very few lights on. Many of the things on the memu have been crossed off. It took them a long time to fix our order. When we started to eat it is when we noticed the crust was way to thick and was burned to a black black color. This place is no longer good. I would say find a differemt place to eat

… more

Esau Blanco
Pizza not very good. Got the chicken wings and tasted like fish fry. Could not actually identify them as wings. Some were drumsticks and others looked liked chopped pieces of chicken. Don’t wast your money.

… more

David Jacobo
Love this place! Awesome pizza and they have whole fried buffalo chiken. A bit on the dry side but theres something about it that just work!

… more

x x
What a find! A hidden gem this place is… Incredible food, incredible prices, great family style authentic service. This is truly one of the best spots for a large variety of options. Yum!

… more

Ron H
Went for drinks and apps. Family owned, mom and pop place. Small drink selection, food was good. I would come back for a drink or order to go.

… more

Dana Haimes
Best pizza I’ve had in about 10 years…I have kids, we eat pizza all the time, so that says a lot about the food here!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions