Pasta, pizza & other classic Italian comfort food served in easygoing surrounds with patio seating. Based on 739 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1235 E Washington St, New Castle, PA 16101
Phone: (724) 658-3066
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Rebecca McHenry
We ate there for the first time yesterday. I had the homemade cheese ravioli and it was phenomenal! The pasta was so tender and the cheese filling was very generous and so light and airy. I wish my own turned out as well. Restaurant was very clean too! Enjoyed it very much!
… more
Lori Boguszewski
The food was good . The homemade ravioli was excellent. It’s not my favorite sauce but definitely good. The wedding soup was ok but not great, lots of broth a few meatballs, no chicken or pasta. The service was very slow. It was mid afternoon so we were not exciting it to be as busy. We waited about 45 -60 for our food.
… more
Sherry Derhodes
I had the Tour of Rome last weekend. The ravioli were to die for. The chicken Parmesan was crispy on the outside & juicy on the inside & the fettuccine was just ok. Next time I wasn’t the lasagna or more ravioli! We had wonderful service!
… more
USVWPCA
The best Italian food!! They have a few sauces. We prefer the spicy marinara sauce with homemade cavatelli. I get sausage on the pasta, my wife gets meatballs. Their menu offers many options. This is our favorite place to eat out.
… more
Maryann Tuscano
Very disappointed over the last several take out orders. Wedding soup had only 2 little meatballs. The wilted chicken salad had 1 small tomato, soggy croutons, loaded with soggy fries & nothing else in it for $12.
… more
Linda Robbins
Our waitress was awesome she ran her butt off and was very attentive. I love the music there! Sinatra, Dean Martin and more Italian crooners! The fried greens are incredible and the New Castle red sauce is to die for. I am so thankful that Pagley’s survived COVD and is still going strong. Real incredible Italian food!
… more
Erica S
I live out of town and have been craving Pagley’s, so tonight I bought dinner for my family. I was SO disappointed in the quality of food that I honestly will never order here again. My fettuccini alfredo was bland, the chicken was hard and dry, and the salad was completely inedible. My salad was brown and my sister found black pieces of lettuce in hers. This meal was definitely not worth the $70 I spent. My mom liked her raviolis, which is the only reason I’m giving it 2 stars.
… more
Thomas Goldfinger
Tony never disappoints! His staff is on the ball! Never had a bad meal or experience at Pagley’s Pasta & More!!
… more
jjt T
Ever since COVID Pagley’s has declined. Below average food and HORRIBLE service. The waitress was snippy from HELLO and far more interested in whatever was going on at the REAR BREAK-PORCH. She did not speak to our table once. Never checked on us…NOT ONCE. I noticed she treated another table the same way. MANAGER: Why allow your service staff to behave this way. I AM DONE!!!!!
… more
Missy Suzuki
Thank you for the warm hospitality and amazing dinner.
… more
… View more